Home › Forums › Chat Forum › 2019 General Election
- This topic has 6,282 replies, 176 voices, and was last updated 4 years ago by kelvin.
-
2019 General Election
-
jjprestidgeFree Member
This is what McDonnell means when he says he’s a Marxist. He doesn’t mean he’s going to try and create a Marxist state. This may be confusing for some people but it’s how intelligent people talk.
Exactly. Pretty similar to how I see Marxism. It still goes that most people who use the word as some sort of insult have never even read the first page of Das Kapital.
The first page (and the rest) of Das Kapital is such a turgid pile of tedious, poorly written nonsense that I’m amazed that anyone has ever got past page 2, let alone been inspired to create a society in its image.
Let’s have a look at the first few paragraphs, to illustrate my point:
” The wealth of those societies in which the capitalist mode of production prevails, presents itself as “an immense accumulation of commodities,”[1] its unit being a single commodity. Our investigation must therefore begin with the analysis of a commodity.
A commodity is, in the first place, an object outside us, a thing that by its properties satisfies human wants of some sort or another. The nature of such wants, whether, for instance, they spring from the stomach or from fancy, makes no difference.[2] Neither are we here concerned to know how the object satisfies these wants, whether directly as means of subsistence, or indirectly as means of production.
Every useful thing, as iron, paper, &c., may be looked at from the two points of view of quality and quantity. It is an assemblage of many properties, and may therefore be of use in various ways. To discover the various uses of things is the work of history.[3] So also is the establishment of socially-recognized standards of measure for the quantities of these useful objects. The diversity of these measures has its origin partly in the diverse nature of the objects to be measured, partly in convention.”
JP
stevextcFree MemberWorking class brexiters* are just another example of the strangeness of human nature.
*correction
No it’s not… lots of working class people go to work… they get home and put kids to bed and they might get some time to try and keep in touch on the likes of FB before work the next morning.
his policies are excellent. Means nowt.
Many don’t have the time or energy left to read policies… they get some lies broadcast in FB circulated by friends (who got them from friends.. who got targetted by a russian bot)
kelvinFull MemberSo… what are they expecting Johnson to deliver for them, when Brexit is “done” in January?
raybanwombleFree MemberNo it’s not… lots of working class people go to work… they get home and put kids to bed and they might get some time to try and keep in touch on the likes of FB before work the next morning.
This isn’t an excuse – many of my friends work in the hospitality industry, they do ridiculously long hours as chefs and still manage to avoid being uniformed idiots.
What there is, is a large portion of the population who revere ignorance and actively applaud it – people who consider education and schooling to amount to nothing more than just being another brick in the wall.
Maybe my opinion is colored by the fact that decent chefs are usually bright individuals though.
tjagainFull MemberNo – maybe your view is coloured by the fact its obvious you have no understanding of how many folk live.
kelvinFull MemberReally? Lots of working people without two spare seconds to rub together can tell that Farage is a spiv, and Johnson an amoral liar who would rather piss on them than help them.
binnersFull MemberJust watching a party political broadcast for the Brexit party
If anyone is in any doubt that they’re heavily targeting the… erm… ‘unreconstructed’ labour votes, you wouldn’t be after seeing that.
The pitch is: you usually vote labour, but you voted leave. We know you can’t bring yourself to vote Tory, so vote for us instead so we can ensure Brexit
Subtext: we know you’re racist and you want them all sent back, but you can’t vote for that bumbling blonde dickhead, so vote for the proper racist party
I hate to say it, but they’re potentially a nightmare for labour in Tory marginal seats, this lot.
Dom and Dommer must be thanking the lord for the man-frog, and him not running in Tory seats.
They’ve got the same outriders on board as they had for the referendum, pulling the same stunts. And we all know how that went
raybanwombleFree MemberReally? Lots of working people without two spare seconds to rub together can tell that Farage is a spiv, and Johnson am amoral liar who would rather piss on them than help them.
+1
I haven’t met a bright working class individual who would vote Farage or Tory. I have however, met a lot on the wrong side of the educational distribution curve that would vote for the former.
Stating that they don’t have the time to be informed is just the soft bigotry of low expectations – chefs work 70-80 hour weeks, why have I not met one – in the 5 years I worked in kitchens whilst studying, that was a Tory or Farage voter?
RustySpannerFull MemberNo it’s not… lots of working class people go to work… they get home and put kids to bed and they might get some time to try and keep in touch on the likes of FB before work the next morning.
