I just left the company car scheme as the numbers didn’t add up, and I hated the car…
I was handed a 18 month old Insignia(list price £27K) when I re-joined the company 2 years ago. The company paid for all fuel and I was charged for all non-work miles. I was paying £155 a month as a tax hit, and 16p/mile for personal miles so I took the option of changing to a car allowance when I could in March this year.
Car allowance of £5K/annum means I get about 3K in the bank, £250 a month. add on the £155 tax hit I no longer pay and it gave me a budget of ~£400 a month for a car. New car (24K on PCP) @ £376 a month inc servicing and insurance means the company is still paying for the car but I don’t have to do any miles to break even. I have to put tires on it. every company mile I do is @ 45p/mile for first 10K, then 25p/mile. i expect in a normal year to do about 15K company miles.
I get the 45p/mile that’s meant to contribute to the depreciation/running costs/petrol but even @ 1.45/litre, its costing me ~14p/mile on fuel, the depreciation is covered in the PCP payments. 8 months on and the car is worth exactly what I owe the finance so I’m struggling to see a downside to the deal.
If you own a car already, then the numbers might not work out the same depending on the depreciation and servicing costs of the extra miles you’ll put on it.