Home Forums Bike Forum 500 watts for 5 minutes? Anyone done it?

  • This topic has 153 replies, 77 voices, and was last updated 3 years ago by jonba.
Viewing 40 posts - 41 through 80 (of 154 total)
  • 500 watts for 5 minutes? Anyone done it?
  • J-R
    Full Member

    I see the fastest time up the Alpe du Zwift is 28mins at 503W.

    Personally I’d be happy to do 500W for 28seconds.

    Garry_Lager
    Full Member

    It’s prob quite rare, even amongst pros. On the one hand, if strong amateurs can dish out 400+ for 5 mins then obviously some pros can do 500, given the geometric progression in ability as you go up the levels.

    But to do this raw wattage you’d need to be a big strong man and almost all pros are sub 80 kg. Stijn VDB and Taylor Phinney are low 80s and look(ed) like giants in the peloton. Outside of the velodrome it might be an unusual physiology to see in road racing.

    TiRed
    Full Member

    Pros average surprisingly normal power outputs when riding in the bunch on stage races. In fact, you would be surprised how low and would likely be able to achieve that with club-level road fitness. What they can do is 1) recover daily, 2) turn it up when the road goes up. A few can really turn it up in the last 500m.

    I’m a diesel. 200W. 12hr is my best (2.9 W/kg when race trim). I have little top end and can’t sprint to save my life!

    jon2
    Free Member

    Can you translate for those of us who aren’t roadies? How much is 500 watts in football pitches?

    I don’t know anything about football but in biking terms 500W for anything longer than a minute is absolutely hauling and I think there is some dodgy calibration going on with some of the posts above. I did a lab test (ramp test) a long time ago at peak fitness and managed 484W, peaking just over 500W for the last minute which is ignored in that test. At the time I had FTP of around 350W and although of course a heavier rider than my 63kg would produce more power, I would be surprised if there are more than a handful of riders in the country who can manage 500W for 3 mins and certainly not for 5 mins.

    For comparison just over 500W for 3 mins will win you the national hill climb championships https://www.cyclingweekly.com/news/latest-news/dan-evans-national-championship-hill-climb-2014-strava-ride-141454

    An absolute machine like Filippo Ganna will manage 500W for 10 minutes but his power output is on a different level to even most of the other pros https://www.strava.com/activities/3567142726/analysis/5290/5871

    steve_b77
    Free Member

    Nowhere near, according to the “gospel” that is Zwift Power I’m on 310W for 5 mins and only a bit less in reality at 272W for 20mins, but my 60min power isn’t much less than my 20min power, guess that’s why I’ve been OK at 12 & 24hr stuff previously. FYI I’m 78kg at the mo and down to 74kg in race mode.

    For comparison just over 500W for 3 mins will win you the national hill climb championships

    Not if you weigh 95+kg it won’t. Wattage is pretty meaningless it’s W/kg that matters as soon as the road is anything other than flat.

    yohandsome
    Free Member

    I see the fastest time up the Alpe du Zwift is 28mins at 503W.

    But it’s not by people verified on zwiftpower? so it doesn’t count IMO. Not sure how much faith id put into those results, could have hacked trainers, use trainers that give watts too easily etc. I haven’t seen anyone getting close to those numbers on zwiftpower and we’re looking at the top guys up to 100 kg.

    An absolute machine like Filippo Ganna will manage 500W for 10 minutes but his power output is on a different level to even most of the other pros https://www.strava.com/activities/3567142726/analysis/5290/5871

    525 watts for 13 minutes actually, beast.

    jon2
    Free Member

    Not if you weigh 95+kg it won’t. Wattage is pretty meaningless it’s W/kg that matters as soon as the road is anything other than flat.

    True. I meant it as an example of how hard 500W is, for the previous poster who asked for a football pitches measurement, and it’s true that a pro level 85kg rider wouldn’t find it so intense, but it’s still out of reach for almost everyone whatever their weight.

    finbar
    Free Member

    500W for anything longer than a minute is absolutely hauling

    Quoted for truth. I can’t even do it for a minute (65kg).

    chakaping
    Full Member

    Sounds like a ridiculously high figure to me, and I’d be very impressed if any non-professional could achieve that.

    Apart from Daffy, who must put out those kind of figures on his commutes, obvs.

    😉

    chakaping
    Full Member

    500W for anything longer than a minute is absolutely hauling

    Quoted for truth. I can’t even do it for a minute (65kg).

    If Wattbikes are accurate, I could maybe hold it for five seconds or so.

    robbo1234biking
    Free Member

    I have managed 450w for one minute, 323w for 5 minutes. I think my power curve is quite flat though. I am aiming to hit a 300w ftp – I don’t think I am for off. There is a dip in my power curve at about 18.5 mins which means a bit more endurance and I should make it (in theory).

