Viewing 40 posts - 1 through 40 (of 47 total)
  • Ebike help (again), battery range is disappointing!
  • Mintyjim
    Full Member

    So I bought a 2018 Trek Powerfly LT on Sunday. I’ve now done two rides .

    First was Gorlech plus the Raven, getting to know the system. I ran tour mode then eco, turned off on the descents and had one bar remaining after 20 miles and 3380 feet of climbing.

    Yesterday was bike park Wales. I did the climb six times only using eco. Off for the descents. 15 miles of climbing, it is a hard, steep climb, and 5600 ft of gain. Again, one bar remaining.

    I think that’s pathetic! My mate gets 40miles off road on his 130mm powerfly FS but it may be considerably less steep where he is.

    I know that there are many factors impacting performance but 15 miles of climbing in eco mode seems weak!

    Any feedback gratefully received!

    martymac
    Full Member

    That doesn’t sound bad to me tbh.

    i have managed 33 miles while still having 40% battery remaining (with around 1400 feet climbing)

    all in eco mode.

    i have also, on the same route, managed to flatten the battery in 14 miles, by leaving it in turbo all the way.

    i weighed 20 stone at the time, and had all my work kit with me, probably 25lb of stuff.

    GeForceJunky
    Full Member

    I’ve found it very much depends on the steepness and total climb. I’ve done 100km with 1400m climb over 5 hours or 15km with 1200m climb over 1.5 hours and used similar amount of battery.

    I’m eco modes you get much further the harder you pedal. In higher power modes it makes less of a difference.

    Mintyjim
    Full Member

    Thanks guys, I guess some perspective helps!

    Both climbs are hard so probably make a massive difference to battery life.

    I could have squeezed in another climb at BPW but I was knackered from chucking a 53lb bike around on the descents!

    colp
    Full Member

    Just got your message mate. Shamefully, I haven’t had a chance to ride mine yet, but I’ll do some testing and update you. I guess physique and fitness will be a factor, I’m about 14.5 stone and reasonably fit but not a big pedaller, mainly into DH.

    thisisnotaspoon
    Free Member

    My OH get’s 30+ miles out of half a charge on her cheap carrera E-bike and I take the piss out of her for not having to pedal hard enough!

    So, erm, pedal harder!

    kayak23
    Full Member

    The reason that if I could afford an ebike, I’d only get one that could piggyback another battery, such as a Focus Jam.

    Doesn’t seem much point having the ebike when you can’t do a decent mileage.

    retro83
    Free Member

    Without wishing to be rude, is your mate carrying less moobage?

    Mintyjim
    Full Member

    Snap colp. I’m 13 stone and more of downhiller too.

    I only pootled up in eco at BPW because I was with a mate who was pedalling. I probably could have pedalled faster and squeezed out some more juice life!

    Mintyjim
    Full Member

    Haha at retro83, quite the opposite, I’m in better shape but we probably weigh the same.

    colp
    Full Member

    Just had a quick blast around the local woods with the dog. No really climbing there but the battery was rattling terribly. Took it out and there was a bolt missing that holds the lock in place, I’d check yours.

    First impressions are that it pedals fine switched off, it’s bloody heavy but keeps great momentum.

    Stock tyres aren’t great.

    I left it mainly in the e-MTB mode which is the auto adjust one I think?

    I’m taking it out to Austria in a few weeks so it’ll get a proper workout there.

    jabbi
    Free Member

    There is a range calculator on the Bosch website.

    https://www.bosch-ebike.com/en/service/range-assistant/

    Just looking at that, there are so many variables that affect the range it’s ridiculous! If you set everything to the worst case you end up with a range of 16km in turbo, 31.4km in eco (E-mtb, performance cx line motor, powertube 500 battery, heavy rider). So if you’re heavy and ride in mountains all the time you’ll have a very different range to someone light who only rides on the flat.

    geex
    Free Member

    ignore distance, it’s climbing that uses most Ebike battery.
    5000ft+ is a good range on one battery no matter how few miles you do it in.
    You’ll get more using eco but where’s the fun in that?

