Ive always found Evans to be fine, although I thought their clothing range was a bit of a selection of odd choices. The rest was pretty good though. My local one in Durham is closing apparently which isn’t great for the people who work there 🙁
I can’t comment on whether its profitable, but I can comment on the fact its in a very high demand area for retail, being on probably the most popular trading estate. Im thinking that SD might have asked for a discount and being told to get on their proverbial bike… if that is the case I can see why they would say half will close. Assume a 50% success rate for negotiating a significant rent discount, close the rest.