Singletrack's forums are sponsored by...

Forum sponsored by Saracen

New car legal advic...
 

[Closed] New car legal advice - Sh** dealers (again)

83 Posts
38 Users
0 Reactions
48 Views
Offline  Jakester
Free Member
 
Share this post

Been to garage this morning, to be met by three people all apologising they’d got it wrong. They checked the CCTV, they could see that I did leave my keys with them whilst on the test drive and can see the sales girl check the outside of the car, but didn’t check the inside of it, or the mileage. They also accept they had at least three opportunities to have checked the mileage and didn’t, so they apologised unreservedly.

And then they all stood up and clapped...

So really, what you're saying is you went off too soon until they'd had a chance to check it, now they've checked it it's all fine so this whole thing was a load of fuss over nothing?

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 11:26 am
Offline  smallspinsized
Free Member
 
Share this post

Surely if the deal is done and all signed for, it's not your problem.

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 11:27 am
Offline  geordiemick00
Free Member
Topic starter
 
Share this post

So currently the dealer is sat on £1400 of OP’s money, which should be used as deposit on the new car. Are you worried OP that the dealer will ‘keep’ this money in lieu of the difference in valuation on the Merc, rather than apply it as deposit on Volvo or return to you?

Exactly this. They have assured me that they'll return the money when I bring in the new log book for the trade in.

So really, what you’re saying is you went off too soon until they’d had a chance to check it, now they’ve checked it it’s all fine so this whole thing was a load of fuss over nothing?

I had a cooling off period on the new car, why would I sit around and wait and reduce my options?

Someone called me up and categorically stated I'd provided them false info, I wanted it cleared up ASAP as they're sitting on £1400 of my money.

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 11:40 am
Offline  Jakester
Free Member
 
Share this post

Someone called me up and categorically stated I’d provided them false info, I wanted it cleared up ASAP as they’re sitting on £1400 of my money.

As I read it, it's literally been a day? You asked them to reconsider/recheck - they did and now it's sorted? Still struggling to see the problem here...

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 11:47 am
Offline  Cougar
Full Member
 
Share this post

Hang on.

In your OP you said they were claiming that their mileage record was based on what you told them and they don't check it so it's all your fault for lying to them, now today:

They checked the CCTV, they could see that I did leave my keys with them whilst on the test drive and can see the sales girl check the outside of the car, but didn’t check the inside of it, or the mileage.

... thus proving what you say they said in the first place, that they didn't check it? What's changed?

I don't doubt for a moment that you told them a genuine figure and the mistake was theirs in entering it wrong. But I don't understand where your sudden innocence comes from, it looks like the opposite.

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 11:48 am
Offline  Poopscoop
Full Member
 
Share this post

Cougar, I read it as they disputed they could even have checked the car over (inc odo) as he didn't leave the keys with them, or so they protested.

The CCTV however shows he did thus blowing their contention out of the water.

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 12:02 pm
Offline  Cougar
Full Member
 
Share this post

But from the OP:

The sales manager said they didn’t check the odometer or MOT history because they expect their customers to be truthful and he’d check the CCTV to see if I’d left my keys on her desk whilst out for a test drive!

What do the keys matter, that's not the reason cited. If he'd said "the sales manager said they couldn't check the odometer because I didn't leave the keys" that'd be different. (And would still have been their fault for not insisting, of course.)

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 12:15 pm
Offline  geordiemick00
Free Member
Topic starter
 
Share this post

But I don’t understand where your sudden innocence comes from, it looks like the opposite.

pardon? My stance has been the same from the minute I walked into the showroom. I told her the correct mileage, she's wrote it down wrong and clearly when she's realised she's got it wrong, she's then tried to blame me.

They've had three opportunities to check the mileage and didn't.

Today they admitted that it was ALL their own fault.

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 12:17 pm

Offline  Poopscoop
Full Member
 
Share this post

I'm reading it different to be honest Cougar, hence why they said they would check the cctv.

Edit: Glad it's all resolved anyway op.

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 12:18 pm
Offline  geordiemick00
Free Member
Topic starter
 
Share this post

What do the keys matter, that’s not the reason cited. If he’d said “the sales manager said they couldn’t check the odometer because I didn’t leave the keys” that’d be different. (And would still have been their fault for not insisting, of course.)

and he admitted today he was wrong because he's now checked the CCTV and not only seen that they could have, but they didn't. Nor did they check it again when I went to pick the new car up.

