Home Forums Chat Forum 2015-16 rugby, world cup year

  • This topic has 7,395 replies, 232 voices, and was last updated 8 years ago by WillH.
Viewing 40 posts - 4,921 through 4,960 (of 7,396 total)
  • 2015-16 rugby, world cup year
  • namastebuzz
    Free Member

    Ah, we both know that stat to be bollocks.

    😆

    I know you’re right but I find Farell such a disagreeable sort that I’ll persist in arguing the toss…… 😉

    wrecker
    Free Member

    So you’d pick Ford because he’s a bit less objectionable? 😯

    jambalaya
    Free Member

    At international level Farrell is nothing special and his development has stalled. Ford was first choice 10 for 18 (?) months before the RWC and it was a major error to switch to Farrell after the first game. Ford stays first choice until his England performances are not up to scratch. We know what we’ll get with Farrell and its not enough.

    On Wales bringing players into the side early it certainly helped a lot with North as he was a man mountain at 19. The intensity of International rugby mixed in with tough league and european schedules mean I’d rather see playets eased in gradually unless exceptional (North was/is)

    anagallis_arvensis
    Full Member

    On Wales bringing players into the side early it certainly helped a lot with North as he was a man mountain at 19.

    Halfpenny also had a shit load of caps by 23 or 24.

    wrecker
    Free Member

    Ford stays first choice until his England performances are not up to scratch

    Hate to break it to you, but he’s already failing to deliver to the required standard, and he hasn’t played well since last season. England cannot afford to have a misfiring 10, no matter how talented he might be. He needs benching and soon. Eddie needs to grow a pair.

    Pigface
    Free Member

    Friday night is not a proper time to be playing international rugby, grumble moan, kicks can and wanders off hands deep in pockets. Just saying.

    anagallis_arvensis
    Full Member

    I agree

    namastebuzz
    Free Member

    So you’d pick Ford because he’s a bit less objectionable?

    If two players were equal I’d pick the less objectionable one.

    I personally think Ford is better anyway so I’d pick him. With Cipriani on the bench. 😀

    DanW
    Free Member

    I agree too Pigface. Not least because I’ll be in the air coming home from work and have to watch it later. Sport should be watched live otherwise there’s no point cheering and shouting at the television where you can clearly make a difference to the outcome 🙂

    IdleJon
    Free Member

    Friday night is not a proper time to be playing international rugby, grumble moan, kicks can and wanders off hands deep in pockets. Just saying.

    I work every Saturday. Checked my schedule over the weekend, thought about booking next Saturday off, decided against it. Then thought a bit harder – rugby ’til late on Friday with a few beers, I could then go to watch Swansea v Llanharan on Saturday with an old friend. A few more beers then meet my wife for a curry and Zoolander 2. I decided that, yes, I need to book Saturday off. By the time I made my decision all holidays had been blocked because work is expected to be busy. FFS!! Dithering fool.

    jambalaya
    Free Member

    Friday night is not a proper time to be playing international rugby, grumble moan, kicks can and wanders off hands deep in pockets. Just saying.

    Agreed. Same with club games really. I have a friend who cancelled his wendyball season tickets partly as he missed so many games which where moved to stange days/times.

    As an aside ticket sales for Twickenham seem to have dipped as RFU mailing about extra availability.

    @wrecker in absolute fairness to you I”ve not watched a single game or any highlights 😳 Consistent with my view that post rwc 6n is largely irrelevant. Dropping who was the best 10 in the run up to the rwc and is the player to drive a more expansive game is imo daft, EJ seems to be agree. All my spectating this season will be European RC and Top14
    Being slightly cheeky I can see why Irish and Welsh fans want to see Farrell, he’s far less dangerous to them than Ford

    wrecker
    Free Member

    I wonder of those england fans, who admires players like Mike Phillips, Picamoles, Healy etc for their no-nonsense approach. Farrell has done nothing these guys don’t do.
    I don’t play this self loathing bollocks. I like Farrell and Brown. We lack fire and aggression. We have a lot of players who are scared to show their teeth when needs be. They act like a load of big soft dopey lummoxes 😀 Regan, Back, Dally, Hill, MJ etc must be rolling their eyes.