Lots of people have busy lives.
You can find time to inform yourself of current affairs, that’s what the radio is for.
And it’s not to do with class.
I mentioned working class people because my post was specifically dealing with Labour’s historic safe heartlands.
The most politically aware people I know come from working class backgrounds. Working class people have always had to fight to provide themselves with the knowledge and opportunity that the ruling classes would love to deny them.
The point applies to us all. Brexit voters of whatever social background have more similarities than differences.
tjagainFull MemberNo Rayban – once again you show your bigoted views and your complete lack of understanding
……………..and still manage to avoid being uniformed idiots.
What there is, is a large portion of the population who revere ignorance and actively applaud it – people who consider education and schooling to amount to nothing more than just being another brick in the wall.
Maybe my opinion is colored by the fact that decent chefs are usually bright individuals though.
So here we have naked prejudice, negative stereotyping and pure snobbishness all in one post.
a post you could only make because you have no understanding of the lives some people live and because you clearly hold bigoted and snobbish views about people you have never met
raybanwombleFree MemberSo here we have naked prejudice, negative stereotyping and pure snobbishness all in one post.
I’m sorry – but the “they don’t have time” doesn’t wash. A lot of people work long hours TJ – it’s giving people a poor excuse. This is more snobbish, it denies people any agency and allows the underlying issue (a poor education system that people are not connecting with) to be ignored.
Education is the issue, state schools do not equip people to be able to make rational and informed decisions in the modern world.
a post you could only make because you have no understanding of the lives some people live and because you clearly hold bigoted and snobbish views about people you have never met
I don’t give a **** what you think TJ, I’ve worked along side people who work more hours for less money than nurses like yourself.
binnersFull MemberInteresting stat of the day:
1.36 million people under the age of 35 have registered to vote
CaptainFlashheartFree Memberyou have no understanding of the lives some people live and because you clearly hold bigoted and snobbish views about people you have never met
Well.
mattyfezFull MemberBrexit voters of whatever social background have more similarities than differences.
I’d agree with that, short sighted and selfish.
RustySpannerFull MemberI’d agree with that, short sighted and selfish.
I think it’s far, far more complex than that.
Education is the issue, state schools do not equip people to be able to make rational and informed decisions in the modern world.
Nonsense. 🙂
I was about to defend you before you posted that little gem.Well.
Exactly. 🙂
roneFull MemberInteresting stat of the day:
1.36 million people under the age of 35 have registered to vote
Which apparently is double the amount for 2017 at this point.
raybanwombleFree MemberI think it’s far, far more complex than that.
https://www.theguardian.com/society/2012/jun/05/why-working-class-people-vote-conservative
Here we go – from 2012 – almost prophetic hey?
Also, not one mention of people working too many hours to care.
tjagainFull MemberWell Thats really good Rayban the ” some of my friends are poor” defense.
You are the man who claimed he knew what its like to be poor – with a university education adn £5000 in debt and having to flatshare. Sure thats just like being poor – my arse. The ability to get £5000 in cedit shows you are not poor. Your whole attitude stinks dude and you are unable to realise this due to the inability to realise that you have no idea at all about the lives of many in the UK.
The difference is that I know I am rich. Oh and CFH – accuse me of inverse snobbery and you might be able to make a case. Its not me thats looking down their nose here at the poor, the illeducated and illinformed
raybanwombleFree MemberYou are the man who claimed he knew what its like to be poor – with a university education adn £5000 in debt and having to flatshare. Sure thats just like being poor – my arse. The ability to get £5000 in cedit shows you are not poor. Your whole attitude stinks dude and you are unable to realise this due to the inability to realise that you have no idea at all about thelives of many in the UK
That student debt was sold to anyone at the time, without any care given as to whether they could repay it or not. I had little to no help from parents to go to university – nor any grants. Hence why I worked in kitchens or even as a baker – with the 4am starts to prep the bakery and then go to lectures.
I know I’m well off now though, you however are so wrong on this even the soft headed sociologists appear to disagree with you.
RustySpannerFull MemberHere we go – from 2012 – almost prophetic hey?
An interesting but ultimately flawed hypothesis (In my opinion, obviously), as it assumes an equivalence of the various standpoints (‘moral flavours’) given.
I prefer the explanation that it is easier to appeal to the basest aspects of human nature than the most altruistic.
