0.47% failure rate for MTB frames is incredibly small – but as with any statistics i’d take them all with a pinch of salt
A quick review of my high end MTB frames suggest that I have a 38.4% frame failure rate
This covers 13 frames and the failures occurred on 1 XC bonded steel bike, 2 x lightweight titanium XC bikes and 2 x Lappierre Zesty frames
The stats are further skewed by 3 steel frames with very little use, an alloy fatbike frame with no proper abuse and a very high end German tank of a bike
More interestingly, the cheapest frame i’ve ever had – a Carbon 456 took all manner of abuse over a 2 year period and did not fail – top marks to On-One
I’d much prefer to see Orange’s statistics for 7500 frame failures over a 3 year period
I do ride with a lot of folk with Orange’s and the only failure i have seen is on the swing arm of a Alpine – so i’d say they are pretty good
To me frame failures are just part of biking – hence why i’d only spend top dollar on a frame with a good warranty 🙂