    EJ seems to be agree.

    I suspect Farrell is playing 12 because ford can’t. With Slade fit, I would have expected Ford to have been dropped by now. I wouldn’t be surprised to see him replaced vs Ireland.

    DanW
    Free Member

    Ford/ Cips/ type player with a proper 12 and a balanced back row is a team I wouldn’t want to face. I think most teams would take Farrell all day long by choice! The other backs get instantly taken out of the game 😉

    The England pack on form do the work of most full teams in defence so I don’t think adding to the lumbering-1D-ness (Farrell) helps the team as a whole if you want to be more expansive (i.e. challenge the SH sides).

    I wonder of those england fans, who admires players like Mike Phillips, Picamoles, Healy etc for their no-nonsense approach. Farrell has done nothing these guys don’t do.

    I wouldn’t call Farrell no nonsense, nor the others really. Farrell is all mouth and no trousers which is what gets people’s backs up and his “confrontational style” is often very misplaced and lets down the team as a result.

    Farrell is a solid international 10 who’ll kick penalties but isn’t the long term option IMO. I would imagine Snr’s meddling will also delay this progress

    wrecker
    Free Member

    I wouldn’t call Farrell no nonsense, nor the others really. Farrell is all mouth and no trousers which is what gets people’s backs up and his “confrontational style” is often very misplaced and lets down the team as a result.

    They are all “no trousers”. No fisticuffs allowed nowadays. I think his disciplinary record is better than Healys.

    Ford/ Cips/ type player with a proper 12 and a balanced back row is a team I wouldn’t want to face. I think most teams would take Farrell all day long by choice!

    I bet they wouldn’t. So many games are won by pens, they’d be crazy to.
    I don’t think Farrell is the long term answer either, but it’s undeniable, regardless if you are a fan of fords or if you dislike Farrell for whatever reason that Farrell is playing the better rugby and is more deserving of an england shirt than ford is. You either pick by reputation or by form.
    I’m far from convinced that Ford is the long term answer either. He’s shown flashes but he’s unconsistent and flaky.

    anagallis_arvensis
    Full Member

    who admires players like Mike Phillips, Picamoles, Healy etc for their no-nonsense approach. Farrell has done nothing these guys don’t do.

    None of those players have played for England! Therefore Farrel is a scum bag but Phillips a saint.

    Healey is actually the worst of the lot, a violent stampy thug who tries to injure people.

    wrecker
    Free Member

    None of those players have played for England! Therefore Farrel is a scum bag but Phillips a saint.

    😀

    namastebuzz
    Free Member

    The thing is, it’s a lot easier to look good playing for Saracens than it is playing for either Sale or (at the moment) Bath.

    When people say Farrell is the “form 10” in Europe that judgement is based on how he looks given an armchair ride by a dominant team.

    Mike Philips may be a total kn*b off the pitch but at least he played some good stuff on it. Farrell just runs round all the time trying to be a total c**t. As does Brown.

    Josh Lewsey was hard as nails without being a tw*t. That’s what you want.

    wrecker
    Free Member

    The thing is, it’s a lot easier to look good playing for Saracens than it is playing for either Sale or (at the moment) Bath.

    You could have said exactly the same thing about Ford last season.

    Brown is one of the only england players who came out of the RWC with any credit, and it was only a couple of years ago people were saying he was the best 15 in europe.Farrell may be running around being a **** but he’s still performing better than Ford, which says quite a lot about Fords form.
    It’s disconcerting when England fans won’t acknowledge a good player for their own team just because they don’t like them.

    Oh, and Phillips was every bit the **** on the pitch that MB and OF were/are, and then some. I liked him, too.

    namastebuzz
    Free Member

    Brown’s not that good either. He had one good run of games where he was England’s best player but then Mark Cueto did the same a few years back – didn’t make him Jason Robinson.