    Couldn’t imagine doing 500w for 5 mins!

    ianpv
    Free Member

    In recent years 502 is my one minute best, 365 my peak 5 min. 68-73kg depending on beer. Not that close to those numbers this year…349w peak 5 min and about 450w peak 1 min

    DanW
    Free Member

    Around 500W for 5 minutes for the British Hill climb champ at 65kg just messing around for the cameras

    Slightly longer segment with a bit of flat at the top and Feather did it at 462W for a little over 6 minutes.
    https://www.strava.com/segments/1393060

    So anyone here who isn’t porky and reckons they have a 500W 5 min CP should be right up there with the National best

    My 5 min CP is 4.5W/kg which Coggan’s chart has me as “Good” (which is consistent with my FTP but my 1 min CP is way off) and I can tell you that is not anywhere near 500W even at a higher than average weight 🙂

    benman
    Free Member

    My numbers are super flat – 400W for 1 min and 300W for 20min. Not even held 500W for 15 secs.

    Need to work on my strength! 63kg weakling ;p

    n0b0dy0ftheg0at
    Free Member

    I surprised myself in April, up the final nasty little incline I sometimes do on the road bike, often the way I come home from work too on the commuter because I’m sadistic. Easily my best 60-75sec power of the last few years, 578W scaling down to 503W (7.5 to 6.6 W/Kg at the time), 500W+ 1min efforts are definitely not my forte!
    https://www.strava.com/activities/3347515536/overview

    continuity
    Free Member

    Checking my intervals.icu my PB 5min is 482, but it was 502 for about 3m50. I was about 75 at the time. My power trails off pretty quickly though; down to around 340-350 threshold. That’s on about 4-6hrs a week on avg?

    thecaptain
    Free Member

    As a student I could do 400W for 8 mins, it was a standard test (and not a particularly impressive number, plenty could do better). On a rowing machine (2500m on a CII erg), which may or may not be easier/harder than cycling but I’d expect about the same.

    30+ years later quite pleased to be not all that far off at 350 for 8 mins cycling. And I’m 5kg lighter.

    DrP
    Full Member

    I reckon if I was sensible (not going OVER 500W) I could hold 500w for a minute..
    Will see as on zwift currently…

    Just doing a workout.. Will try after..

    DrP

    Edit…Ok… about 520w for the 30 second free ride section… yeah… a min will be tough!

    Ewan
    Free Member

    According to Strava my best for 500w this year was 1:37 at 71kg, the climb ran out (and I started much higher than 500) so maybe I could have done a little longer at a steadier pace but 5 minutes is insane! FTP is about 300w for what it’s worth.

    stevious
    Full Member

    Can you translate for those of us who aren’t roadies? How much is 500 watts in football pitches?

    It’s approximately the weight of an adult elephant.

    robbo1234biking
    Free Member

    @DrP – should be easy for you, just use the ‘other power meter’ that takes you up the epic KOM in 5 mins

    slowoldman
    Full Member

    Going back to the Coggan’s chart, a straight line across would be a theoretical all-rounder. In fact real riders can’t read straight across, your performance moves around in the rows depending on your particular strengths. Power Profiling

    So it is possible for say a track sprinter to have a power output near the top of the left hand column but lower down for the longer durations. That’s why yohandsome’s 700W for 5 minutes guy couldn’t win the TdF.

    The correct use of the chart is to test yourself for each of those durations to find your own profile which then tends to indicate where your strengths lie (if you don’t already know).

    forked
    Free Member

    I can’t do it these days, but looking at my notes, my best 5 minute power was 481 Watts, which was about 7W/kg. I only really took notes of (not tested) 5 minute power during the hill climb season though, which is when I was lightest.

    molgrips
    Free Member

    Someone won a Zwift race I was on recently with an average power of something like 360W. Impressive, but he was listed as 105kg. If you’re all muscle then you will be producing big numbers but it won’t make you a pro because you weight so much.

    Making big numbers whilst weighing 65kg is the trick!

    yohandsome
    Free Member

    That’s why yohandsome’s 700W for 5 minutes guy couldn’t win the TdF.

    Let’s make some guesstimates here. Conservatively estimating FTP to be 80% of 5 minute power = 560W and bodyweight 100 kg.

    Let’s say the avg gradient of de tour is 2.5%, then for each 10 kgs weight loss a rider has to do 5% less work. A 60 kg rider would need to do 20% less work than our 100 kg beast, to best him they would need a 450W FTP.

    The beast’s watts pr kg is still just a meager 5.6, whereas the 450W FTP 60 kg climbing god would need to hit 7.5 watts pr kg to beat him.

    Watts pr kg only makes a big difference on steep hills and is a silly way to compare riders’ capabilities outside of pure hill climbing.

    fdfd

    DanW
    Free Member

    That is wrong on so many levels especially when related to *Le* Tour, the dynamics of riding in a team, where stages are won, how the GC is won, how W/kg work, etc, etc but hey 🙂

    yohandsome
    Free Member

    The conclusion is still likely right even though the details are let’s say grossly simplified. 700 watts for 5 minutes is so insane and there’s no way this person also wouldn’t have a beastly FTP (you need good endurance for 5 min!).

    People focus too much on watts pr kg..

