Hi Kryton.
You’re from my neck of the woods so I’ll give you a sensible answer.
I really like Bontrager tyres, they are the benchmark for easy tubeless mounting and are a nice balance of light weight and durability.
I’ve used most of the range so speak from experience.
xr1: Good small nobble tyre. No complaints, as good as any small nobble tyre. Use it for endurance Gorrick events in dry conditions.
Xr2: bought it as a front for loose Gorrick loam but despite a promising looking tread pattern proved disappointing in the real world.
Xr4: The secret that I’ll share with you (and the rest of STW); Frickin awesome levels of grip combined with a pliant yet durable casing. Comes up large.
I use a 2.35 old pattern (the best)at 16 psi on my rigid 26’er for most Gorrick events now (place about 10th in Super Masters, have won Masters on this tyre in wet conditions). Also use a 2.35 new pattern on my Blue Pig when playing silly beggers in Wales. Great, great tyre.