Just got home to find embarrassing bodies on. They seem to be dealing with larger folk, which got me thinking. Obesity do you think it’s a disease? discuss……….
Myself I believe its more complex than that – the food companies increase their market share by making foods we get addicted to – sugar salt and fat and then carb loading them – but hidden sugar and perhaps fructose play a large part. we have a much higher calorie intake than our ancestor but dont lead such active lives
I think, no I KNOW, that his is far to complex an issue for such a simple debate! And it’s potential to offend makes it to sensitive an issue for forums like this one.
1. A pathological condition of a part, organ, or system of an organism resulting from various causes, such as infection, genetic defect, or environmental stress, and characterized by an identifiable group of signs or symptoms.
2. A condition or tendency, as of society, regarded as abnormal and harmful.
3. Obsolete Lack of ease; trouble.
So it falls into 2. A disease just means “not normal”.
Lots of people fail to deal with lots of issues. This particular group of issues has a very visible symptom, so people who are more fortunate point and laugh.
Poor show.
I’m curious how stuffing your face could be defined as a disease?
When you know that eating too much makes you fat but you either deny it to yourself or just can’t stop anyway, this is mental illness territory. Like alcoholism any other substance abuse.
When you know that eating too much makes you fat but you either deny it to yourself or just can’t stop anyway, this is mental illness territory. Like alcoholism any other substance abuse.
I think if you’ve got yourself so massively fat and physically unable through overeating to carry on a “normal” life, there must be a psychological problem driving it. Which makes me feel sorry and empathetic for that person and wonder how they can be helped.
I’m mentally ill and I’m fat, I think the two are separate things for me.
I’m mentally ill(bi-polar) cos I am. I’m fat cos I eat too much,live a really disorganized, sat down playing the guitar all day, scoffing pizza etc.lifestyle and like beer.
get behind one at the supermarket till and be amazed at the sheer amount of ‘treats’ they load onto the conveyor. Not a vegetable in sight, coke by the gallon.
If it is a disease or a medical condition it was not present in Belsen.
Stupidest post of the day, well done.
If calories in are more than calories burnt you will become fat, fact.
And the least well informed! On a roll, aren’t we?
Btw it’s calories STORED that’s the issue. There are other factors at work besides how much exercise you do, which is obvious from looking at skinny lazy over-eaters.
Severally over weight people, I think is more of the metal illness issue, alcoholic type mechanism.
Moderately / slightly over weight (most people), I believe is partly a cultural / society type thing. This idea is based on the fact how much more common being over-weight is in this country compared to many others.
is it better to be an overweight but physically active person (ooh, let’s say for sake of argument a middle aged mtb’er who might be carrying a few pounds extra but can easily knock out a 4 hour cross country ride)
or-
someone with a BMI right in the target range but who doesn’t do any significant exercise and can’t run for a bus without getting out of breath.
Most people when feeble and poorly at age 65 due to poor diet and lack of exercise will wish they were healthier earlier in life, I would imagine, regardless of how happy they were at the time.