It wasn’t clam-shell though
Nokia massively blew it with Clam Shells – they missed the flippy phone boat by a year and went from being the best selling phones in the world to not even being the best selling phones in Finland as a result.
I really liked my old n73 – reasonably smart but still candy-bar sized. But really my old ip4 is the best phone i’ve had simply because its stayed operational for twice as long as any other phone I’ve owned and, unlike all the other phones I’ve owned previously, it hasn’t filled up with dust, which all the nokias I’ve had, even the supposedly rugged nokias like the 5210, were terrible for.
The old Razr was good – properly strong and hardwearing as well as pretty but massively let down by have the enter and cancel buttons back to front. So nice as an ornament now that I don’t actually use it for anything.