You can't speak the truth any more…

Doesn’t mean it is…..
And with no evidence (as is usually required when making accusations like this) she hasn’t a leg to stand on. She’s a hateful, intolerant, bigot.

I swear I saw her fighting with that asshat down at the allotment yesterday.

In her Forum 13 lecture Scheper-Hughes discussed the two motivations of Israeli traffickers. One was greed, she said. The other was somewhat chilling: “Revenge, restitution—reparation for the Holocaust.”

She was accompanied by the Laurel & Hardy theme tune.

Dark chocco Hobnobs! OMG!!

That’s just typical of the criticism we are up against – any proposal is just rejected as an attempt to nobble the peace process with the dark arts. I am disgusted by your innuendo and disgraceful slang.

What’s this country coming to when a House of Lords peer can’t make an ill-informed, juvenile proclamation on foreign affairs?
She’s obviously not fit for frontline politics, but these sort of alehouse statements are par for the course in the Lords – bit harsh to get the boot.

She’s a hateful, intolerant, bigot.

well you would recognis one 😉

Opposition to what Israel has done/does does not make you a bigot
Being intolerant of injustices that state dishes out on a daily basis to the palestinian population in terms of illegal land grabs, illegal settlements etc or opposin git killing peole abroad is not hateful its callef justice and the law

Without the US veto there would be an extraordinary amount of UN resolutions against this country –iirc USA has the most vetos of any country and the majority are Israel related

You cannot just defend Israel carte blanche becasue it has the right to exist — we can reasonably expect it to act reasonably and within International law
Criticising its actions does not make you hateful it make you dislike oppresssion whoever does it

The Peer seemed top be syaing the US funding would not last forever not Israel
It is odd even in the UK you cannot criticise Israel without knee jerk reactions but we can portray Iran as anything we like…mmm interesting

Whatever your views on Israel she has a lot of form, verging on anti-semitism.

Tonge said in 2006: “The pro-Israeli lobby has got its grips on the western world, its financial grips. I think they’ve probably got a grip on our party.”

She means Jews.

I first heard of her when she came out with the old “If I was a Palestinian I might become a suicide bomber too…..”

Those numbers on the growth of religious fundamentalism in Israel are scary. I just dont get religion.

Interesting if not particularly related article about Haredi Jews in London

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/religion/8326339/Inside-the-private-world-of-Londons-ultra-Orthodox-Jews.html

well you would recognis one

It would seem so junkyard 😉

Edit for mistake

She’s welcome to criticise Israel, and given her very very fortuante position up to today, be a representative voice in parliament and UK society doing just that. She can’t expect to be taken seriously as a politician, though, dishing out sixth-form zionists-under-the-bed rhetoric. That’s the last thing that’s needed.

mcboo – Member
I just dont get religion.

That doesn’t put you at a disadvantage.

“If I was a Palestinian I might become a suicide bomber too…..”

where’s the problem ?
wouldn’t you consider drastic measures if your community was essentially walled in and persecuted by some other group ?

It would seem so junkyard

Damn 1- 0 to you 😈
😀
good retort

Thanks!

“If I was a Palestinian I might become a suicide bomber too…..”

What about if she’d said “if i were israeli, I’d probably have joined the army”
That OK too?

She can’t expect to be taken seriously as a politician, though, dishing out sixth-form zionists-under-the-bed rhetoric. That’s the last thing that’s needed.

6th form rhetoric seems to be exactly what’s needed to get ahead in politics usually.

scaredypants – Member

“If I was a Palestinian I might become a suicide bomber too…..”
where’s the problem ?
wouldn’t you consider drastic measures if your community was essentially walled in and persecuted by some other group ?

Oh bless you make it sound so reasonable, blowing up buses full of folk on their way to work. No, there is nothing that would make me commit such an act.

Oh bless you make it sound so reasonable, blowing up buses full of folk on their way to work. No, there is nothing that would make me commit such an act.

What about if they rounded up your wife and child and put them in a building and then shelled it for ‘fun’?

http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2009/jan/09/gaza-palestinians-israel-evacuees-zeitoun

Nope. Still not doing it.

