Looking for some fit/sizing advice! Is anybody 175cm tall on a medium/18″? What size fireline is closest to a medium canfield?
I’ve previously owned a medium canfield yelli screamy, and currently have a 16″/small Kona Honzo. The Honzo is a little small, the canfield was just about right. Comparing the geometry charts between these bikes makes me think the fireline reach or top tube lengths are incorrect- either that or the reach is extremely short despite a steep seat angle and decent top tube length? Furthering my confusion is Brant’s recommendation for a size small at my height- on paper that’s smaller than my Kona (which is smaller than I’d like for longer rides, having owned ridden it for a year now). The 18″ fireline looks pretty close to the medium yelli screamy, which is why I’m leaning that way. Only the head tube length worries me on the 18″ fireline.
I’m 175cm tall, my saddle height is 74cm from center of BB to top of saddle. 760/20mm bars and 50mm stems on all my bikes.
Here’s some numbers from the geometry charts- note the reach #’s vs TT lengths-wtf
Reach
Titus Fireline Evo 29 18″: 15.3″
Canfield Yelli Screamy Med: 16.18″ / 411mm
Kona Honzo 16″ : 16″ / 406mm
Top tube length
Titus Fireline Evo 29 18″: 23.6″
Canfield Yelli Screamy Med: 23.75″ /564mm
Kona Honzo 16″ : 23″ / 584mm
Head tube:
Titus Fireline Evo 29 18″: 4.7″ / 120mm
Canfield Yelli Screamy Med: 4.3 / 110mm
Kona Honzo 16″ : 3.5″ / 89mm
By the way, I’ve also posted on MTBR.
Appreciate any thoughts.