An open reply to Julian McIntosh
REF: http://singletrackworld.com/forum/topic/avalanche
Hi Julian,
It’s clear from your Facebook posts that you really haven’t understood what Hotlinking is. It’s absolutely NOT copying of images. The images have not been downloaded from your pages and stored elsewhere, a fact that can simply be demonstrated by you removing the images from your Facebook page, as I advised, and watching all the places on the internet where they are displayed simply disappear and be replaced with an error message or a little blue square. If they had been copied as you seem convinced they have been, then you removing them from your Facebook page would have no effect on their appearance elsewhere.
Also, I should point out that the reply that you have posted on your own personal Facebook page is from me. I’m a Director here at Singletrack. That reply was not from one of our team of volunteer moderators.
And for the record, had you not shrouded your original email in the misjudged pretence of a legal threat (Who uses the word ‘noon’ anyway?) at 10am on a bank holiday, then you would likely have received a much more sympathetic response that may have included such helpful dialogue as, ‘If it’s simply an issue of credit then why don’t we just add a credit and link to the OP’s post to clear things up?’.
While we, as a publisher are very sympathetic to the misuse of anyone’s images and would never deliberately breach anyone’s claim to copyright (we also appreciate that the misuse of hotlinking and copyright is a controversial issue) we are also prepared to stand up against anyone who’s opening gambit to any dialogue consists of veiled legal threats against either us or our registered forum users.
And finally, having had hotlinking explained to you several times now and how the control of your own hotlinked images is within your control, why are the images still visible on our forum?
And in case there’s any doubt, the above can simply be summed up as – Don’t start throwing veiled legal threats and setting deadlines as an opening volley when you could have simply been polite and asked us to look at it. On a Bank holiday FFS!
Cheers
Mark