I’m wondering on the reasons for picking up the road bike as the easier option.
Is it because of the faff involved with MTB with possibly more kit perceived needed to carry and the clean up post mud ride?
And then many have said about not being close to trails, and in which case are you exclusively a trails/trail centre/singletrack rider or can you do some xc? Bridleways, paths, towpaths about?
I ride whatever and quite enjoy a local pootle as much as ripping around singletrack. Though I am lucky in having a huge amount of common land about. I keep finding more each week, even just small bits dotted around and then link them all up. Though plenty I know in the area say they have to drive miles to trails to ride because they’re only interested in the singletrack. To me I see singletrack all over the place, just they may not have been built for bikes, but they’re tracks that are the width of a bike.
Also enjoy a bit of urban off road. Has to be done more at night but loads of laughs. Paths between houses, local parks, through business parks, and empty multi story car parks are fun (if all cheeky) 😀