Home Forums Chat Forum 2019 General Election

  • This topic has 6,282 replies, 176 voices, and was last updated 4 years ago by kelvin.
Viewing 40 posts - 4,321 through 4,360 (of 6,291 total)
  • 2019 General Election
  • mrwhyte
    Free Member

    The issue with teaching is not getting them in to the profession, it’s getting them to stay once they are in.

    Like every public sector they are trying to do more for far less. Workloads are a huge issue, dealing with many of societies problems and now being teachers and social workers. Unless you work on the underlying issues of why teachers leave, then you’ll just be throwing money at teachers to train for a few years until they leave the profession.

    kimbers
    Full Member

    Tories not doing so bad in Scotland after all

    Bxp ltd collapse saving them

    Which sucks for rest of UK

    outofbreath
    Free Member

    Tories not doing so bad in Scotland after all

    We don’t know how it all translates to seats. The Brexit factor makes this election the least predictable ever.

    kelvin
    Full Member

    mrwhyte is right

    But, of course, fewer teachers means teachers are more stretched, so part of any plan to retain staff is to train more staff (and make it enticing for staff to return to the profession, and to come from other countries). Even more true of nursing (both NHS and in care homes).

    It’s a chicken/egg situation.

    kimbers
    Full Member

    We don’t know how it all translates to seats. The Brexit factor makes this election the least predictable ever

    I agree, but with bxp ltd not standing in Tory seats scot leavers have to go somewhere

    SNP will do well either way, but if Johnson only loses 5 seats in Scotland, that won’t be enough to offset his gain elsewhere

    Tho the Tory candidate in Hastings is doing well ,🤪

    rone
    Full Member

    Ipsos Mori is one of the most extreme with 16pt Tory lead last poll.

    They also polled people’s thoughts on who was having the best campaign – Tories by far – apparently.

    binners
    Full Member

    The continued half-arsed incoherence of the Labour campaign and how easy a ride its giving Johnson is utterly depressing to witness

    rone
    Full Member

    The continued half-arsed incoherence of the Labour campaign and how easy a ride its giving Johnson is utterly depressing to witness

    And they should do what?

    I tell you this – I’ve been involved in the local campaign recently (offering my media services where time allows) filming the local Hustings (which just happened to be hosted by an independent school) and a vote sample was taken – this in a 70% Brexit constituency – widley tipped to go Tory – and Labour were way out in front on the vote. Not what I expected. And this is purely down to the campaigning effort thus far by the Labour PPC / Labour at large.

    kelvin
    Full Member

    Treasury report on Johnson’s Brexit leak today is good.

    Pointing out that the new hospitals promise is a lie so good.

    Pointing out that the additional nurses promise is a lie is good.

    Pointing out that the new GP promise is worthless as similar promises have been made and broken by the same party at the last two elections is good.

    Pointing out that the police staffing promise doesn’t even replace the police that the Tories cut is good.

    Pointing out mental health services for kids have been decimated is good.

    Pointing out A&E waiting times are at an all time high is good.

    Pointing out that any lopsided trade deal with the USA will negatively effect the NHS is good.

    Pointing out that relying on the regulated private sector to provide key infrastructure is holding the UK back is good.

    Pointing out that spending on transport has to shift from road to rail to meet climate objectives is good.

    Pointing out that shifting from gas to renewables has to happen fast to meet climate objectives is good.

    rone
    Full Member

    The trouble is people queue up to reward Boris Johnson’s bad behaviour. That’s the rub. People actively go for his lies. Corbyn could walk on water – but you ain’t doing battle with that irrational logic.

    dazh
    Full Member

    The continued half-arsed incoherence of the Labour campaign

    I think you must be watching a different one to the one I’m seeing.

    binners
    Full Member

    The polls seem to show that most people are watching the same one as me 🙁

    rone
    Full Member

    The polls seem to show that most people are watching the same one as me

    They’re polls – they reflect people’s perception plus possibly out-moded weighting – they’re not a critique on how good a campaign is.

    kelvin
    Full Member

    They are as good an indication as any of how successful the campaign has been so far.

    Of course, voters are swayed by far more than the campaign… everything said or done (or not said and done) before the campaign has set many people down a voting path that last minute campaigns will not shift. Some have bought into the “success” of the swing managed in the 2017 campaign, and think the same level of change is possible again, as if voters will ignore the last two years.

    outofbreath
    Free Member

    a vote sample was taken – this in a 70% Brexit constituency – widley tipped to go Tory – and Labour were way out in front on the vote. Not what I expected.

