The traditions suck and rob us of great racing. Sean Kelly said during his Eurosport commentary “Nibali was right to attack”
I think it’s right if it’s down to misfortune out of your control – Evans puncturing due to tacks on the road, Wiggins slowed the field down (except for Rolland who didn’t realise). Lance got yanked off the bike by a spectator’s musette and they waited for him (and he then rode straight past them, he never did have any class).
In the Contador/Mandy Schleck scenario I was all for contador; Mandy fluffed a gear change, went small-small and dropped the chain so some rider error, and manufacturers make big claims (having spent big $$$ sponsoring pro teams) about their kit, so the technology is just as relevant. They’re not all riding around on standardised bikes and kit.
In the Froome/Nibali scenario, if that fugly Pinerello struggles to clear stones then tough luck, but Nibbles gave credibility to the idea of their being an unwritten rule by saying “I didn’t see him, it’s his word against mine, not saying any more so ner ner”, when he should have said “I’d always planned to attack to win a stage to save my tour, I’m no threat to his GC position, so why the hell wouldn’t I attack then?!”.
Nibali’s problem is also that he already proved he was a classless git by throwing a water bottle at Froome when Tony Martin caused a crash.