Fair enough aa, that system did seem to work great for wales last year.
Lydiate tackles, Warburton jackals. I guess both sides play to the strengths of their own players, and as long as the balance of skills is there, it can work anyway. Incidentally, your explanation raises my opinion of Lydiate. He’s an excellent tackler, but I always felt he lacked that little bit extra as a 6 compared to someone like Ferris. It seems he was playing his role in his team’s system to perfection.
😉 But IMO, it’s Wales that are playing them the wrong unconventional way around, not england. First one tackle, second win ball. And seven should be first if he’s any good. 😉 (agrees to disagree and leave this point alone?)
Anyway, it all goes out the window on consecutive plays. You’re never first to two in a row from the bottom of a breakdown, assuming the rucking’s a fairly decent pace, so a bit of balance to the skillset helps any back-rower. And Ireland spoil any explanation by trying to tackle without ever putting players on the floor.
Agree about Cole. Gethin’s got a bit of it too. There’s a few other players with that skill not playing flanker too, BOD’s been at it for years.
And about the captaincy. At the moment,for me, the most certain starters don’t match the most likely captains. My outside pick, assuming hoping he’ll make the team at 6 or 8, would be SOB. I reckon he does have that little bit extra going forwards and in defence.