Revisiting this thread, I’m really chuffed to see the love for the Mk2 Golf, at the time I owned mine, my old man had a Saab 9000, with a famously sober dash layout and I honestly preferred the ergonomics in my Golf – humble, easy to reach and never got in the way when you were lift-off oversteering round a bend.
Alfa Romeo…
I’ve had a 156 V6 Sport, a 147 Lusso and finally a 159. The 156 looked gorgeous, the binnacle was straight out of a Lamborghini Miura but the plastics were a tad Airfix. The 147 was leagues ahead, with excellent materials the equal of an equivalent VW (I know, I drove a lot of VW loan cars while my Golf was being fixed), gadgets worked well and it fitted my athletic frame but it lacked a little charm.
My 159?
Well, the passenger experience is amazing. Leather trimmed with quilted matching door panels, everything has an expensive feel and smell (as it should, a replacement gear knob is £138.94 from Alfa). The switches feel nicely tactile, the controls just so, you’d be forgiven for thinking you were sat in an Audi or early noughties Merc…
…But the column stalks feel cheap, cheaper than the 147 and 156. The dash is a quality item, but the cruise control will hit your right knee, unless you have the classic Italian driver shape of long arms, short legs and small feet, which I don’t. The gear lever blocks the aircon controls if you’re in 3rd or 5th, the throttle travel is long but it’s a front wheel drive GM based saloon that you can heel-and-toe with happy abandon.
The piece de resistance? The boot release is in the roof, a la Alfa 33. Albeit, it’s well made, reliable and a delight to use, but it’s in the **** roof…
Sorry, but VW had it sorted in 1983.