Mucky Nuts bender fender on the fork and front crud catcher on your down tube give almost the same protection as an SKS shockboard (but look slightly more ‘cool’), which for me is the standard that all front mud guards should be able to match.
Hmmm looks like mudhugger have basically copied the Muck nuts for all intents and purposes, for there new front mudguards (all mud guards are copied/cloned, so I hardly blame them). Would still suggest it needs a crud catcher to stop mud being flicked straight up, by the back of the front tyre.
PS: Goggles don’t stop your tyres flicking mud and other nasty stuff into your mouth.