I think the main question about this bike is whether the Isospeed decoupler makes a noticeable difference or if its a gimmick? If its a gimmick, there are several similar XC race bikes in the price range which have a better spec, are lighter etc.
I looked into this and found really conflicting accounts both anecdotally from owners and from professional bike reviewers. There were a bunch of people saying Isospeed is great and comfortable, while others saying they couldn’t notice it. One reviewer seemed to have done more work testing it than others, and said it basically felt equivalent to reducing your tire pressure by 0.2-0.3 psi IIRC.
It’s a nice looking bike but the proprietary nature of the Isospeed and the knock block puts me off. It looks like the newer version gets rid of these and makes several other changes too. If the Isospeed is really that great, why have Trek removed it and replaced it with an “Isobow” technology on the new version?
I did give the Procaliber and the Xcaliber a test ride and I didn’t notice much difference so I went for the cheaper and less proprietary Xcaliber. But I’m very far from a racer, and a complete novice to MTB at the time so wouldn’t be able to detect marginal differences.