Regardless of script, plot, acting and cast, some films just seem to ‘be right’ and evoke emotions which far supercede the individual parts, whether those parts be good or bad.
A few of my personal favourites which fit into this category are the two ^^ and off the top of my head……
Animal House
Roadhouse
Rambo (only First Blood)
Gladiator
Master and Commander
Oceans Eleven
I can understand re-makes when technical advances may improve the experience, or make it more realistic but the special effects in Highlander were adequate and a huge part of the success was the Queen soundtrack. I’ll definitely have to see the remakes when they come out and hope they improve on The Italian Job.