Home Forums Chat Forum 2019 General Election

  • This topic has 6,282 replies, 176 voices, and was last updated 4 years ago by kelvin.
Viewing 40 posts - 4,681 through 4,720 (of 6,291 total)
  • 2019 General Election
  • rone
    Full Member

    I don’t, I think it would be fairly similar to how it is now. We will never know though so your guess is as good as mine.

    100%.

    The mud would still be thrown.

    Character assassination wouldn’t just stop.

    cromolyolly
    Free Member

    context of the people I speak to and a lot of them thinking like that

    So you’ve taken a small sample and extrapolated to a larger population which is the textbook definition of generalisation.

    Had you qualified what a lot meant (many of the people I know, which amounts to 2/5s of naff all) it might be different

    But then it would literally be the same thing I said, which is that many studies have studied large numbers of rich people and found that a lot of them share common behaviours.

    rone
    Full Member

    This idea of a centrist cleaning up seems to be an unshakable belief, but where’s the evidence for it?

    Lib dems diving in the polls is all the evidence you need that centrism won’t clean up.

    That and the fact that we are at the arse-end of neolibralism which has bought about the divisions we have. (for me centrism is still neolibralism – tuned for the Guardian.)

    Imagine a world without the Mail and The Sun. Corbyn would walk it.

    rone
    Full Member

    Corbyn is unpopular.

    All leaders are unpopular to many groups of people.

    rone
    Full Member

    People are perfectly capable of making their own minds up ..

    So by that raitionale we can move on from Brexit because poeple are perfectly capable of making their own minds up. And the ones that voted for Brexit clearly knew what they were getting in to?

    You’ve used the crux of your own argument here time and time again against Brexit voters.

    cromolyolly
    Free Member

    There surely can’t be all that many remainer Conservatives left, can there?

    Apparently there are. For remainder cons party>remaining for leaver Labs the opposite is true. That’s part of the problem.

    kelvin
    Full Member

    The Tories have a plan to steel some voters from Labour. It’s a big fat obvious obnoxious one. I’ve not seen even a hint that Labour want to take votes from the Tories. Their priority seems to be new voters, and I have no idea where that will be enough for them to poach seats. I hope it pays off.

    Cougar
    Full Member

    @mrmonkfinger > you missed one trick there:

    because democracy is about making decisions through public vote?

    It isn’t, it’s about choosing people through public vote who are then empowered to make those decisions.

    Cougar
    Full Member

    What you’re forgetting is that for a lot of people the war is personal

    Did you ask him what he did in the war personally? Unless he’s approaching 100, the answer is probably “hide.”

    we’re better than europe and won the war

    We did win the war. With help from *deep breath*:

    The United States (from December 1941)
    The Soviet Union (from June 1941)
    China
    France
    Poland
    Yugoslavia
    Greece
    Netherlands
    Belgium
    Norway
    Czechoslovakia
    Luxembourg
    India
    Canada
    Australia
    New Zealand
    South Africa
    Ethiopia
    Brazil
    Philippines
    Mongolia
    Nepal
    Mexico
    Cuba

    kerley
    Free Member

    The Tories have a plan to steel some voters from Labour. It’s a big fat obvious obnoxious one. I’ve not seen even a hint that Labour want to take votes from the Tories.

    How could Labour take votes from the Tories?

    binners
    Full Member

    I see Johnson is up to his usual default antics. If in doubt, say something racist

    Boris Johnson vows end to migrants ‘treating Britain as their own’

    He’s an absolutely despicable human being. He’s deliberately ratcheting up fear of ‘the other’, stoking up xenophobia and giving a tacit nod to the racists that he’s on their side. It ****ing infuriates me because there are genuine consequences to this kind of shit. Not for a rich privileged white man, obviously…

    I’m cautious about quoting the great sage Gary Neville but he was bang on at the weekend after the monkey chants at the Manchester derby

    Gary Neville accuses Boris Johnson of fuelling racism

    CaptainFlashheart
    Free Member

    How could Labour take votes from the Tories?

    Moving away a Marxist shadow chancellor, and a shadow home secretary who thinks Mao wasn’t all that bad. That would be a start, I’d say.

    Oh, and the whole inviting nasty people to parliament. Better stop that as well, I reckon.

    kelvin
    Full Member

    How could Labour take votes from the Tories?

    There are an awful lot of people who historically voted Conservative, don’t want Boris as PM, don’t want Brexit, don’t like the Trumpificatuin of UK politics, don’t want the government to neuter the legal system and other restraints on executive power, and simply aren’t impressed with post 2016 Tory “government” so far… they should be ripe for the “let’s give the other party a chance” vote.

    ctk
    Full Member

    Yep Labours problem is they just think all they have to be is the best Labour Party ever and then everyone will see sense.

