riding around the Pentlands/Edinburgh area, and then bikepacking trips in the Highlands and hopefully further afield.
Back in the day (2001) I did almost that on a 100mm hardtail. Raleigh RSP, then a norco fireball then a cove stiffee.
I’d say any of the bikes you have listed would be ace.
Sonder Broken Road Ti – I’m not hugely fussed by Ti but it’s a lot lighter than the steel version. Main detractors I can see are slack seat tube angle, and not the most exciting brand.
Can you ram your seat forward to give a steeper effective angle? Only one of my bikes doesn’t have the seat all the way forward and that’s because it’s got a rigid fork that’s a bit shorter that the 130mm suspension fork it’s supposed to have.
Rack mounts over frame mounts. I toured with panniers and now I see they are making a comeback. Bike packing bags are better for balance, but panniers are easier to get on in one go with no faffing after taking stuff on and off.
I don’t get to bike pack often anymore. Last time was on my geometron – G13 (160/135mm) , time before on my on one hello Dave(160mm fork)
What about on one? Ti/ steel/ alloy options.
I commute on an on one vandal which was cheap and ticks some of you boxes. There’s is the Titius silk road which ticks more.
I’d suggest choosing one you like the look of, there will all be great in their own way.
On one aren’t a super exciting brand in my eyes, but both the bikes I’ve had from them are great and have geometry that fits me. I’d have a sonder over on one for the warranty on ti. I pretty much expect if my vandal breaks I’ll have to buy myself a new one. It was second hand but I’d assume that for a new one as well.