    Brown lacks basic skills like how to draw a man and give a pass. (See Eng v Wales 2012 80th minute) He also lacks basic manners when talking to officials.

    Brown’s been lucky – Foden’s been injured a lot and Armitage/Abendenon went to France. They should have stuck Watson in at fullback and let him learn on the job.

    duckman
    Full Member

    Anybody read the article on project players in the Times today? Talks about us and Ireland targeting players for positions using Stander,Nel and Payne as examples.

    wrecker
    Free Member

    Well, I am a fan of Foden and watson, and I was not keen on Brown in the early days, but he does a job well. If he needs to behave aggressively to get the most out of his game, then it’s fine by me. Armitage? 😆 and you think Brown is a ****? He’s a complete novice compared to that person AND he’s shit anyway!

    ekul
    Free Member

    I’m in the camp that being a tw*t can be a good thing if you do it right on the rugby pitch. Farrells problem for me is that his aggression leads to him shooting out the line to smash the player and leaving a dogleg in defence, means everyone else has to compensate. This is fine if he smashed his man every time but he doesn’t.

    Re. Mike Brown I’d never noticed it before but someone mentioned it to me against Italy, he’s so easy to read. He never carries the ball in two hands, therefore he never looks like he’s going to pass it and that’s why he doesn’t draw defenders in. To his credit he’s pretty good at wriggling through but he’s never gonna put other people away until he learns to carry in two hands and at least look like he’s considering using his support runners!

    anagallis_arvensis
    Full Member

    France: Maxime Medard; Virimi Vakatawa, Maxime Mermoz, Jonathan Danty, Djibril Camara; Jules Plisson, Maxime Machenaud; Jefferson Poirot, Guilhem Guirado (capt), Rabah Slimani, Alexandre Flanquart, Paul Jedrasiak, Antoine Burban, Damien Chouly, Wenceslas Lauret.

    Replacements: Camille Chat, Uini Atonio, Vincent Pelo, Yoann Maestri, Loann Goujon, Sebastien Bezy, Francois Trinh Duc, Gael Fickou

    Anyone able to offer some insight into that lot? Backs look sharpe, have no idea about pack

    mrhoppy
    Full Member

    The problem with englands **** is that they’re aimless ****, see Farrell’s push on Laidlaw or brown starting on forwards on his own. When Phillips was being a **** he’d generally be a discerning **** and getting some gain by winding the player up.

    DanW
    Free Member

    They are all “no trousers”. No fisticuffs allowed nowadays. I think his disciplinary record is better than Healys.

    I’m glad others were able to better articulate what I meant when I said Farrell is all mouth and no trousers…. granted though Healy is some special kind of nut job for the stuff he comes up with some times

    I’m in the camp that being a tw*t can be a good thing if you do it right on the rugby pitch. Farrells problem for me is that his aggression leads to him shooting out the line to smash the player and leaving a dogleg in defence, means everyone else has to compensate. This is fine if he smashed his man every time but he doesn’t.

    Not to mention being seemingly easy to wind up and knock off his game, a fan of cheap shots and also bloody lucky that high tackles have been deemed lawful for some reason this 6N. He could already have a couple of yellows and that is potentially game changing stuff.

    mefty
    Free Member

    Anyone able to offer some insight into that lot? Backs look sharpe, have no idea about pack

    The No 8 had a good Christmas period.

    But in all seriousness, the coach is trying to rediscover France’s rugby DNA, rightly in my view, it will take time to click but my guess is this Friday is too early – we, England, may be playing a very different team by the end of the tournament.

    wrecker
    Free Member

    trying to rediscover France’s rugby DNA

    Gouging and le combat?

    mefty
    Free Member

    Peut-etre

    namastebuzz
    Free Member

    Well, I am a fan of Foden and watson, and I was not keen on Brown in the early days, but he does a job well. If he needs to behave aggressively to get the most out of his game, then it’s fine by me. Armitage? and you think Brown is a ****? He’s a complete novice compared to that person AND he’s shit anyway!