    Your mate almost certainly isn’t climbing as many feet as you are.

    somafunk
    Full Member

    Your battery will take quite a few charge/discharge cycles before it operates at peak efficiency, likewise i imagine your motor will need a few hundred miles on it before it frees up (my bosch cx motor scott egenuis certainly did).

    65kg rider and i used to be able to get round a local route in galloway with 5500ft of climbing and 24 miles with 2/5 bars left on battery using tour/sport

    tjagain
    Full Member

    It also depends on how hard you pedal given that its torque sensing  so say eco mode is + 50%.  If you put out 200 w then the motor is adding 100w, if you put out 50W then the motor is only putting out 25 W

    My record is 8 miles to flatten a 375 watt / hr battery.  I derestricted it and pedalled as hard as I could with it in turbo mode.  Less than 1000ft of climbing as well  I was hitting 40 mph at times and catching some german motorcyclists!  Highly stupid but fun and an experiment I won’t repeat ( Country roads and I was in a hurry)

    I usually get around 30 miles out of it

    angeldust
    Free Member

    What was it about that ‘numpty’ that was doing something illegal by only having 1 brake?

    angeldust
    Free Member

    Sanctimony and hypocracy is a awesome combination 😜

    fishcake
    Free Member

    Two things I have found that have an impact on range is cadence and tyre pressure.

    Low cadence uses more power so you need to maintain a high cadence like 70rpm and above and then lower tyre pressure = more grip / more drag so more power req, a higher tyre pressure will give more range.

    Its a juggling act to get the range but still have the bike handle right.

    Mintyjim
    Full Member

    Great feedback, thanks all.

    It does have massive 2.8 tyres on 40mm rims at about 18 psi so pretty draggy compared to my 2.4 tyres on 26mm rims.

    I’m off to Nant yr Arian today so I’ll try a higher cadence, on the climbs, because I’m cycling alone. I’m quite happy with eco mode and have no interest  in turbo.

    The tyre pressure is perfect for my ability/riding so that stays, maybe things loosen up a bit.

    Despite my range concerns, it is a great bike. I normally have quite negative thoughts when climbing long climbs, as a result of my mind wandering, but for the first time in years my mind stayed clear and positive which was very welcome!

    I wasn’t expecting mental health benefits!

    Thanks again for the feedback and advice.

    Hey colp, I stripped my bike down and torqued/added loctite etc before my first ride so I found it reasonably quiet. Agree about the pedalling, the gearing is superb and, despite the weight, you can pedal pretty easily!

    You aren’t doing bad, from what I’ve read elsewhere, 4 runs at BPW kills it for most. I’ve got a Kenevo and have killed the battery in 18 miles/2500ft. I am 95kgs with kit though

    fishcake
    Free Member

    The other option is buy and carry a spare battery. I have done this, a few people I know have also done this.

    letitreign
    Free Member

    Similar to my OH’s, (his is a Cube with a Bosh battery) roughly a 20 mile ride in the Peaks with around 3500ft climbing used mostly on eco, odd bit of tour and very little turbo and the battery is done in, there’s been a few times where he’s been nipping his butt cheeks wondering if he’ll make it back to the van! lol

    madhouse
    Full Member

    It’s a generic issue that comes with the territory. We’re used to riding our bikes all day but that’s just not possible with the current crop of e-bikes.

    My mate’s got a Spesh e-bike and it’s got their top-end stuff on it (due to tall the warranty replacements – whole other story) but that only manages a 2.5hr ride on the ridgeway – hardly mountainous stuff. So while it’s great that we can ride together, we are somewhat restricted by battery-life rather than legs. Give them a few years and the industry will have something sorted, until then he’ll just have to miss out on the all-day rides.

    Mintyjim
    Full Member

    Well, looks like third time lucky! Messing around at Nant yr Arian today, only using eco again and turning off for the descents…..

    17 miles, 2700 ft climbing and only used one bar!

    I maintained a much higher cadence and turned off power when descending rather than turning off the system, if that makes sense?

    A much more undulating place than the brutal long climb at BPW and clearly more ebike friendly than Brechfa!

