Home Forums Chat Forum 2015-16 rugby, world cup year

  • This topic has 7,395 replies, 232 voices, and was last updated 8 years ago by WillH.
Viewing 40 posts - 4,881 through 4,920 (of 7,396 total)
  • 2015-16 rugby, world cup year
  • peteimpreza
    Full Member

    We beat Sale !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    Go Warriors !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

    My old man will be dead chuffed .

    anagallis_arvensis
    Full Member


    Naughty

    teamhurtmore
    Free Member

    Who’s in the clip AA?

    Not sure about naughty, more crap at punching!

    I was thinking about you while watching the Leeds NQC RL match yesterday – the high tackles, tip tackles and neck rolls would have had you in a frenzy!!

    Pigface
    Free Member

    The run and wriggle mob did well didn’t they 🙄

    wrecker
    Free Member

    Not sure about naughty, more crap at punching!

    The punchee then failed a head injury assessment and had to be subbed, so not that crap!

    teamhurtmore
    Free Member

    OK – stand corrected!! Oops

    Did they exchange pleasantries while the medics were on? (BBC website picture)

    tinybits
    Free Member

    Devoto and Beaumont out of England Squad (not that they were going to get a game) and Burrell in. Thought it’d be Manu (who isn’t playing well enough yet) so I’m pleased.

    Kryton57
    Full Member

    I don’t think Burrells playing at his best. But will EJ use him or continue with Farrell? He’s a much heavier runner than Farell, has experience and has worked with JJ – once touted as the RWC partnership.

    If the fans have their way Ford off for Farrell and Burrell in. Right?

    wrecker
    Free Member

    I don’t think Burrells playing at his best.

    He’s been very good indeed for the last 3 games.

    If the fans have their way Ford off for Farrell and Burrell in. Right?

    That’s exactly what I’d do.

    ekul
    Free Member

    I don’t think Burrells playing at his best.

    He’s been very good indeed for the last 3 games.

    At 13… which is where he was pretty impressive for England when he first came on the scene. I don’t think he’s a 12, he’s a big, quick guy but doesn’t break or bend the line enough to be a out and out bosh 12, and he doesn’t seem intelligent enough (as a player) to be a ball playing 12. His strengths seem to be out wide where he can use his size and pace a bit more, so for me he’s 13 or bust, and I can’t see him ousting Joseph.

    I’ve not seen much of Saints’ games recently but have seen plenty of praise for Henry Mallinder, with some suggesting that its he who has brought the best out in Burrell again. Can anyone confirm?

    DanW
    Free Member

    Looking at how a Hooker can play nowadays are you sure you don’t want the chubby centre to have another go at 12 for you? 😀

    Kryton57
    Full Member

    In which case Ekul, we’d see Ford/Farrell again (groan), and potentially Burell / JJ subbed for different jobs?

    ekul
    Free Member

    I do think we’ll see Ford and Farrell again, I think our only hope is that Ford plays himself into some form in the next couple of games! I do feel for him a little, a couple of times against Italy I could see him looking for the pass only to either have a lumbering idiot (Haskell and Robshaw) jogging alongside him with no arms up to receive the ball and blocking him from passing it to anyone more useful, or there was simply no one there at all, hence why he got smashed a few times.

    It might be symptomatic of whats happened at Bath but last 6Ns Joseph was running really good lines off Ford and just ghosting through gaps thanks to Ford’s flat passing on the gainline, this year there’s none of that. Have they been worked out? But it doesn’t even look like they’ve tried anything like that in the past 2 games.

    wrecker
    Free Member

    I’ve not seen much of Saints’ games recently but have seen plenty of praise for Henry Mallinder

    Deservedly, I’ve seen I think 3 games he’s played now. One at fullback and he was excellent in all. He looks like a 10 year old, mind. A 6ft4, 17st 10 year old 😯
    Ross Chisholm at quins has been looking very very good at Fb too.

