[Closed] 9speed 135mm spacing problem??

sorry should point out its a new frame to me, it was born 2002 i think

Could be a number of things:

Bent (not centred) frame (should be visible by eye)

Wheel (massively) out of true, the whole thing off to one side (again should be obvious)

I reckon most likely though is that your hub has been rebuilt wrongly. For eg if its a cup/cone (one with nuts on a threaded axle) and the spacers/nuts/etc.. have been rebuilt in the wrong order/sides shoving the whole wheel off centre when in the frame

Could be something else though, or a combination?

its a deore xt hub fh-m765 and is like you say i think. frame seems ok wheel is ok and fits in my other frame with 135mm spacing. do some 135 not take 9 speed?

Try putting the wheel in the other way round with the disc on the drive side.

If it's still off center on the same side the frame's out if it's off center on the opposite side it's your wheel that's out.

cheers did that, it was off centre to the opposite side as before, so my wheel is out? what do i do about that then...ha

Its probably either the wheel trueing is out loads (All to one side) or the spacers/nuts/etc are arranged in the wrong order/on the wrong sides on the axle. Have a look through the tech documents for your hub on shimanos website and try to figure out if its been (re)assembled correctly?

good man cheers.

Asymmetric chainstays?

carlosg, not familier with what youre on about?

hub seems fine though... as i said it fits straight into my jump bike

the frame is a giant nrs dont think it has asymetric chainstays. i think i had a old marin before which had the same problem...

dish on the wheel is wrong it needs redishing.

you can do this yourself - if you not done anything wheel related you shoudl take a look at this:

http://www.wheelpro.co.uk/wheelbuilding/book.php

money back if you think it is rubbish.

thanks rootes1, i havent really done much to wheels before so if i attempt it, it may be worth having a look at that e book.
is it definatly just out of dish though.
i would have thought, granted from my limited knowledge about bikes, that if the wheel was out of dish it wouldnt fit in any frame i put it in, but it fits fine in my commencal cromo?
after raking my memory i do remember a old marin having the same problem a few years back. i eventually took it into a shop and they just said it was a 8 speed or 7 speed frame i cant remember which, and showed me by putting a 7/8 speed wheel in it and it fit perfect. dont know how reliable the shop was though as lbs around me arnt great.
are 7/ 8 speed wheels aligned differently to 9? although all fit in 135mm of space?

7,8 or 9 shouldn't affect the frame fit as long as its a 135mm, unless somebody has fitted a 7 freehub body to a 8/9 hub(or vice-versa)without re-dishing the wheel to suit the different freehub widths.

"but it fits fine in my commencal cromo?"

Perhaps that is bent (it is steel)? But in such a way the wheel fits (either the wheel being out of dish, or perhaps the spacers are wrong

thanks i'll go down the dished wheel route... maybe try and borrow another 9 speed and try that in it.

think i may have figured out why it was fitting in my commencal... the commy has horizontal drop outs so was easy to hide the dish. bit pissed really since it was a lbs who put the wheel on for me after he wanted to buy former said marin frame!!! seems probable that wheel was out of dish all the time and he just fed me a load of bs about old 8 speed frames 135 not taking 9 speed...etc.
havent managed to put a wheel in the giant yet though so just wonder what other walls im gonna come across haha i love building bikes.