    Armitage is a total bellend – I agree – but he has a grasp of basic skills that Brown never will and has more pace too.

    There’s behaving aggressively by flattening some annoying opponent in a legal manner (Lewsey) or by shouting at linesmen and running 50yds to shove someone in the back because they haven’t released the ball for a lineout (Brown).

    These days, fullbacks need to be the first line of attack and pose a proper threat – Ben Smith, Israel Dagg/Folau, Stuart Hogg etc.

    Brown is little threat. As Ekul points out he tucks it under one arm, is easy to read and doesn’t put people away.

    Foden has far more ability although he hasn’t looked great this season the couple of times I’ve seen him. Watson has massive potential as a fullback but doesn’t look a natural winger – if anyone listens to Austin Healey….

    duckman
    Full Member

    That French pack is big,slow and not especially destructive in the tight for their bulk. Expect more grinding rugby to break out. 3 weeks for Britz for his red,that was premium brand biccies,none of your tesco own brand orange clubs there.

    anagallis_arvensis
    Full Member

    When Phillips was being a **** he’d generally be a discerning **** and getting some gain by winding the player up.

    When he was Farrels age he was still a bit of a bell end tbf.

    jambalaya
    Free Member

    FWIW Brown would be one of the first names on my England team sheet. Farrell adds nothing postive in terms of “aggression”, I doubt a single opponent takes himthat seriously in that rgeard. A red card in a big game has been a risk for a while, his shoulder charge/late tackle on Giteau was poor discipline in a massive game. He was personally humiliated by Wilkinson and Giteau in the Heinekin semi and final – that showed in his late tackle at the RWC. During the Cardiff final Farrell looked the pedestrian “jobbing 10” he is at that level, shovelling passes like his father.

    Farrell got himself and England so far, to go further we mire from 10 and Farrells development has stalled.

    duckman
    Full Member

    anagallis_arvensis – Member

    When Phillips was being a **** he’d generally be a discerning **** and getting some gain by winding the player up.

    When he was Farrels age he was still a bit of a bell end tbf.

    Posted 2 hours ago #

    Getting knocked out by bouncers on drunken nights out, wasn’t he? Oh;and sharing sexy time with that blonde singer. The rest of his leisure time was mostly wasted. 🙂

    loum
    Free Member

    Looks like injuries have forced Joe to pick a centre in midfield and McCloskey’s getting a start at 12. 🙂

    And Josh van der Flier at 7 too. 🙂

    DanW
    Free Member

    What a legend 🙂 Going back to CFH’s post….

    DanW
    Free Member

    England starters as per BBC. Itoje in the second row…

    Mike Brown; Anthony Watson, Jonathan Joseph, Owen Farrell, Jack Nowell; George Ford, Ben Youngs; Joe Marler, Dylan Hartley (capt), Dan Cole, Maro Itoje, George Kruis, Chris Robshaw, James Haskell, Billy Vunipola

    anagallis_arvensis
    Full Member

    Getting knocked out by bouncers on drunken nights out, wasn’t he? Oh;and sharing sexy time with that blonde singer. The rest of his leisure time was mostly wasted.

    Couldnt really care about that, at least he wasnt scoring coke for journo’s!

    mefty
    Free Member

    Couldnt really care about that, at least he wasnt scoring coke for journo’s!

    Your apostrophe looks like it might have been tackled by Jamie Roberts, it has been knocked back four words.

    jambalaya
    Free Member

    @medty thanks for that link. Went on a golf tour to SW Ireland with an ex rugby player with a nose like Tolon’s. He’d jist spent £15k on his teeth but none of us where nearly brave enough to ask why he hadn’t got his nose done

Viewing 40 posts - 4,921 through 4,960 (of 7,396 total)

The topic ‘2015-16 rugby, world cup year’ is closed to new replies.