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 12:20 pm
Offline  stumpyjon
Full Member
 
Share this post

On the face of it garage made you an offer on your car as part of the deal, you liked the price and agreed. They came back and said we cocked up ay us more at which point I would have said sorry, I entered into a contract in good faith.

The mileage issue is a red herring, even if he'd lied through his teeth about it it's such a simple thing to check due diligence falls to them to check before completing the deal.

All very simple and has worked out as it should.

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 12:25 pm
Offline  jp-t853
Free Member
 
Share this post

Well done OP it all worked out as it should. Enjoy the car

I am just struggling to understand where some people are getting their views of your wrongdoing it seems straight forward to me that the garage did not do their work properly. I suspect the person who called you was trying to find a way out of the mess up. It created a very bad experience and I would have been very concerned in your shoes.

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 12:28 pm
Offline  Cougar
Full Member
 
Share this post

he admitted today he was wrong because he’s now checked the CCTV and not only seen that they could have, but they didn’t.

But we already know they didn't, in your OP you said they admitted they hadn't checked it - you said that they claimed they didn't check the odometer because they trust their customers, not because they didn't have the opportunity. Hence your (justified) outrage at being accused of lying to them.

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 12:40 pm
Offline  boblo
Free Member
 
Share this post

I am just struggling to understand where some people are getting their views of your wrongdoing

Because he has history on here of slightly dodgy dealings - at least twice to my certain knowledge so people remember leopards rarely change their spots...

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 1:46 pm
Offline  theotherjonv
Free Member
 
Share this post

I'll say again;

I'd be annoyed at the false accusation as much as anything, but I'm a little surprised and disappointed even, do we not let anyone off a genuine mistake any longer. Just because it's a garage or a company, the attitude of 'tough shit, your problem' doesn't sit that well with me.

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 1:59 pm
Offline  snotrag
Full Member
 
Share this post

Interesting this.

My partners last car was p/xd at a Honda dealer, we followed the same pattern, went out on a test drive and let them have a look round our old car whilst we were gone.

We dealt with a lady whom, it turned out was the wife of the sales manager. She had lost her unrleated job, and this was her new role, and we were her first ever customers, so she was lovely.

I had a 'cost to change' in mind, (because thats what matters, not how much they give you p.x or how much the new car is) and they came in with a very favourable figure, so we bought the car there and then.

Only once we were home, did we spot that when filling out the p/x appraisal documents and value calculator, she had input the mileage of our old car as the number on the trip computer. Which would have been, at an absolute maximum, 999. Not the number on the odometer. Which was 70 thousand and something.

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 2:21 pm

Offline  theotherjonv
Free Member
 
Share this post

surprises me in this computer age that it doesn't flag up and need an additional input if eg: mileage per year is not between say 6K and 15K. Would be dead easy

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 2:30 pm
Offline  geordiemick00
Free Member
Topic starter
 
Share this post

Because he has history on here of slightly dodgy dealings – at least twice to my certain knowledge so people remember leopards rarely change their spots…

Seriously? Because of the Lings cars thing people have this perception that I have had 'dodgy dealings'. What you forget about the debacle was the person who was arranging the lease, was also trying to force a contract that was unenforceable.

I've been in sales for 26 years and NOT ONE thing I've ever sold has ever been brought into question, not one.

Not one of the dozen or so bikes I've sold in the last ten years has ever been an issue, a fair few of them through the STW community. I must have sold £12k of bikes in that time, once the bike has been sold I've not had the slightest noise of disappointment or complaint.

Just like the car I've just traded in, anything I've shifted on has been looked after. sold at the right price and in a very transparent manner.

I’d be annoyed at the false accusation as much as anything, but I’m a little surprised and disappointed even, do we not let anyone off a genuine mistake any longer. Just because it’s a garage or a company, the attitude of ‘tough shit, your problem’ doesn’t sit that well with me.

So I should have just rolled over then and offered them the £3k they claim they're down?? I wish I was rich enough to be that spirited.

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 2:32 pm
Offline  Cougar
Full Member
 
Share this post

do we not let anyone off a genuine mistake any longer. Just because it’s a garage or a company, the attitude of ‘tough shit, your problem’ doesn’t sit that well with me.

Sure. "You're forgiven."

