- This topic has 0 replies, 919 voices, and was last updated 4 years ago by Cougar.
-
EU Referendum – are you in or out?
-
roneFull Member
If a GE election does actually happen, and campaigns start to shift attention away from Brexit and the NHS under the Brexit party is tackled you will see completely different results.
There are other things than Brexit that people will vote on.
kelvinFull MemberIf there is a snap election just a few weeks before we are due to crash out, Brexit policy will be everything. Another election will be along again before we know it soon after that anyway. Probably within a year. If we’ve left by the time that happens, then what the hell we do next as regards Brexit will still be everything. If instead we’ve cancelled Brexit, well only then is there any chance that it won’t be one of the key motivators for voters, and parties can concentrate on everything else that we should be doing now.
Anyway… tariffs…
As some are still trying to pretend otherwise, again, for the record: No hope of avoiding tariffs in 'no deal' Brexit: EU's Malmstrom | Article [AMP] | Reuters https://t.co/IHC5q8VSQg
— Sabine Weyand (@WeyandSabine) June 22, 2019
kimbersFull Memberyet the labour party still dont get it
https://www.mirror.co.uk/news/politics/brexit-poll-reveals-vast-majority-16902164?
edhornbyFull MemberLabour have a conflict in their party, as do the tories. Labour have a spineless leader, as do the tories. I’m not sure which party will implode first.
binnersFull MemberThere was one of Corbyns apparatchiks on Pienaar’s Politics yesterday. It was painful listening to the convoluted nonsense he was waffling on about with regards to going back to Brussels and renegotiating a ‘jobs first Brexit’
Then they had Liz Truss on detailing Borises Brexit strategy. It was painful listening to the convoluted nonsense she was waffling on about with regards to going back to Brussels and renegotiating a ‘cake and eat it Brexit’.
They’re both treating us like idiots by proposing policies that are entirely unicorn-based and will implode on the first contact with reality.
dazhFull MemberBrexit policy will be everything.
No it won’t. You may be obsessed with it, but there are huge numbers of people who don’t give a shit about it and care more about day to day issues like schools having enough money and being able to get a GP appointment. At best they actually see brexit as a distraction from these other issues and at worst they see it – membership of the EU and failure to leave that is – as complicit. They may be wrong, which they are, but it doesn’t change the fact that the next election will not be fought on brexit alone.
pihaFree MemberBrexit policy will be everything.
dazh Subscriber
No it won’t.
The recent polls that put TBP way ahead of the tories suggest otherwise. Politics is all about Brexit at the moment.
The tory membership are about to vote for someone to be their leader that offers little apart from a (a No Deal Brexit) single issue and a possible defeat for TBP and to a lesser degreee Jeremys Labour party. And lets not forget that Bojo was unelectable 3 years ago and fled the leadership race.
kelvinFull MemberA reminder that the Brexit “Party” is no such thing, and is just the latest means for transforming the Conservative Party into the new UKIP…
WATCH | "The result is a foregone conclusion" – @Nigel_Farage praises our hugely successful Blue Wave initiative, which recruited tens of thousands of true Brexiteers into the Tory Party and guarantees Brexit Boris in Number 10!
Help support our work at https://t.co/ntwXbJeHQw pic.twitter.com/6ClSjnpKyw
— Leave.EU (@LeaveEUOfficial) June 24, 2019
Politics is all about Brexit at the moment.
And if we were due to fall out of the EU with no deal a few weeks after a snap election, then Brexit policy will be even more keenly scrutinised by voters than it is now. There will be no room for hiding behind constructive ambiguity.
tjagainFull MemberJust to point out that labour policy although still evolving is for a second ref on any deal. This is agreed by corbyn
kelvinFull MemberWith a Remain option? Even after a general election that results in a Labour government?
torsoinalakeFree MemberPolitics is all about Brexit at the moment
And even if you think it isn’t – there is probably a rude awakening on the horizon.
https://twitter.com/JamesMelville/status/1143122412780892160
tjagainFull MemberSubscriber
With a Remain option? Even after a general election that results in a Labour government?Yes
PJayFree MemberI did participate in this thread a while back, but I’m not aware of recent posts, so sorry if this has been covered, but with Boris potentially becoming Prime Minister & threatening to take us out of Europe without a deal if necessary I’m wondering where this leaves Northern Ireland.
The Power Sharing Executive has been down for a couple of years, ostensibly as Sinn Fein won’t work with Arleene Foster (DUP) who doesn’t seem bothered by this and is staying put; she’s now playing power politics with Brexit. During this time there have been some alarming developments in Northern Ireland including bombings and the murder of Lyra McKee; dissident republicanism seems to be making a re-appearance.
Presumably if we leave the EU without a deal, a hard border in NI becomes inevitable cutting off the country and isolating it from Ireland; the DUP probably aren’t bothered about this but I can’t imagine Sinn Fein being too please along with the dissident republicans.