A point I made some pages ago.tjagainFull MemberAch – I shouldn’t have got personal and for that I apologise but really rayban – try actually thinking a little and please stop saying that you have understanding of how many folk live when its clear you do not and stop denigrating those less fortunate than yourself. It stinks
raybanwombleFree MemberAn interesting but ultimately flawed hypothesis (In my opinion, obviously), as it assumes an equivalence of the various standpoints (‘moral flavours’) given.
I prefer the explanation that it is easier to appeal to the basest aspects of human nature than the most altruistic.
A point I made some pages ago.You should look at Haidts more detailed work – that isn’t watered down for a general audience, start with his wiki page and go from there.
Ach – I shouldn’t have got personal and for that I apologise but really rayban – try actually thinking a little and please stop saying that you have understanding of how many folk live when its clear you do not and stop denigrating those less fortunate than yourself. It stinks
I’ll try to be less obtuse next time in return TJ and I will try and use more subtlety in regards to my opinions. I do think the idea that people don’t have time is wrong though, we need to be giving people a sense of agency not telling them they don’t have any.
Citizen agency is at the root of our political malaise IMO.
RustySpannerFull MemberYou should look at Haidts more detailed work – that isn’t watered down for a general audience, start with his wiki page and go from their.
I shall, thank you.
And whilst the spirit of forgiveness and reconciliation is upon us I apologise for my characterisation of you as a ‘right wing frother’ in my post some days ago.
Can we substitute ‘libertarian’ for ‘right wing’? 😉
Your prejudice against those who attended (or didn’t) state schools is telling though.
It undermines your standpoint and reeks of prejudice.raybanwombleFree MemberI’m a slightly left libertarian, that believes in maximizing the prosperity of as many people as possible (material and environmental before some of you e-lynch me). I sometimes get attached to Left-wing market anarchism but know that it would not work in practice.
Your prejudice against those who attended (or didn’t) state schools is telling though.
It undermines your standpoint and reeks of prejudice.My time in the state system never included a single mention of the concept of critical thinking – the first time that I came into contact in a semi-state based system with the concept of something like “confirmation bias” was within the university system. Most of my state friends can attest to the same, maybe I went to comp during a particularly bad era?
kelvinFull MemberThe ability to get £5000 in cedit shows you are not poor.
That’s an interesting opinion. Assuming you mean debt.
RustySpannerFull MemberI sometimes get attached to Left-wing market anarchism but know that it would not work in practice.
Me too. 🙂
Life is much simpler when you accept that morality is both relative and absolute.
My time in the state system never included a single mention of the concept of critical thinking – the first time that I came into contact in a semi-state based system with the concept of something like “confirmation bias” was within the university system. Most of my state friends can attest to the same, maybe I went to comp during a particularly bad era?
Maybe you did.
Perhaps you chose or were not encouraged to engage with such complexities, even though the tools to enable you to do so were freely available?
Blaming the state system for your own lack of awareness is the very antithesis of libertarianism.
raybanwombleFree MemberBlaming the state system for your own lack of awareness is the very antithesis of libertarianism.
Of course, that’s why I have done a lot of reading in my own time. I noticed that apathy and lack of agency among my peers when I was a kid and decided I didn’t want any part of it.
I don’t pretend to know how to give people the tools whereby they are encouraged to do the same though – or whether we need a more strongly funded state system in reality, against my own libertarian leanings. Is the state system the answer – or is it what causes people to disengage in the first place? Do we need a radically different form of education with more freedom and choice where people can self sort? Or do we need hardcore stateism with classes on citizenship?
All I have is a deep suspicion that something is grossly wrong with the way society is educated and that it’s evidenced by those who are deeply ambivalent towards it and who do not care for “experts”.
RustySpannerFull MemberOf course, that’s why I have done a lot of reading in my own time.
And yet you abuse Angela Rayner (and everyone else from a similar background) for doing (or not doing, you seem to be confused on the subject) the same as you?
Hypocrisy, no?
raybanwombleFree MemberAnd yet you abuse Angela Rayner (and everyone else from a similar background) for doing the same?
Rayner dropped out, sorry – but I stuck with it and got myself out of my shit state school and hometown. She went into a union which was a way out for her, but not one that I believe sets you up to be a competent PM.
Rayner, will be good as a cabinet minister for education or equality, she really isn’t PM material like Cooper though. You need someone with more of an international outlook than Rayners background, unless we want to spend another decade navel gazing and misunderstanding our place in the world.