    +1 My constituency’s the same. Conventioal wisdom says it should go one way, all the evidence I’m seeing (and there’s a fair bit) is that it’s going a completely different way.

    This election is impossible to call. We simply don’t know how the seats are going to fall. (From what I’m hearing I don’t even trust the raw poll data but that’s a seperate issue.)

    rone
    Full Member

    They are as good an indication as any of how successful the campaign has been so far.

    Alright so the fact the gaps have close over the last few weeks would indicate a positive direction?

    kelvin
    Full Member

    Agreed, trying to map national polling to local seats is a fools errand.

    rone
    Full Member

    +1 My constituency’s the same. Conventioal wisdom says it should go one way, all the evidence I’m seeing (and there’s a fair bit) is that it’s going a completely different way.

    What are the particulars – out of curiosity?

    ctk
    Full Member

    A look at the newspaper headlines -every day- would tell you Labour is up against it.

    ctk
    Full Member

    Looking at Scotland data above- is Jo Swinson’s seat safe?

    rone
    Full Member

    A look at the newspaper headlines -every day- would tell you Labour is up against it.

    For sure – we all accept that.

    None of this translates to Binner’s suggestion that the Labour campaign is wonky.

    oldnpastit
    Full Member

    Both main parties are a complete shambles.

    TrailriderJim
    Free Member

    The trouble with these uber-threads is I can’t be arsed to go through to check if the same point has been raised before, but my point with this election is: voting tory seems to be the sensible option to just… get… bl&*dy brexit… done. However, as a remainer (and given only one-third of the voting public voted to leave wayback when), I don’t believe in voting in order to help get brexit done. Whilst everyone is sick and tired of the damned issue, I’d rather we keep driving the bus around in circles, than drive the thing right off the edge, right?

    kelvin
    Full Member

    Brexit can be stopped, or take years. There is no path to it being “done” quickly. It’s yet another appealing but empty nebulous three word slogan.

    mrmonkfinger
    Free Member

    Brexit will be super quick.

    Fixing the absolute cluster fudge that follows it will take decades. A story utterly absent from all Tory horse poo merchants.

    That process will have a new, different, catchy portmanteau name. Probably.

    outofbreath
    Free Member

    What are the particulars – out of curiosity?

    On the surface a very safe blue seat. Lib dems came third last time. Lab 2nd. Leave Majority in the Referendum.

    In contrast to what you’d deduce from the above, the facts on the ground seem to me to be:

    Locally the Red Voters are typically leavers.
    The Blue voters are typically remainers.
    The Blue voters typically think Boris is a joke.
    I can’t find a blue voter – they’ve all openly gone Lib Dem.
    Outside my house I met a Blue Party member who stood as a Blue councillor in the local elections in the summer campaigning for the yellows!
    I can’t find a red voter – I’ve no idea where their votes are going but it isn’t to the red candidate – my gut feel is they’re either not voting or going blue and don’t want to say so.

    I’m convinced the numbers are going to be a real shock, maybe even the result.

    I’m sure there are other places, like yours where the surprise will be a red win. My point is this election can’t be predicted, you can’t tell from national polling where votes in the constituencys are going. I wouldn’t be ruling out any result at all.

    outofbreath
    Free Member

    A look at the newspaper headlines -every day- would tell you Labour is up against it.

    Maybe but the credible media is telling us this is too close to call. If I were you I’d join the stampede away from print media and stick to the mainstream TV/Radio which is far more reliable with far more news and far less ‘comment’.

    slowoldman
    Full Member

    Locally the Red Voters are typically leavers.
    The Blue voters are typically remainers.
    The Blue voters typically think Boris is a joke.

    How do you come to these conclusions if you can’t find any red or blue voters?

    boomerlives
    Free Member

    appealing but empty nebulous three word slogan.

    Which is easier to remember than Labours policy on Brexit.

    What was it again?

    kelvin
    Full Member

    Not as simple as a simple lie.

    kimbers
    Full Member

    Which is easier to remember than Labours policy on Brexit.

    What was it again?

    2nd ref on a Norway deal

    not that hard to figure out, is it?

    molgrips
    Free Member

    The only quick way to get brexit out of the headlines is to remain. If we leave in any terms there’ll be a generation of fighting against our former allies.

    kelvin
    Full Member

    a Norway deal

    It’s not that though, is it.

