Hmm tough one, ive had a few different forks, going from fixed to adjustable travel and back again. Ive gone from Psylos to Pace to 36 Vans to Talas, then RS Totem to U turn Pikes then 36 Float and now im on 180 36 Talas RC2 and i think ive found my perfect AM fork.
I think with the likes of the Rock Shox U Turn and the older 36 Talas’ with 3 stage adjustment, the problem lies within the range of adjustment, as in there was too much of it and us being too lazy too use it all so just leaving it in one place, well that was my excuse anyway.
Having used the new Talas with just 2 options from 180-140mm for a few rides now im sold as the 180mm is too much to go uphill but the dogs danglies for coming down and the drop by 40mm makes uphills i piece of cake. Fair enough some say that the suspension system is not as precise/plush etc but i honestly havent noticed the difference going from fixed Floats to Talas. It all boils down to your type of riding/budget and personal taste i guess.