That’s my opinion though, it’s not in reality fact, and you are entitled to yours. I might have been overly harsh on Rayner as I’m **** pissed with the Labour party and Lib Dems as a whole. Tories are tories, we all know that a lot of them (not all) are total bellends (those that have dragged it further right than even Thatcher), so what they do doesn’t make me so emotionally livid.
jjprestidgeFree MemberThe current education system is f***ed. I say this as someone who has taught at all levels, including the university sector, so this isn’t a layman’s opinion.
We’re still using a lightly modified version of an education system that was designed to suit the needs of industrial revolution era Britain. It’s completely unfit for purpose in the postmodern world.
JP
raybanwombleFree MemberYeah, I can’t make a further comment on that jjprestidge – but maybe you guys can give education a good argue over on my behalf.
RustySpannerFull MemberRayner dropped out, sorry – but I stuck with it and got myself out of my shit state school and hometown. She went into a union which was a way out for her, but not one that I believe sets you up to be a competent PM.
This again highlights your hypocrisy.
What makes you believe that her background in care work, her experience as a single parent and her work for a trade union makes her less capable of analytical thinking than yourself?
You appear to have a very high opinion of yourself and a very low opinion of other people who have achieved as much or more by alternative means.
raybanwombleFree MemberWhat makes you believe that her background in care work, her experience as a single parent and her work for a trade union makes her less capable of analytical thinking than yourself?
You appear to have a very high opinion of yourself and a very low opinion of other people who have achieved as much or more by alternative means.
I believe that Cooper has a better understanding of global affairs than either myself or Rayner.
Don’t take me thinking that Cooper is better equipped for that role than Rayner as some sign that I think I am better equipped to do the job than Rayner. I’d have probably glassed Istanbul with the big red button now ffs.
Cooper has demonstrated her ability to think globally and she has demonstrated a sharper intellect than almost anyone in the Labor party, care work or my own background in my career does not demonstrate any evidence of capability on a world stage.
Cooper comes the closest (and only slightly) to some kind of Labour version of Angela Merkel, that is what Labour needs right now to win.
RustySpannerFull MemberThat’s not the question I asked.
I think your responses betray a certain hypocrisy and gives the (possibly incorrect, I’m willing to admit) impression of bitterness, along with a genuine lack of empathy and understanding.
Maybe that’s unfair, but I can tell you now that care work makes people desperate to improve themselves and also gives a greater understanding of human nature than anything else I’ve experienced.
I’d rather be governed by a cabinet of care workers than a cabinet of hypocritical ‘libertarians’.
raybanwombleFree MemberMaybe that’s unfair, but I can tell you now that care work makes people desperate to improve themselves and also gives a greater understanding of human nature than anything else I’ve experienced.
That still doesn’t make her better than Cooper for the position of PM, the experience you talk about is what is useful to have in cabinet members.
Rayner is also objectively dire in her media appearances, do you want someone who can hold their own and not be so easily wrong footed by media questioning? We all want someone who cares for the British public, that isn’t the only qualification you need to win and be successful in the role.
ctkFull MemberYou must have forgotten how bad Cooper was in her leadership campaign ( and after it!)
raybanwombleFree MemberYou must have forgotten how bad Cooper was in her leadership campaign ( and after it!)
I think she has come along way since then – and the last time I checked she was second behind Corbyn in terms of popularity among Labour membership, Rayner was down in something like 7th.
She appears to have found media form recently.
cromolyollyFree MemberRayner dropped out, sorry – but I stuck with it and got myself out of my shit state school and hometown.
Dropped out. Went back as a adult and single parent. 2-1 to her.
Shows she is a striver not a skivver. That should float your Tory? Conservative? Libertarian? whatever it is we’ve decided you are boat.
raybanwombleFree MemberAnd qualifying as a social carer somehow makes you fit for the office of PM? Is being a bit of a “striver not a skivver” now what we hold as the prerequisites to become PM? After elements of the left have spent the past 20 years lambasting the poor educational attainment of people like G W Bush? Does that not leave the left looking like complete hypocrites? Poor educational attainment is okay in a leader – as long as it’s one of us.
That should float your Tory? Conservative? Libertarian? whatever it is we’ve decided you are boat.
Let me take a guess at what you think – is it https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_fascism ?
The topic ‘2019 General Election’ is closed to new replies.