    But what it isn’t is yet another undeliverable promise from a serial liar. The earliest we will effectively be outside the EU, by Johnson’s own reckoning, is over a year away. Whatever replaces EU membership will not be complete and in place, and returning us to a stable position for businesses and families, for years. Years and years of Brexit negotiations and negative changes for individuals and businesses stretch ahead of us under Johnson.

    ferrals
    Free Member

    THe big issue is, as said above, people no longer care if things are out-right lies if it meet their world view. It’s therefore hard to run a reasonable campaign and get your point across; which is why the tories seem to be doing well by repeating their three-word bullshit mantra.

    Also, I’m not sure how many people are even listenting to the campaigns compared to having decided who they would vote for long before the election was called.

    The big concern for me is the number of people (over a dozen) I’ve spoken to in my constituency (a labour marginal where the differnece when the tories took it in 2015 was under 30 votes) who are intelligent, pro-EU, but are sayign they won’t vote for Corbyn again so will vote liberal (who had a few percent last time). You can blame the media for mis-representing Corbyn as much as you like but it doesnt change the fact he, or people’s impression of him, are putting people off voting labour. I find it mindblowing that people won’t hold there nose and vote tactically in such a key marginal but it seems many won’t.

    boomerlives
    Free Member

    Years and years…stretch ahead of us under Johnson.

    …And Corbyn, sadly.

    There’s a three word mantra Labour should get behind

    kelvin
    Full Member

    (over a dozen)

    Same here. Locally Corbyn is still the block to previous Labour voters voting for the only local candidate that can unseat our no-Deal Brexit advocating Tory MP. I’ve persuaded one or two to hold their noses and back the Labour candidate, but many still will not. One week to go. Keep pressing people to face up to the reality… Johnson must have his majority denied him, vote for whoever can keep your seat out of his hands… try and persuade others to do the same.

    Cougar
    Full Member

    Like every public sector they are trying to do more for far less. Workloads are a huge issue,

    I’ve dated a couple of teachers over the years. Even 15-20 years ago the amount of work they brought home – lesson prep, marking etc – was astonishing. And people think teachers have it easy with long summer holidays (when everything is three times the price). If teachers could claim overtime they’d make an absolute mint.

    Based on a current sample size of “one” it would appear that TAs do more actual work in the classroom itself (though get to walk away from it at 4pm at least).

    I don’t believe in voting in order to help get brexit done. Whilst everyone is sick and tired of the damned issue,

    As others have said, there is no done to be got. If we do leave in whatever fashion it won’t be the end of anything, it’ll just be the beginning.

    kelvin
    Full Member

    Voters have been told that the withdrawal agreement is simply a means for getting Brexit done. A way to make the whole thing stop. They deserve to know, not just that the process would drag on for many years to come, but also that it would harm their country in ways that go far beyond a simple cut in GDP.

    Johnson’s Brexit Deal is Getting No Scrutiny – But it is the Most Damaging Proposal Ever Put to Voters

    ferrals
    Free Member

    @kelvin – agreed, I’m keeping on trying. The message in these cases has to be ‘you’re not voting for Corbyn (zero chance of a majority), you’re voting against boris’

    solarider
    Free Member

    For the first time in my life, I really don’t know who to vote for.

    After 3 years of damaging bickering, I do believe that we need a majority government. Coalitions just tread water and focus on in-fighting rather than moving forward.

    Realistically the vote therefore is for Conservative or Labour. If you don’t want Labour, you have to vote Conservative, otherwise there would be a hung parliament. If you don’t want Conservative, you have to vote Labour as the chance of any of the next tier parties forming a majority government is slim to bugger all.

    I have traditionally voted Conservative, but I am a strong Remainer, and despite associating more with the rest of their policies than Labour, their stance on Brexit is a deal breaker for me.

    If Labour would get off the fence on Brexit they could get my vote, despite Corbin, who I think is a danger to the country. But without that clarity, I cannot vote for them.

    Despite their views on Brexit, the Lib Dems are not a realistic choice to form a majority government.

    So I genuinely have a dilemma. I want to vote as I believe it is a fundamental obligation and a hard fought right that not everybody in the world has. But literally none of the choices represent me, and despite their manifestos and campaigning BS, there won’t be a massive difference between any of them.

    Fundamentally politics is broken. Professionally, as a business we all pull together across functions, nations and roles collaboratively, yet our politics are designed to spin and divide rather than all pulling together for the common good (climate, health, education etc – none of which should be politicised).

    Grrrrrrrrr.

Viewing 40 posts - 4,321 through 4,360 (of 6,291 total)

The topic ‘2019 General Election’ is closed to new replies.