    Disagree about ford though, he’s getting smashed, because at present he is shit. Currently he does not deserve to be wearing an england shirt, nor, arguably a bath shirt either.

    anagallis_arvensis
    Full Member

    Wales make 3 changes Cuhbert for James, Lydiate for Tips and Davies for Girafferis. Shame Girafferis the maul buster is out big loss. Lydiate coming in to chop down the big French forward runners makes sense. On the wing Forest Gump 1 replaced by Forest Gump 2. Anscombe and Ball are on bench. If they play well they should beat France but it’ll be tight. Not many players other than Roberts and Faletau are playing at their best tbh.

    namastebuzz
    Free Member

    Some interesting comments by EJ on whether Tuilagi can be the next Nonu:

    “If you look at it purely on athleticism between Manu and Ma’a Nonu, Manu is not behind Nonu at all, He starts in a good situation and then it’s a matter of how hard you work at your game and how desperate you are to want to play for England.

    “I think 12’s his best position, yes. He’s not a 13. That’s what I know he’s not. He’s definitely a 12. He can carry the ball across the gain line.

    “He threw a beautiful left to right pass on Friday night, threw a terrible right to left, so maybe he’s left handed, I don’t know.

    “But he’s got the ability to catch and pass. I haven’t seen him kick but there’s no reason he can’t learn to kick. We have a reasonable kicking mentor (Jonny Wilkinson) here. He’s got all the attributes to be an outstanding 12.”

    And on Burrell:

    “The reason I left him (Burrell) out in the first place was because he wasn’t good enough to be in the squad. He had flaws in his game and was making a lot of mistakes. I think he’s done that brilliantly and looks like he’s getting better every day.”

    http://www.nzherald.co.nz/sport/news/article.cfm?c_id=4&objectid=11593960

    namastebuzz
    Free Member

    ON the All Blacks – I was reading about how Kieran Read will be the next captain and how Sam Cane will fill the No7 jersey vacated by McCaw.

    Cane is 24 and already has 31 caps, including having captained the side. Contrast this with Matt Kvesic who’s nearly 24 and has 2 caps to his name. Maybe Kvesic is the answer for England or maybe he’s not but the point is – if he was a Kiwi they’d know by now.

    It seems like he’s been wasted. He’s been on the scene for a few years but we’ve never found out if he can cut it.

    The ABs are also talking about when Hansen is going to go. That’s the difference. THey know when someone is going and they know who’s gonna replace him.

    Contrast that with England (or France) over the last 10 years……

    anagallis_arvensis
    Full Member

    George North has 50!

    mefty
    Free Member

    There was plenty of blood letting in NZ rugby when they were losing.

    namastebuzz
    Free Member

    George North has 50!

    Indeed and he’ll probably get 150 if he avoids too many more bangs on the head. The cream seems to rise to the top a lot quicker in Wales.

    There was plenty of blood letting in NZ rugby when they were losing.

    True but I don’t recall much losing going on of late – a couple of RWC knockout games aside.

    wrecker
    Free Member

    Cane is 24 and already has 31 caps, including having captained the side. Contrast this with Matt Kvesic who’s nearly 24 and has 2 caps to his name. Maybe Kvesic is the answer for England or maybe he’s not but the point is – if he was a Kiwi they’d know by now.

    I disagree. How many other NZ 7’s have got caps in the last 8 years?
    The difference is the ABs identify talent early and ensure that the individual is ready when he needs to be. As per the above example, they didn’t just know that Sam Cane would make it, they made sure of it.
    We just flit around trying this and that, hoping that the clubs come up with the goods.

    anagallis_arvensis
    Full Member

    The cream seems to rise to the top a lot quicker in Wales.

    The vastly smaller number of options helps but Wales do make more effort to identify talent early and bring it in to the international game.

    tinybits
    Free Member

    In case the country they actually are from cotton on and cap them…..

    anagallis_arvensis
    Full Member

    Dylan? Vunipola x2 Tuilagi?

    wrecker
    Free Member

    Quite clever having an age grade tie in.