What about if they stole your dinner money and gave you a wedgie?

mcboo – Member

Nope. Still not doing it.

Fair enough, others may have more backbone though

others may have more backbone though

Yeh, thank heavens for the backbone of suicide bombers 🙄

I’m always reminded of resistance fighters during the WWII occupations when people are morally outraged at the undignified acts perpetrated by so called terrorists..

I think the worlds oppressors get off very lightly in the great scheme of things..

Yeh, thank heavens for the backbone of suicide bombers

I’d imagine its the first thing to go through their mind when they pull the detonator

My point was, anyone who will stand by and let the people who murder there loved ones get away with it without raising a finger in defiance lacks backbone, and ironically the founders of the Israeli state agree with me http://www.britains-smallwars.com/Palestine/Kingdavid.htm

Personally, I hate to think of the level of desperation that someone would have to be driven to to blow themselves up and feel very lucky that we live in a society where I will never get to experience this, however the Palestinians don’t. Hence the issues, if Israel wants to stop the bombs perhaps if they started treating the Palestinian as human beings then the problems will stop

Ba doom tish.

I fail to see what’s worse about suicide bombers deliberately targeting civilians compared to not really giving a **** if civilians get killed, especially given that the numbers stack up the way they do (far more Palestinian civilians killed than Israelis). In fact I would argue its worse for a well trained, funded and equipped army to kill so many innocent people than a ragtag bunch of desperate people.

I’m always reminded of resistance fighters during the WWII occupations when people are outraged at the undignified acts perpetrated by so called terrorists..

The resistance targeted the military. Suicide bombers generally choose softer (civilian) targets. This lacks any kind of courage.
Have a scrap by all means, but don’t expect people to feel for your cause when your blowing up school buses. Keep it between “combatants” (that should be true for both sides).

Keep it between “combatants”.

Should these rules only apply to the terrorists?

Edited after your edit – fair dos

Have a scrap by all means, but don’t expect people to feel for your cause when your blowing up school buses. Keep it between “combatants”.

What like this?

That’s a UN compound sheltering non-combatants being shelled via white phosphorous to I quote ‘shake and bake them’

It’s nice out isn’t it?

Keep it between “combatants”

All very Marquess of Queensbury.. just like war.. how very neat and British.. 😀

I’m certainly not going to defend the actions of the Israelis. What I will say is that whilst I do not in any way agree with the use of WP, I also don’t believe that they shell the Palestinians without provocation. If they want a scrap, then they should bloody well have one away from the civilian populace of both sides.

Fair enough, others may have more backbone though

Thats pretty insulting.

Thats pretty insulting.

You admitted that you wouldn’t get fired up by all your loved ones being murdered for ‘fun’, so how else would you describe yourself?

TBH you are coming across as someone who would mumble into their skinny mocha-choca-latte with sprinkles if someone beat up your missus in front of you, so they could post it on youtube.

Funny, cause I spent my youth as a platoon commander in a Scottish Infantry Regiment. Feel free to send me a mail direct, I’ll be happy to meet you one on one for a bit of unarmed combat.

^^there’s a bit of this going around at the moment it seems^^
Some knobber tried throwing his weight around in the 6N thread yesterday. Maybe because its getting warmer?
Still, tenner on the jock grunt? 😀

Funny, cause I spent my youth as a platoon commander in a Scottish Infantry Regiment. Feel free to send me a mail direct, I’ll be happy to meet you one on one for a bit of unarmed combat.

So you are happy to fight someone who insults you? But not do anything about someone who killed you family for entertainment?

You have very strange views on right and wrong

LOL at the fantasy world of mcboo.

I’ll be happy to meet you one on one for a bit of unarmed combat.

handbags at 10 paces?

LOL at the fantasy world of mcboo.

Thats what I was thinking from Unarmed military champion to recommending skinny jeans in London in 40 posts.

Skinny jeans are practically uniform in the scots regiments. Wrangler usually.

fair point 😉

At least he didn’t claim to be Kaiser Soze