As I said, if a particular poster ends up taking a disproportionate amount of the mods’ (limited) time then I don’t see it as unreasonable behaviour to try and stop that problem using bans. It is a shame it comes to that though.
I’ve often considered setting up a new forum with a ‘no being a ****’ rule and pretty much anything else goes but I suspect that it’s not as simple as it appears, particularly to maintain or even to maintain the positives of this forum. Not to mention that you’d probably just end up with all the banned people from here on it while everyone else stuck on STW.