Good luck if the mistake had been in the opposite direction and you only noticed after you'd signed the contract.

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 2:33 pm
Offline  imnotverygood
Full Member
 
Share this post

I’d be annoyed at the false accusation as much as anything, but I’m a little surprised and disappointed even, do we not let anyone off a genuine mistake any longer. Just because it’s a garage or a company, the attitude of ‘tough shit, your problem’ doesn’t sit that well with me.

Except, to be fair to the OP, the dealer has tried to make it his (the OP’s) problem.. He’s gone in with good faith, and accepted the deal offered. If he’d realised the mistake they had made & not said anything, then I would have agreed with you. But as it stands the deal was done & dusted & quite frankly, once he’s taken the car away then they just have to accept that it was their mistake & they just have to take the hit.
Also, while I remember the Ling thread, I think trying to have a go at the op when he clearly hasn’t done anything wrong is a bit playing the man and not the ball.

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 2:39 pm
Offline  stumpyjon
Full Member
 
Share this post

I fully agree with the OP on this, it was a legal contract with a professional retailer. The OP made his decision to purchase based on the offer in front of him. If it had been brought up before signing the OP had the option not to move forward, once signed both parties were committed to the deal.

I nearly got screwed when we bought my wife's car, despite repeatedly saying I didn't want the after market paint protection rubbish they were flogging it still ended up o the contract. Luckily I spotted it when I read the contract through before signing otherwise I'd have been committed another £800 I'm pretty certain I wouldn't have seen again. Conversely on the car I ordered on Monday the salesman put the cost of the optional paint upgrade in at £650 when it should have been £800, his mistake which he spotted before signing. To his credit he left it as it was as we'd agreed on the bottom line price.

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 2:42 pm
Offline  theotherjonv
Free Member
 
Share this post

So I should have just rolled over then and offered them the £3k they claim they’re down?? I wish I was rich enough to be that spirited.

Hang on, you said

It was about where I expected it to be, especially given they were looking to do a deal on a car they had to shift on and had lots of margin to play with due to the extensive list of options that inflated the RRP.

and now that's £3k different between what they offered you and what they say they should have offered you?

I wish I was rich enough that a £3K difference is in the 'sounds about right' noise.

True honesty would have said 'that's a good deal but I think you've entered the numbers wrong somewhere'.

He’s gone in with good faith, and accepted the deal offered. If he’d realised the mistake they had made & not said anything, then I would have agreed with you.

I asked earlier about 'gift horse' - and it was denied. £3K would have had my spidey senses tingling, tbh, then again the new car is what, £35K+ so maybe £3K is in the noise?

Good luck if the mistake had been in the opposite direction and you only noticed after you’d signed the contract.

Fortunately you have cooling off periods for that, but I agree. However as I said if the error in the offer had been the other way, you'd sure as hell point it out.

A mistake's a mistake, and IMHO should be rectified, not taken advantage of.

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 2:52 pm
Offline  DrP
Full Member
 
Share this post

Actually - funny enough MANY years ago something similar happened to me..

I had a Honda Civic Type R (braaaaap) I was trading in for a Skoda Octavia (erm...brrrr..) plus some cash (my way).
The Civic had a small dent in the wing.
When we test drove the Octavia the garage looked round the Civic, and offered a price for it.

When we went back a few days later to collect the Octavia+money, and give them teh Civic, they got a bit annoyed about the 'new dent' on the car... I told them it was there for weeks, and was there when they looked round it and made an offer..

I wasn't going to let them try to wangle down an agreed price.. whether they really didn't see the dent, or had, but were trying it on, it wasn't like I was hiding anything or lying..

DrP

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 3:00 pm
Offline  doomanic
Full Member
 
Share this post

I asked earlier about ‘gift horse’ – and it was denied. £3K would have had my spidey senses tingling

How is the OP supposed to know that figure prior to getting a PX value?

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 3:02 pm

Offline  geordiemick00
Free Member
Topic starter
 
Share this post

Good luck if the mistake had been in the opposite direction and you only noticed after you’d signed the contract.

For the same reason I've never had PPI, I read the small print and T's & C's, I've been burned in the past. But the information that caused this whole debacle was never put before my eyes, so you expecting me to be a mind reader too?

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 3:06 pm
Offline  TheFlyingOx
Full Member
 
Share this post

How is the OP supposed to know that figure prior to getting a PX value?

