The top of Stanage is very different from even next-door Burbage. Big boulders and peat bog in between. It’s very sloppy so if you believe MTB is a problem in terms of erosion, Stanage is far worse than Burbage/White edge/ Froggat etc. It’s also often packed with walkers and climbers. Plus as you’ve discovered, it’s actually pretty hard to ride and a lot of riders would struggle.
The status quo is fine IMO.
Bamford Clough has also just been tarmaced too (also DCC’s work, like the wanton destruction of Stanage causeway itself).
Argh that’s really annoying. I saw they were doing work but didn’t realise they were gonna ruin it. Still, it might work as an uphill drag? It’s nice and, errr, direct!
I don’t mind the fact they’ve done the causeway, it works well for the gravel bike.