I’ve had loads of cars and a fair few classics, and have fond memories of almost all of them! I’ve finally worked out that you can’t identify a “great car” in isolation; the roads you’ll be driving on and the use you’ll be putting it to are key factors.
Of all the cars I’ve had the 105 series Alfas (1750 Spider and 2000GTV) were my favourites at the time. Now, though, if I were to revisit anything I’ve had before it would be a Mk1 MR2. Whether they’re a “classic” is moot, but I think it’s fair to call them a “future classic”.
I know they’re a bit marmite, but might be worth a punt? I was a bit “meh” about them until a mate let me drive his, after which I was smitten. They’re a sweet little thing and reasonably fast, with a really characterful engine (designed by Yamaha I think) which effectively runs as a torquey 12v up to 4750rpm and then switches to a 16v revver and goes on to a 7700 red line. The handling is genuinely superb and ride is a real eye-opener – superbly comfortable. Don’t know where you’re based but if really rough back-roads are a regular part of your life, it’s great having something which doesn’t have to make allowances.
They’re also very reliable, will do 30-35mpg all day long, won’t leave you knackered after a 700-mile drive and can carry plenty for a week away (unless you’re traveling with Imelda Marcos). And as you can tell, they can really get under your skin – in a good way!
Only downside is they rust like buggery and the looks (inside and out) haven’t aged well to all eyes.
Having had three I’d say go for the earliest, non T-bar you can find, but as ever with these things that’s just a matter of personal taste and condition should be the main decider. If I didn’t live within spray-range of the sea I’d have another like a shot!
ETA:
After all that, I think I’d be happy to live with pretty much anything mentioned above, too. Some really good shouts. There are so many good cars out there (so little time)….