Northwind – Member
I really didn’t like Eccleston… He was great at the serious but tried too hard for the wacky, felt like 2 different characters. To be fair I guess the scripting/characterisation hadn’t really hit its stride either.

I thought that was the point. When he first met Rose he was quite harsh, having spent too much time on his own. Rose humanised him over the course of the series to the point a bouncy and more energetic Tennant took over.

Russell96 – Member
With Sue Perkins how would they approach snog with River Song?

Not sure, but there might be tongues…
…River doesn’t seem much bothered, somehow. 😉

I really don’t care just bring back Amy Pond in a cheeky Police outfit.

Rowan Atikinson?

[video]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Do-wDPoC6GM[/video]

Sean Pertwee FTW.

I find Sue Perkins intensely irritating. Perfect for the Dr then.

CaptJon – Member

I thought that was the point. When he first met Rose he was quite harsh, having spent too much time on his own. Rose humanised him over the course of the series

Mmm, to be honest I thought it was a constant. Probably the best actor that’s ever done the job but… nah, didn’t quite work IMO.

`