With a 400mm post my small bike is not even vaguely pedallable for any length of time.
I would rather buy a bike that fits. Sure they may look like gates but they fit me but, frankly my dear I don’t give a damn.
my bikes fit me too, thanks 🙂
lets say a 350mm post has 270mm ‘showing’. if you also assume a saddle gives you an extra 20mm, a 17inch frame and 185mm cranks will give you a 35″ saddle-to-pedal height. a 16″ frame is an inch less. I personally don’t ride xc in such a way that my leg is fully extended, and I believe most fitting guides reccomend a slightly bent leg. A 16″ frame, with 350mm post at full extension is thus the perfect size.
That just brings up the length of the bike. I wouldn’t want to ride a normal xc bike in 16″ size (a quick look at on-one suggests an inbred of this size has a 59cm ett). my 16″ frame has a 617mm effective top tube. My 17″ frame has a 620mm Your orange has a 620mm effective top tube. I fit 50mm stems on both. Given I’m an inch shorter than you, I find that fits perfectly, thanks 🙂
I’d argue people shouldn’t write off shorter seat post frames without understanding the geometry fully.