    DanW
    Free Member

    For a flat, non technical road race, racing as an individual (eg flat TT) then mega Watts regardless of weight is a huge advantage but the less powerful lighter rider *could* also still be faster due to being more aero. Whatever scenario you dream up total power never trumps everything regardless of all other factors. You can take your argument further to say people focus too much on power and fitness as the only judge of progress or success is race results and that is all anyone should focus on 😉

    thegeneralist
    Free Member

    Let’s say the avg gradient of de tour is 2.5%, then for each 10 kgs weight loss a rider has to do 5% less work. A 60 kg rider would need to do 20% less work than our 100 kg beast, to best him they would need a 450W FTP.

    Can someone explain these numbers to me?
    Or are they junk?

    yohandsome
    Free Member

    Ballpark correct based on the equation:

    Power needed to go up a hill (watts) = gravitational constant 9.8 (m/sec^2) * gradient in %/100 * total mass (kg) * speed on the road (m/s)

    To take a more realistic comparison, comparing Ganna (rider 1) assuming his FTP is 480 watts to a lighter shorter 65 kg rider, it actually looks like a smaller rider like Remco _could_ beat him if they can hit 400W FTP due to aero advantages (Cd the same, A calculated from height and weight).

    fdfd

    Comparing a 20 km/h climb it actually looks like you’d need to get well above 10 degrees for Remco to gain an advantage over Ganna.

    fd

    jonba
    Free Member

    In road racing there’s normally a kick to establish a gap before the 5 minute effort. So you have to stand up, hit 8-10W/kg for long enough to get a gap then sit back down and hold 5-6 to grow then settle down to something you can maintain for the duration of the race.

    It’s what makes Pros so impressive. You look at their 5 minute power and realise they can do it at the end of a stage on week three of racing. Or the numbers they put out in sprint are after a threshold effort in the last few km.

    I think weight is less of an issue amongst lean riders as it is mostly just down to height and body type. It’s more likely a problem amongst us mere mortals where its a bit of extra padding.

    sockpuppet
    Full Member

    Let’s say the avg gradient of de tour is 2.5%, then for each 10 kgs weight loss a rider has to do 5% less work. A 60 kg rider would need to do 20% less work than our 100 kg beast, to best him they would need a 450W FTP.

    The beast’s watts pr kg is still just a meager 5.6, whereas the 450W FTP 60 kg climbing god would need to hit 7.5 watts pr kg to beat him.

    Watts pr kg only makes a big difference on steep hills and is a silly way to compare riders’ capabilities outside of pure hill climbing.

    The maths there might be right, I haven’t checked.

    But that’s not how a grand tour is raced. It isn’t a few hundred km of a gradual slope.

    The flat sections are dominated by riding in a peloton where on,y those on the front are working. Those drafting are saving energy & trying to avoid silly crashes taking them out or losing them time.

    Unless it’s a cross tail wind when it’s chaos & fascinating to watch.

    Rarely is much time made between favourites on the flat stages.

    The TTs have some relevance to the data above, but really they’re down to aero not power output alone.

    Then there’s the hills – the steepest bits ridden at the slowest speeds and with least aero benefit from drafting have a disproportionate affect on the outcome, and that *is* down to w/kg and to the ability to recover.

    yohandsome
    Free Member

    I realized that Remco has beat Ganna 3 out of 3 times, and it’s said his FTP is up to 420w so that makes sense.

    Nobeerinthefridge
    Free Member

    I reckon I could nail 500 wotsits in 5 minutes, easy.

    tpbiker
    Free Member

    I think I’m a competent club cyclist. My best 5 min power was about 5 watts per kilo, or close to 330 watts at 66kg. Scaling that up I’d need to be 100 kg to put out 500 watts at the same watts per kilo. There probably aren’t many 100 kg roadies out there.

    However..

    I reckon a good competitive amateur roadie would be able to put out around 6w/kg for that period of time (coggan’s chart appears to agree with me). To hit 500 watts they’d then need to be around 84 kg, which whilst big for a roadie isn’t unheard of.

    So yeah, I reckon 500 watts for 5 min is probably doable by most large built cat 1 roadies out there.

    For me it would be a distant dream however.

    yohandsome
    Free Member

    Here’s 1927 watts for 25 seconds https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mqRsMG46z0I

    mjsmke
    Full Member

    No chance for me. Too light at 58kg.

    thegeneralist
    Free Member

    Let’s say the avg gradient of de tour is 2.5%, then for each 10 kgs weight loss a rider has to do 5% less work. A 60 kg rider would need to do 20% less work than our 100 kg beast, to

    Why 5% less & 20% less?

    yohandsome
    Free Member

    He’s 4×10 kg heaver so 4×5% = 20%. It’s ballpark correct even when factoring in the probable height and in turn drag difference, look:

    djflexure
    Full Member

    I’m very average club rider but heavier at 90kg and short surges is what I’m best at
    Managed 500w for 2:24 in the last couple of weeks
    5 min power was 420 but that’s not max as 10 min power was similar
    These were indoor rides on a Kickr

Viewing 40 posts - 41 through 80 (of 154 total)

The topic ‘500 watts for 5 minutes? Anyone done it?’ is closed to new replies.