In Issue #115 of Singletrack Magazine, Wil and the team tested and reviewed eight powerful trail brakes.
As part of the test process, we took all eight brakes down to Wales for three solid days of back-to-back testing on the slatey, unforgiving, high-speed trails of Antur Stiniog. Each brake was set up with 180mm rotors front and rear, and we left the hoses uncut to ensure the factory bleed was retained. Once we’d had sufficient comparative test time on all the brakes in a controlled environment, we then returned to Calderdale to continue testing each brake individually on more familiar home trails.
At the end of testing, we had four awards to hand out, including Best Engineered, Easiest To Live With, Best Feel, and Best Overall.
Winner Of Easiest Brake To Live With: Shimano Zee
It’s all well and good having disc brakes that look pretty, or can melt your face off with their stopping power, but it all amounts to nought if those brakes give you nothing but grief on the trail. If you’re someone who likes to travel with your bike, having a reliable brake that’s easy to maintain and service can go a very long way to retaining your sanity.
Since the XTR M980 groupset launched way back in 2010, Shimano has built itself an enviable reputation for its hydraulic disc brakes, particularly when it comes to brake feel and reliability. Well, for the most part anyway. We have experienced a few somewhat unsettling moments with the latest M9000 XTR and M8000 XT stoppers, with certain sets occasionally plagued by a weird variable bite point.
Thankfully, the Zee stoppers on test have not given us such troubles. And from a reliability and ease of use perspective, these are no doubt the easiest to live with brakes from the whole group test.
Shimano Zee Specifications
- Quad-piston calliper brakes for Trail/All Mountain/Downhill use
- Lever blade: Forged alloy
- Lever body: Forged alloy
- Ambidextrous: No
- Adjustments: Tooled lever reach
- Callipers: Forged alloy quad-piston
- Piston diameter: 15/17mm
- Piston material: Ceramic
- Stock pad compound: Resin (Metal sintered available separately)
- Fluid: Mineral Oil
- Rotor options: 160, 180, 200mm sizes in 6-Bolt and Centerlock options
- Actual weight: 310g (front) & 326g (rear)
- RRP: £134.99 per end (without rotors and adapters)
With Zee being to Saint what SLX is to XT, what you’re looking at here is essentially a set of Saint brakes that have had some of the bells and whistles trimmed off. You don’t get the fancy finned brake pads or a tool-free reach adjuster, and the lever is essentially the same as SLX (whereas the Saints get an XTR-level lever). But, otherwise, that’s kind of it.
There’s the same chunky four-piston Saint calliper, which uses a pair of 15mm and 17mm diameter pistons that are made of a ceramic material to insulate the calliper from heat generated by the pads and rotor. Compare that to the 22mm diameter pistons used in the two-pot SLX brakes, and you’ve got nearly a 20% increase in piston surface diameter to put more pressure onto the pads and rotor. Add in the wider pads, and there’s a substantial increase in friction available to scrub off speed.
Like all of Shimano’s high-end disc brakes, the Zees are a doddle to set up. There’s a 4mm hex key to bolt the split clamp to the bars, and you’ll need a 2mm hex key to set lever reach. The short lever blade has a comfortable and intuitive hooked profile, and if you’ve got a new generation I-Spec Shimano shifter, the two can share the same bar clamp. As for bleeding, using Shimano’s cup tool and One-Way Bleed system could not be any easier.
One of the big advantages with Shimano disc brakes is the large degree of pad rollback. With more distance between the pads and rotor it’s significantly easier to align the calliper to the rotor for rub-free coasting, making the Zees the easiest to set up, bar none. Because of the Servo Wave roller cam up the lever end, the pads close in quickly to make up that gap as soon as you squeeze on the lever. Admittedly there’s quite a bit of lever throw before anything happens and because there is no pad contact adjustment, you can’t fine-tune this bite point position. Still, it’s a solid and definite bite point, and there’s a gently progressive feel to the power.
On The Trail
Compared to Shimano’s SLX & XT brakes, the Zees aren’t nearly as grabby initially, with more power being available deeper in the lever throw. As a result, the Zees actually have better modulation and fine-tune control than their lighter twin-pot siblings. However, overall power wasn’t as good as we were expecting. There’s certainly plenty of grab from the Zee callipers, and they felt stronger than both the Hopes and TRPs, but they couldn’t match the sheer stopping force of the Magura or SRAM brakes.
One thing we noticed after returning from Antur Stiniog was that braking power seems to soften if you leave a few days between rides. And, as we’ve experienced with other Shimano brakes, the pads also seem to be susceptible to being contaminated by bike cleaners. The first ride after any wash was met with high-pitched wailing and a soft brake feel, though after getting a bit of heat into the pads and rotors, the power would soon return to normal levels.
The Zees are excellent stoppers that feature decent power, great modulation and solid reliability. They may be a little heavier than a set of SLX or XT brakes, but we prefer the feel and their consistency. Factor in the ease of bleeding and the wide availability of spare parts including pads, rotors, spare hoses, adapters and mineral oil, and the Zees get a strong recommendation from us.
For our group test, we tested eight brakes in total. Some were outstanding in certain areas, and others performed well across the board. But with just four awards up for grabs, that left four remaining brakes that narrowly missed out on the glory. To see how those other brakes performed, hit the following links;
|Price:||£134.99 per end (rotors & adapters sold separately)|
|Tested:||by Wil Barrett for 3 months|