I’m a fan of the Shimanos (AM40s in my case). No they don’t have as much grip as 5 10s, but they still have more than I need.
And also they’ve lasted more than twice as long as my last 5 10s did and are still in reasonable shape- they won’t last the year but I’ll forgive ’em. I think it was the wet that killed the 5 10s- they soaked up so much water and dried so slowly that they were basically never dry all winter. Stitching burst, soles delaminated, inners came apart, just about every part failed at the same rate.
Oh- 5 10 no longer use cardboard insoles as far as I can see, which does help. I just bought a pair of cheap Freeriders to try and nuked them with waterproofer, we’ll see how that goes.