bit early to tell. I rode the same trails back to back but it was perfect yesterday for the FlareMax and significantly slipper today. I loved the FlareMax yesterday and got a couple of PBs which since I ride here a lot was a surprise. Got a couple more today on the smuggler which definitely wasn’t expected as I do mince about when it’s that dry/wet/dry/moist root kind of ride.
Initial impressions are the smuggler has a better rear end (it’s a better shock as well), incredibly plush, bottomless even with 115mm of travel, loads of grip, doesn’t seem to get phased by anything. I’m not a massive fan of that rear tyre and think it’d be even better with a DHRII
They both climb well. They are both really ‘smooth’ on the trail and both reward a bit of commitment like any good bike. My feeling is the smuggler might need riding a bit harder to get the best out of it.
I need to ride it a lot more. I’ve not yet switched back to 29 in my head and keep looking at that 2.3 tyre and think ‘where’s the rest of it’ 🙂 Although as I said the Cotic might be a better all rounder on the 29s not the chubbies.
Too many nice bikes. I’m not good enough to be any judge of which is best. The are certainly different tho and I hope different enough to justify keeping both.
I just weighted mine, it’s 31lbs dead which is about the same as the Cotic with those nice american classic wheels on. Agree it doesn’t ride heavy.