I've been born, lived and worked in many of those northern towns mentioned and none compare to the time I spent around the east end of london , the areas of Poplar and then Barking. (god I hope I never have to go back to Poplar – do they know what a tree or blade of grass is)
Have to agree with Fubar somewhat. Admittedly I've only live in Lichfield (although went to school in Walsall) Reading and London. Was a student in Reading and lived in several areas new town, earley and whitley.
Whitley is supposed to be the worst area of reading and pretty ruff which is partly true, but to be honest I'd much rather live there than Battersea. Obviously it depends where you live I lived north of clapham junction (york road/falcon road junction) but parts of battersea are serious pants. My girlfriend got broken into a guy came in her room while she was sleeping and stole her handbag !
But then you get plenty of people saying its a good area lots of culture, plenty going on and best of all its up and coming.
Which translates as loads of rubbish, watch your self and the area is not going to get any better for at least 50 years.
I cant help but feel theres alot of people living in london in denial. Oh I've moved here got a job have to keep up apperances oh yes its a nice area up and coming !