Some great recommendations on this thread, and I’ve eaten at a worryingly high proportion of them, though a bit of a range ( as in I’ve spent less on weekends in Barcelona than I have on a recent overnighter at the Cottage in the Wood. Handy for Grizedale Pike as it is.) Tho not the Daffodil, sorry ton, which struck me as an okay big hotel with food a bit below par for prices.
Anyway, this is what you want.
http://www.thestaratharome.co.uk/
Relaxed but nice place to poke about. Posh rooms over the road. Thatch, old leather everything Michelin star (not sure this will have been regained post fire, but looks like they’ve done a full on restoration of the place) but prices are not insane. I’ve had some great meals here though not since the fire. Would have booked now if I’d not on reading half this thread just made a reservation at Shibden.
Been here a lot for food many times but not for a year maybe https://www.bestpubinthedales.co.uk/ white lion, cray, does rooms that look posh from the outside and the food is more restaurant than pub (nice touches, Yorkshire amuse bouche, home made chocks etc), and it’s good as a pub. Bit remote up a hill.