Old
Much beefier and better looking new…
and then a little bit more beefier…
I will just say one thing… ride both as much as you can before buying… and buy for how you ride. Mine is a heavy beast now, perfect for riding in the peak / alps, but totally overkill for many other things. You’ll get fed up of riding it otherwise.
I ended up buying a carbon hardtail, which at the moment I’ve been riding more (mainly because I keep breaking bits off the Five like rear derailures).