Right, forget the nonsense about the lack of grip when climbing. There isn’t. They grip very well indeed, I’ve been riding with them for about 2 months now and lost a pedal maybe once or twice. I’ve not noticed any significant difference between these and the standard freeriders.
They’re thin, and well ventilated – so for me, that means in the wet they’ll dry quicker and not soak up the water.
My problem with the winterised version is that they’re essentially a closed shoe, with a low ankle. So water gets in, and can’t get out.
What I’d do is get some VXis, and then spray them with some DWR stuff.
The VXIs are by far the best 5:10 riding shoe I’ve used, light, thin, sensitive, movable, and just so less bulky it feels more like a disco slipper than a big DH shoe.