Boris might feel that he’s best buddies with Donald Trump and consequently could negotiate a favourable trade deal with the US but I assume that he’d need the support of the House of Representatives whose Speaker (if I recall correctly), Nancy Pelosi has told the UK (during a trip to Ireland) to forget a trade deal if the Good Friday Agreement is threatened, so there’s the potential for renewed troubles in Northern Ireland & no deals with either the EU or US.
The Tories seem to be colluding in this madness to stay in power with the (fickle) support of the DUP.
Assuming that I haven’t gotten my facts wrong (perfectly possible), is this a realistic possibility? It doesn’t feel terribly encouraging.
kelvinFull MemberYes
Thanks for clearing that up TJ.
🤡
It doesn’t feel terribly encouraging.
Not breaking up North/South cooperation is essential to get a trade deal with either the EU or the USA. There may well be measures that could have been agreed to which could ensure this, and still let us Leave the EU… but that kind of Brexit has been off the cards for over two years now… and, no, not because of anything said or done by EU officials or heads of state… but by the choices made by our PM and leader of the opposition.
And even if you think it isn’t – there is probably a rude awakening on the horizon.
And there we go. He knows the damage ahead, but feels it can’t be stopped, because of 2016. At one point he was saying that another vote may have to occur. No chance of sticking to that if you want to be the leader of the party that used to be the Conservative Party.
mrmonkfingerFree MemberThere’s “respect democracy” in action. You asked for it, so let’s slash the seats and burn the place down. They all know it will be a disaster but are still pushing it.
Useless, useless, useless Tw*nts.
CougarFull MemberAssuming that I haven’t gotten my facts wrong (perfectly possible), is this a realistic possibility? It doesn’t feel terribly encouraging.
The Good Friday Elephant In The Room Agreement aside, it’s written into the Withdrawal Agreement that there cannot be a hard border in Northern Ireland (and that’s legally binding unless it subsequently gets amended). It’s just one more paradoxical impossibility in the gamut of brexit unicorns.
kiloFull MemberGiven that the majority in the north voted to remain in the EU I’m not sure a hard brexit and the resulting chaos in the economy and agriculture will aid DUP in the long run and may accelerate a united Ireland. I think they’ve been expecting the EU to blink first – they’re not exactly the sharpest tools.
binnersFull MemberJust to point out that labour policy although still evolving is for a second ref on any deal. This is agreed by corbyn
My policy is to go vegan one day to save the environment and all the animals and all that. Honestly. I really mean it. I really will get around to it at some point…
Could you just pass me that steak bake……
CougarFull MemberThat Leave.EU tweet is absolutely astonishing. They’re openly boasting that they’ve stuffed tens of thousands of brexies into the party membership in order to rig the vote. How is that even legal?
How does this sit with your average leaver’s supposed desire for democracy? Is this what they voted for?
binnersFull MemberNot breaking up North/South cooperation is essential to get a trade deal with either the EU or the USA.
Tearing up a legally binding international treaty (which the Good Friday Agreement is) would leave us a North Korea style pariah state who nobody would do business with, as we simply could no longer be trusted to honour any treaties we signed.
International law is there for a reason. You can’t just rip up the bits of it you don’t like on the say so of your hardline nutters
kelvinFull MemberI think TJ should be given the mission of getting out there and telling Labour MPs that they’ve spent 3 years pushing against an open door, and that Jeremy already supports the position that they’re still repeatingly calling for him to move to…
Labour MP @MPphilwilson tells BBC @jeremycorbyn must get behind a second Brexit referendum this week or lose more votes in the north pic.twitter.com/xb0qv6HTg8
— Michael Wild (@michael_wildbbc) June 24, 2019
kelvinFull MemberI think this thread could do with a healthy dose of Clegg bashing… to balance things up a bit… get stuck in…
“It is difficult to get a man to understand something, when his £7 million Silicon Valley house and £1m annual salary depends upon his not understanding it!” – Upton Sinclair https://t.co/FLGQqAD0uy
— Peter Jukes (@peterjukes) June 24, 2019
binnersFull MemberClegg bashing you say? Like Nick Cohen in yesterdays Observer
Sapped by Brexit, it’s little wonder we dream of doing a Nick Clegg
Clegg said Brexit was a battle that had to be won, then fled the field as the struggle began.
crazy-legsFull MemberCorbyn in PMQ now asking about the disaster of crashing out with No Deal. Perhaps he gets it…
dissonanceFull MemberHow is that even legal?
Because they are private organisations which can choose their membership (lawsuits not withstanding). Same way that Labour had a bunch of right wingers join a while back.
In theory the tories probably should be able to boot some of them out if they are shown to be supporting another party but lot of hassle to get to.