And when it was, iirc, within about £200 of a private offer he'd already had for the car he was PXing, and therefore seemed to be reasonable.

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 3:08 pm
Offline  doomanic
Full Member
 
Share this post

It's a bit suspect that the amount of the difference in PX value is approximately double the deposit lodged at the dealer. "Tell you what sir, we don't want to be unreasonable, we'll split the difference and just hang on to your 1400 quid"

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 3:16 pm
Offline  Cougar
Full Member
 
Share this post

But the information that caused this whole debacle was never put before my eyes, so you expecting me to be a mind reader too?

I think you've missed my point.

People are arguing that you should accept their mistake and allow them to revise it, after you've signed a contract. What I'm saying is if the mistake had been in their favour rather than in yours, say they'd recorded the odometer as 185k, I'm dubious that you'd get anything from them other than "sorry but you signed the contract so too bad."

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 3:20 pm
Offline  geordiemick00
Free Member
Topic starter
 
Share this post

and now that’s £3k different between what they offered you and what they say they should have offered you?

They say the car with 85k is worth £3k less than they paid, which is ridiculous, even WBAC only has £1200 difference.

True honesty would have said ‘that’s a good deal but I think you’ve entered the numbers wrong somewhere’.

They offered me exactly what I thought they would, it was about £800 more than WBAC quoted. And as they confirmed this morning, they upped the offer using some margin from the new car.

I asked earlier about ‘gift horse’ – and it was denied. £3K would have had my spidey senses tingling, tbh, then again the new car is what, £35K+ so maybe £3K is in the noise?

The car was £47k. the'£3k' was only ever mentioned last night when they rang me up to discuss the issue AFTER picking up the new car. So there was no opportunity for my 'spidey senses' tingle, they paid exactly what I thought they would for an immaculate, well maintained sought after Mercedes.

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 3:20 pm
Offline  davros
Full Member
 
Share this post

Op, did you check wbac and others to see what their prices were before you heard their px offer? And if so, how did their offer compare? Was it +3k

I would have thought anyone would do that before considering a px considering how easy it is.

Edit, ignore, you've answered it!

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 3:22 pm
Offline  geordiemick00
Free Member
Topic starter
 
Share this post

I think you’ve missed my point.

People are arguing that you should accept their mistake and allow them to revise it, after you’ve signed a contract. What I’m saying is if the mistake had been in their favour rather than in yours, say they’d recorded the odometer as 185k, I’m dubious that you’d get anything from them other than “sorry but you signed the contract so too bad.”

Then please accept my apologies, but I totally agree, they'd shaft me.

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 3:23 pm
Offline  geordiemick00
Free Member
Topic starter
 
Share this post

Op, did you check wbac and others to see what their prices were before you heard their px offer? And if so, how did their offer compare? Was it +3k

I would have thought anyone would do that before considering a px considering how easy it is.

Yep, done that and they offered me £800 more than WBAC, I suspected the uplift was from the decent margin in the new car and when I mentioned it this morning they confirmed exactly what they done.

I'd advertised the car in a private Merc group and the value was around the right mark, hence why I did the deal.

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 3:26 pm

Offline  theotherjonv
Free Member
 
Share this post

OK, I apologise, didn't realise the £3k is what they are NOW saying the difference is.

What I'm trying to say, and obviously not getting over well, is that when I've gone in to look at cars and PX mine, I'd already have a reasonable idea of what that PX would be (Parkers, Autotrader, etc.) and also what sort of dealer discount you'd get on the new one. And I'd expect to be lowballed to start with and have to work to what I thought it would be. I agree, that they can fiddle the PX and the dealer discounts so it isn't always obvious whether what they're offering is right, but in the end I know roughly what the cost to change is likely to be.

I misunderstood where the £3K number came from, but if after doing that their offer was £3K different to what I'd expected, as I say I'd be suspicious. And perhaps I am too honest but I'd be tempted to query that, even though it would cost me. Too honest or just plain stupid, YMMV

I'd also say that if trading in a prestige/pristine E-class (what would that be, 15-20K?) and being offered only £200 less than I'd been offered on a private sale, that too would have raised an eyebrow.

 
Posted : 11/03/2022 4:44 pm
Page 2 / 2

Secret Diary Of Benjamin Haworth Age 47 3/4

Last Minute Tuscany

Digital Detox

singletrack issue 159 cover image

Issue 159