    If Labour had fewer policies it would be so much easier for them. Its about optics and the Tories understand this. The Labour campaign has been a bit of a mess. Every new election promise makes the others less believable.

    The Tories have to convince everyone that they are not going to sell the NHS
    Labour have to convince everyone that they are not going to “bankrupt the country like last time” (NB I know it wasn’t Labours fault but lots of people still think it was! Boris saying it today- unchallenged of course)

    Still fingers crossed

    kiksy
    Free Member

    There are an awful lot of people who historically voted Conservative, don’t want Boris as PM, don’t want Brexit, don’t like the Trumpificatuin of UK politics, don’t want the government to neuter the legal system and other restraints on executive power, and simply aren’t impressed with post 2016 Tory “government” so far… they should be ripe for the “let’s give the other party a chance” vote.

    And how are Labour not meeting every one of those criteria already?

    kiksy
    Free Member

    If Labour had fewer policies it would be so much easier for them. Its about optics and the Tories understand this. The Labour campaign has been a bit of a mess. Every new election promise makes the others less believable.

    The Tories have to convince everyone that they are not going to sell the NHS
    Labour have to convince everyone that they are not going to “bankrupt the country like last time” (NB I know it wasn’t Labours fault but lots of people still think it was! Boris saying it today- unchallenged of course)

    All of this ignores the elephant of Brexit though. The Cons could (and pretty much have) no manifesto and still get an insane amount of votes purely because they claim to “Get Brexit Done”. At one point Brexit Party was polling at 25%.

    Labour having the perfect manifesto but being remain would not get those voters back.

    ctk
    Full Member

    Yep agreed but maybe with fewer policies they could argue more about how the Tories’ policy of ‘Get Brexit done’ is BS and Bojo himself has been an impediment on getting Brexit done etc

    ctk
    Full Member

    Or **** it just have get Brexit done vs Free Broadband

    mrmonkfinger
    Free Member

    Cougar, yes, I know, a subtle distinction given the overall discussion.

    As to what they did in the war, aged 85, I know exactly what they did (have bombs dropped very close to them, watched American troops roll past for D Day, saw a lot of aircraft shot at overhead), the personal thing was really relating to folk having lost parents and relatives (etc). Either way, doesn’t really matter, it is the holding tight of the belief that All Germans Are Nazi Bastards and Britain Shouldn’t Have Anything To Do With Them, which is, well, asinine and unproductive at best, and a number of other words at worst.

    Gowrie
    Free Member

    And how are Labour not meeting every one of those criteria already?

    See CHF’s post above – viz

    Moving away a Marxist shadow chancellor, and a shadow home secretary who thinks Mao wasn’t all that bad. That would be a start, I’d say.

    Oh, and the whole inviting nasty people to parliament. Better stop that as well, I reckon.

    I am that Conservative remainer, despairing of the direction the Tory party has gone and would readily vote Labour otherwise this time around.

    PrinceJohn
    Full Member

    I am that Conservative remainer, despairing of the direction the Tory party has gone and would readily vote Labour otherwise this time around.

    So who are you going to vote for?

    Surely you can’t vote Conservative?

    Gowrie
    Free Member

    Surely you can’t vote Conservative?

    Indeed I won’t. I may not vote at all, for the first time in 40+ years. If I vote it will be LD. I was lining up early on to vote LD but their policy of revoke A50 whatever made me feel they’d overplayed their hand. And as usual, they may be centrist in some things but they’re extreme in some of their Liberal ideas.
    But don’t be so surprised if someone is going to vote Tory. Millions are – and they’re not all fools or Little Englander isolationists. There are many who will hold their nose and vote Tory because they think the current incarnation of Labour is even further beyond the pale.

    boomerlives
    Free Member

    but they’re extreme in some of their Liberal ideas.

    Extreme and Liberal don’t seem to mesh.

    kiksy
    Free Member

    but they’re extreme in some of their Liberal ideas.

    Out of interest what policies put you off?

    kimbers
    Full Member

    Laura K getting played by Cummings again I see

    Anonymous source says that Hancock’s aide was punched by bused in labour protestors
    (Tho she’s since deleted the tweet saying that)

    Reality is that a guy on a bike shouted at him and he drove off, but somehow she can’t quite admit it?

    I’m not saying she’s a paid Tory bot, but just wish that ‘anonymous sources’ weren’t given so much credence in desperate bid to get a story

    Gowrie
    Free Member

    Out of interest what policies put you off?