    Bear
    Free Member

    Wrecker – isn’t EJ trying to do that with Ford?
    He is out of form and playing poorly, but has been identified as the one to take England forward as he does seem to have great vision and passing ability when on form. Therefore you stick with him?
    Or do they just share caps about trying to find a miracle? Personally I think if you identify someone then you should stick with it. I hope EJ does this in several key positions when he is ready and has established the players he wants and that can play in the style he would like.

    wrecker
    Free Member

    It’s a damn good question bear, and not one I have an answer to.
    I am not, nor have I ever been convinced that Ford is as good as some seem to think. Given a year at 10, I think Slade would be better.

    namastebuzz
    Free Member

    wrecker – Member

    I disagree.

    Sounds like you agree more than you disagree – that’s pretty much the point I was trying to make but perhaps I didn’t put it so well. :;

    As for FH – Ford has proved with Bath and England that he can be a top-class operator so EJ looks like he’ll stick with him. Slade might turn out to be better but he hasn’t played too much at 10 for Exeter and he’s not playing at all at the moment so it’s a moot point, for now.

    There’s a lot of luck needed in international rugby – unless you’re Jonah Lomu. Being uninjured and in good form when the various windows for squad selection open is paramount. Slade has fallen foul of that by breaking his leg when surely he was looking at being the starting 12 for the 6N. If he’s not back and playing well when the Aus tour squad is chosen then he might miss out again and that’s a years potential development wasted.

    The same has happened to Christian Wade a couple of times and poor old JSD always seemed to play a blinder but then pick up injuries at exactly the wrong moment for England selection.

    wrecker
    Free Member

    Perhaps but it is relevant that (at present at least) Farrell is the better player.
    Apologies if i missed your point, it’s a source of frustration that we have such a successful u-20s team, and the route to the elite squad is shit compared to the ABs.
    I also learned that the AB contracted players will barely play any club rugby leading up to a RWC, they take part in a RWC conditioning package instead….remarkable.

    namastebuzz
    Free Member

    Is Farrell a better player? Apart from playing for a dominant club and being a good kicker and being able to throw a long miss pass to nobody in particular is he really better than Ford?

    I also learned that the AB contracted players will barely play any club rugby leading up to a RWC, they take part in a RWC conditioning package instead….remarkable.

    Well that’s the beauty of central contracts. In 1995 the RFU decided to “wait and see” how things would turn out under professionalism. How it turned out was the clubs took control of all the players and have never relinquished it. Hence the sorry state of the England team ever since – 2003 excepted.

    CaptainFlashheart
    Free Member

    On current form, this is the best 10 in the English prem.


    All of him.

    🙂

    namastebuzz
    Free Member

    That’s him lying down after running out the tunnel before the start of the match…….

    grahamt1980
    Full Member

    All the kids are just about managing to hold the advertising hoarding up against the load

    wrecker
    Free Member

    Is Farrell a better player?

    At the moment, yes. By a long, long way. Ford is fickle mentally and can only shine when his team are going forward, hence him being so poor for bath this year.

    All of him.

    He’s doing a job for Newcastle, but he’s far from the form 10 in the AP. The bloke doesn’t run, not even a little bit. Love the pic, it ws young harry mallinder who put him there.

    namastebuzz
    Free Member

    The bloke doesn’t run, not even a little bit

    Is that Andy Goode or Farrell you’re talking about? 😆

    wrecker
    Free Member

    Farrell has been playing great rugby this year and he shifts and he can tackle, as in actually bring players to the ground rather than act like a breathing speed bump 😉

    namastebuzz
    Free Member

    Much as I loathe stats his tackling % is actually lower than Ford or Cipriani in the premiership…..

    wrecker
    Free Member

    Ah, we both know that stat to be bollocks. Farrell is considerably stronger defensively than both. You only have to have seen them play to know that.

    CaptainFlashheart
    Free Member

    Skillz.

    🙂

Viewing 40 posts - 4,881 through 4,920 (of 7,396 total)

The topic ‘2015-16 rugby, world cup year’ is closed to new replies.