[Closed] Scottish railways receive highest government funding - why?

<yawn> what's that sound, oh another englishman whining, nothing new there then. If Alex Salmond promises to put in double glazing to stop that irrirating noise, he gets my vote.

you answered your own question with the funding vs passenger densities didn't you 😉

Lolz @ Bigbutslimmerbloke

So we can have beautiful things like this
[img] [/img]

Scottish train lines harder to access/more prone to weather damage/longer between stations/historically underfunded?

Personally, when I occasionally travel by train to Inverness from Wareham (Wessex region) I'm not really bothered that some bits of the track cost more to maintain than others.

Oh, and apparently they're considering spending a few quid on the railway between London and Birmingham - maybe that will even things up a bit.

Bloody hell TJ! Where's that?

nice pic, and let's not forget (with nice new viewing platform, probably)
[img] [/img]

Glenfinnen.

binners - never seen harry potter? athough i've never seen it from that angle
[img] ?__SQUARESPACE_CACHEVERSION=1302092373665[/img]

Its nice TJ. And I suppose in some ways it will prepare you for the majesty of the big bridge you'll be riding under next weekend

[img] [/img]

Some people find it so breathtaking, they stand dumbfounded at its beauty. Best not to stand there too long though. As we found out, now its no longer in use, the local scrotes find it an ideal platform to hurl both abuse and house bricks from 😀

Jeezus wept - who used the "heinz tinned spaghetti tomato sauce" filter on that Forth Rail Bridge photo. Some people really shouldn't be allowed anywhere near Lightroom...

One of the largest concrete structures made without reinforcing. I think Sir Bob McAlpine was the builder?

The best bit of Glenfinnan is actually about 4k further on than the viaduct. The wonderful circuit that is the horseshoe. Views right across to the Isles a year past November.

A railway journey everyone should do - one of the worlds great railway journeys

So the ORR have published a report detailing the costs and funding of the railways in 2010-11, and the Scottish operating region received the highest funding of 15.6p / km with the lowest average passenger densities of 84 passengers per train and Wessex getting 1.7p / km at 143 average passengers per train.
Yet more subsidies for Scotland... Come on TJ explain your way out of this

Post a link to the report and I'll do my best to explain how railway infrastructure/rolling stock funding in the UK works.

In the UK, I act for DfT, TfL, TS, numerous ITAs/PTEs, a handful of train operating companies, ROSCOs and infrastructure/RS funders. I sit on the other side of Network Rail on a daily basis and spent 3 years making representations on behalf of numerous entities to the ORR in respect of third party investment in the UK rail network.

So I should be able to answer your question, but I'm hungover from a Burns Supper last night, so finding the will power might be difficult. 🙂

This diagram is a very simplistic view of the funding flow going into CP4, I can explain each individial aspect if you like, it's not very interesting though 🙂

[img] [/img]

A railway journey everyone should do - one of the worlds great railway journeys

Ticket booked for 10th April. A 5 hour railway journey for £15,. Bargain, and a nice way to start a mini tour.

I'm looking at ferry to Skye, back off at the small ferry to Glenelg - Kinlochourn - Great Glen - Corrieyairick - Minigaig - Blair Atholl.

Undecided where to then. Train home if the weather is bad. Maybe Glen Tilt if it's good weather and finish along the south Glen Dee Rd to Aberdeen or over Mt Keen and go to Montrose. Choices choices ...

A railway journey everyone should do - one of the worlds great railway journeys

Sainsburys are doing a deal at the moment where you can travel anywhere in Scotland by rail for £17 return when you buy stuff (I've got loads of the vouchers now just from picking up a few beers on a Friday night!).

one of the worlds great railway journeys

How does it compare to the Glacier Express (which does spirals to climb up the mountains to St Moritz)?

Dunno aracer as I have not done that one but it is often included in the lists of great train journeys. the west highland line is a real treat - I love using it.

For example its included on here
http://www.greatrail.com/train-journeys-of-the-world.aspx

aP - Member
So the ORR have published a report detailing the costs and funding of the railways in 2010-11, and the Scottish operating region received the highest funding of 15.6p / km with the lowest average passenger densities of 84 passengers per train and Wessex getting 1.7p / km at 143 average passengers per train.
Yet more subsidies for Scotland... Come on TJ explain your way out of this

Presumably you've never looked at a map of Scotland?

Scottish railways receive highest government funding - why?

Because we are worth it?

The extra dosh mainly pays for the Hogwarts Express.

Aracer - is that the one that goes up from the Italian side via Poschiavo? That one certainly spirals.

If so it's quite nice too.

Edit: close but different [url= http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bernina_Railway ]Clicky[/url]

Cause 'Big Men' need paying.

Sainsburys are doing a deal at the moment where you can travel anywhere in Scotland by rail for £17 return when you buy stuff (I've got loads of the vouchers now just from picking up a few beers on a Friday night!).

[url= http://www.scotrail.co.uk/sainsburys ]It's £19 return on a £15 spend[/url] And 1 voucher lets you buy 2 tickets - cheers for that

The extra dosh mainly pays for the Hogwarts Express.

[url= http://www.westcoastrailways.co.uk/jacobite/jacobite_details.html ]and worth every penny[/url]

PS, link mentions Arisaig, no pics, so here's one

[img] [/img]

irc, you might want to jump off the train at Morar and add a trip round Arissaig to your trip, it'll only be an extra 10-15 miles butif it's a nice day, you'll be glad you did

I presume this is the report?

Section 6.2 covers Government support. It's not clear to me whether the subsidy per passenger includes investment in infrastructure and maintenance (e.g. Crossrail).

West Highland Line's different to the Rhaetian Bahn, all of which is a stunning feat of engineering! Better experienced on the standard RhB trains rather than the Glacier Express proper IMO - the windows open, so you can have a proper look.

Both worth doing!

Edit: nice viaducts in Switzerland too:

[img] [/img]

Better experienced on the standard RhB trains rather than the Glacier Express proper IMO - the windows open, so you can have a proper look.

I've only ever been on the normal trains - cheapest and easiest way to get to the Engadine after flying to Zurich - but thought the Glacier Express the easiest way to describe it. The coolest thing is the train served toboggan run (not ever done it, but watched out of the window).

cbike - Member
One of the largest concrete structures made without reinforcing.

Best not mention the Hoover dam then!

Come on English i know your all nothing like as ignorant as aP, but he really does show you all up in a bad light.