    Cancel A50 – not the right way to stop Brexit IMO
    Look at JS as a potential PM – vastly unrealistic expectation
    Those were the principal ones. But perhaps if they were ramping up in the polls I’d still consider them – but they’ve blown it.

    scotroutes
    Full Member

    “Grim”?

    jam-bo
    Full Member

    Cyclist assaults politician…

    kimbers
    Full Member

    AHH apparently the story about police arresting a labour activist taxied over there by the party came from Guido Fawkes

    & Of course the Dan Hodges, mailonline still running with the story

    How is it that 3.5 years after the referendum so many journos still get played so easily by the Cummings/Brexit/Tory fake need soon machine?

    Cougar
    Full Member

    Either way, doesn’t really matter, it is the holding tight of the belief that All Germans Are Nazi Bastards and Britain Shouldn’t Have Anything To Do With Them, which is, well, asinine and unproductive at best, and a number of other words at worst.

    Sure. I mean, I appreciate that people like him are a lost cause. Someone who’s thought that way for decades isn’t going to be changing their opinion any time soon regardless of how many facts you present.

    My point was rather, I’ve seen a commentary that runs along the lines of “well I voted remain but we have to leave the EU because democracy” and it needs challenging because it’s incorrect and misleading.

    Cancel A50 – not the right way to stop Brexit IMO

    Perhaps, perhaps not. But which is more important, that it is / isn’t stopped, or the method in which it’s achieved?

    Personally I think it should be the right way to stop it. It’s literally the entire point of Parliament to make those sorts of decisions. Whether it is the right way, well, sadly after four years of being systematically lied to I think we’ve long passed the point of not being able to do it without another referendum.

    Look at JS as a potential PM – vastly unrealistic expectation

    I can’t really argue with that. She seems to be a remarkably poor choice of leader for the LDs.

    kimbers
    Full Member

    Preston blaming , but not naming, ‘senior tories’

    That’ll be Matt Hancock then

    Edukator
    Free Member

    Cancel A50 – not the right way to stop Brexit IMO

    The only way to stop Brexit. The law says Britain leaves if it doesn’t.

    Cougar
    Full Member

    Cancel A50 – not the right way to stop Brexit IMO

    Huh. Here you go then:

    https://www.theneweuropean.co.uk/top-stories/lib-dems-ready-for-people-s-vote-1-6414965

    “Jo Swinson says bill for second Brexit referendum is ‘ready to go'”

    (Also… wait, what?)

    molgrips
    Free Member

    Posted my vote today – noticed just after I put it in the box that the only collection was 9am! Hope it gets there …

    ctk
    Full Member

    scotroutes

    Member
    “Grim”?

    Grim to a tory like Laura K

    binners
    Full Member

    People died for your right not to post your postal vote in time for it to count Molls

    I just hope the Tory doesn’t win with a majority of one!

    Great description of the two party leaders by a voter in a northern target seat on Five Live just now

    “Boris Johnson is as mad as a box of frogs and Corbyn’s not right in the swede”

    Indeed.

    nickc
    Full Member

    How is it that 3.5 years after the referendum so many journos still get played so easily by the Cummings/Brexit/Tory fake need soon machine?

    Because their job is to report the news? Having listened to many podcasts with KL on them, it’s clear she’s no fan of the current Tory press machine, as many other journalists have expressed, they all realise they’re being fed stuff by both sides. Report it, and folk like you think she’s a stooge, don’t report it, and the Tory party it becomes the Liberal BBC Bias, and it becomes their story all day.

    Can’t win.

    kerley
    Free Member

    All of this ignores the elephant of Brexit though. The Cons could (and pretty much have) no manifesto and still get an insane amount of votes purely because they claim to “Get Brexit Done”. At one point Brexit Party was polling at 25%.

    Labour having the perfect manifesto but being remain would not get those voters back.

    Exactly. Labour have been in a no win situation since the referendum. The majority of tory voters are pro Brexit so easy to keep them, plus getting some other voters who think Brexit is so important for some reason.
    Labour could have come out as remain and lost even more pro Brexit people.

    As someone said earlier – it seems labour pro brexit people are so keen on brexit they will vote tory to get it whereas pro remain tory voters still vote tory.

    The realisation is that the pro brexit labour voters were probably never voting labour for the right reasons as true labour supporters could in no way vote tory, ever.

    Once Brexit is “done” we will see a change.

    bruneep
    Full Member

    @kimbers that was brutal should’ve had a warning before I clicked on it

    Gowrie
    Free Member

    Cancel A50 – not the right way to stop Brexit IMO

    The only way to stop Brexit. The law says Britain leaves if it doesn’t.

    Apologies. My understanding was that the LDs, if they had got into power, would have cancelled A50, with no further reference to the electorate. I accept that to stop Brexit we have to revoke A50. I think the only acceptable way of sanctioning that is via a second referendum.

Viewing 40 posts - 4,681 through 4,720 (of 6,291 total)

The topic ‘2019 General Election’ is closed to new replies.