.binnersFull MemberSame way that Labour had a bunch of right wingers join a while back
Derek Hatton?
kelvinFull MemberNothing new on Newsnight then… same twaddle from Johnson and his team as they’ve been pedalling for years… the EU won’t damage themselves by making our exit from the Single Market and Customs Union change how we trade with them.
fingerbangFree MemberScary stuff from Bernard jenkin on last nights newsnight. Emily maitlis probably felt like Sharon Tate looking at that glassy eyed fanaticism
kelvinFull MemberThe question she should have asked him (skipping over the fact that it is imaginary money he’s suggesting we spend propping up all the effected industries)…
“If our response to other countries applying their WTO tariffs and schedules to us, which they are obliged to do, is to heavily increase state subsidies for farming, manufacturing and other exporting industries, then, under WTO ‘rules’, the other countries are allowed to take reciprocal steps to further disadvantage our exporters. A trade war would soon be under way. As a supposed supporter of free trade, why would you act so as to trigger this?”
binnersFull MemberBoris peddling the same old unicorns this morning. That we’ll be withholding the divorce payment and then he’ll go back and renegotiate the removal of the backstop. Blah, blah, blah…
They must be shaking their heads in disbelief in Brussels
Don’t waste the extension?
PJayFree MemberThe Good Friday Elephant In The Room Agreement aside, it’s written into the Withdrawal Agreement that there cannot be a hard border in Northern Ireland (and that’s legally binding unless it subsequently gets amended).
The Good Friday Elephant In The Room Agreement aside, it’s written into the Withdrawal Agreement that there cannot be a hard border in Northern Ireland (and that’s legally binding unless it subsequently gets amended).
Sorry for my naivete but are we saying that, legally, we can’t leave the EU without a deal as doing so would place a hard border in Northern Ireland (I’m assuming, but don’t know, that the EU wouldn’t countenance a non-secured, open boarder between itself & a non-EU country)?
If this is the case, is anyone challenging the no-dealers with this (I’m afraid that I’m sick to the back teeth with brexit politics & the tory party & tend to turn over when they’re on)?
kelvinFull MemberIt’s not just the Good Friday Agreement, the EU is very keen to have North/South cooperation protected in any agreement they have with us. For obvious reasons.
Hi @kefkat12 Clause 10 Withdrawal Act 2018 'Continuation of North-South co-operation & prevention of new border arrangements' is legal. Fascinated to see what @BorisJohnson / Tories will do re #NoDealBrexithttps://t.co/QknxVZviOe@BBCPolitics@SkyNewsPolitics@itvpeston@Peston pic.twitter.com/CI2IRiORkY
— Gina Miller (@thatginamiller) June 20, 2019
molgripsFree MemberYes, and yes, but the problem with modern politics is none of that seems to matter. Power on this topic has been handed to the people who have absolutely the least idea what any of the implications are. Good job, Dave.
kelvinFull MemberIt might not matter when it comes to picking our leaders… but it does matter to the EU… and it’ll still matter to them after we have left. If we want a relationship of any kind with the whole of the continent, then we can’t just screw Ireland, even if enough Brits support us doing so.
torsoinalakeFree MemberIf this is the case, is anyone challenging the no-dealers with this (I’m afraid that I’m sick to the back teeth with brexit politics & the tory party & tend to turn over when they’re on)?
This is a really interesting take on why they get away with it.
Thread: When will people realise that with this GATT Article XXIV row we're simply re-running the Vote Leave playbook from the 2016 referendum? Cast your minds back to 2016, when the main thing infuriating fact checkers was the £350m on the side of the Vote Leave bus 1/
— Ed Conway (@EdConwaySky) June 25, 2019
PJayFree MemberI think that they also get away with it because, sadly, 50% of the population seem to want and therefore accept) what they’re peddling.
I don’t know whether part of the growing wave of nationalism & populism in world politics but a report I saw this morning was suggesting that however chaotic & bumbling Boris is, he’s likely to win out due to his own “Trump effect” and I’m rather scared at where it all seems to be heading.
MSPFull MemberI’m rather scared at where it all seems to be heading.
This, I actually now think we are heading to WWIII, it is the only way the populists can keep blaming everyone else. The lies just seem so obvious but they keep peddling them and there are clearly enough believers for them to win elections.
At least having **** all pension and not getting on the housing ladder won’t matter.
binnersFull MemberA Belgium MEP has just been on Radio 4 debunking all Boris and Hunts magical proposals for renegotiating the withdrawal agreement and stating a few home truths about a No Deal Brexit.
A No Deal would leave the UK in Breech of the terms of the Good Friday Agreement, which would facilitate a hard border between north and south in Ireland, as the EU cannot have an open border.
Once we’d willingly defaulted on our obligations under international law we would then be a pariah state who nobody would sign any trade deals with as they wouldn’t be worth the paper they were written on. The Americans have already pointed this out, repeatedly.
It seems these lunatics really are prepared to thoroughly trash this country’s reputation (or what’s left of it) with their twisted English nationalism
The topic ‘EU Referendum – are you in or out?’ is closed to new replies.