Well, when I bought my first proper mtb in 96, it was a C16. It wa head and shoulders better than the other bikes in the shop (Specialised Rockhopper, Marin’s Various). I was sold on it’s ridability. When it was stolen, I didn’t hesitate to replace with a P7, having tried various others, including (from another shop) various Kona and more Specialised.
To me, Orange were about decent steel frames, done right – before even that awful X1 they released.
I’d be in the market for one of their Pure7/P7’s now if I was looking. I had a G2 for a bit when the last p7 was stolen, and, you know, it was alright, but it wasn’t a Steel Orange, regardless of where it came from. Even the dealer told me to buy a Whyte instead!
Don’t get hung up on the filing cabinets, there’s more to Orange than them Fives. Well, there was.