    At least I don’t feel like I’ve bought a pup. Still can’t believe how positive and happy I feel after each ride. And guilt free knowing I won’t “need” an enduro motorbike again when my kids leave home!

    Still, roll on battery tech to tease out more miles on the future.

    colp
    Full Member

    Blimey, you’re into enduro motorbikes too?

    My lad and I both have Gas Gas 300 enduros.

    This is getting weird!

    Mintyjim
    Full Member

    Haha, damn, I thought I was unique and awesome!

    sillysilly
    Free Member

    I got 30 mile out the Pivot ebike recently, giving it some proper testing (abuse) along the way. It still had 2 bars left after the ride, prob on the edge of 1. High cadence, not smashing turbo. Wouldn’t want to run out of battery mid ride with the ups I was hitting.

    They seem good for toys early in their product development lifecycle. Next gen will be interesting.

    PeterPoddy
    Free Member

    In all the chat up there ^^ nobody has mentioned battery capacity. 300wh, 400wh, 500wh are roughly the standard sized and you’ll get different ranges from each one. How big are your batteries??

    Specialized now have a hike with a 700wh battery too…..

    Rockhopper
    Free Member

    This has been a useful thread as i was vaguely considering an e bike but as i have range anxiety when my cars fuel gauge drops below 90% full I don’t think the current crop of bikes would be any good for me.  I watched the recent GMBN thing where two of them tackled some pretty epic stuff over two days and that gave the perhaps false impression that they rode for two solid days and just recharged overnight which perhaps wasn’t really the case?

    martymac
    Full Member

    My battery is 400wh.

    blimey, I didn’t realise that anyone did a battery as big as that specialized

    seosamh77
    Free Member

    850wh here, it’s glorious! 😆

    geex
    Free Member

    Heavy AF though I’ll bet

    trail_rat
    Free Member

    My old battery was 910wh.

    Was ludicrously heavy .

    Replaced it with a 700wh as no one needs to be able to ride 150km assisted I figured

    Saved 3kg and a few hundred quid.

    Equally I met a couple of guys from the lakes who rode kingussie to tomintoul via ryvoan all off road slept over night while charging then to braemar then to Blair atholl on third day.

    If you treat it like a motorbike it’ll rip through the power .if you use it as designedthey are fairly conservative.

    Mintyjim
    Full Member

    Mine’s 500wh and if my Nant yr Arian thrash can be replicated elsewhere I’d be quite happy.

    I wanted more miles and smiles for the 2-3 hours I typically do, as I’ve two little children at home and I also want lots of quality time with them.

    geex
    Free Member

    Treat mine like an uplift van.
    Miles are dull (even on an Eeb. smiles as always for me are biggest on the way down where assist is fairly irrelivant.

    trail_rat
    Free Member

    dont be surprised when it rips through the batteries then. just buy another and leave it in the car. swap when it gets tired.

    martymac
    Full Member

    Wow ^^^

    910wh is like 40 miles flat out for me.

    im not sure I could sit on a bike for that long tbh.

    trail_rat
    Free Member

    martymac, mines on a cargo bike. but at a 15mph cut off I’ve ridden it 80km no bother without getting close to a flat battery i find it only kicks in on the climbs. on the flat i was exceeding the 15mph without getting icky.

    mostly the power assist is for when its loaded up with either the weeks shopping or me and the wife going to the pub/a friends etc

    910wH was poor advice from others during the build phase assuming i wanted a motorscooter not a bike with assistance and i guess misjudging my ability as a cyclist also.

    colp
    Full Member

    Treat mine like an uplift van.
    Miles are dull (even on an Eeb. smiles as always for me are biggest on the way down where assist is fairly irrelivant.

    That’s exactly what mine is for. Had a little session today in Delamere on the Old Pale tracks. It’s wicked. On Eco mode, it’s fairly similar to pedalling my Capra up, on tour or higher it’s brilliant, saves my energy for the descents and means I get loads more runs in.

    Downhill it shifts, obviously a bit different to jump etc compared to a regular enduro or DH bike but loads of fun.

    I lowered the tyre pressures on the Nobby Nics and they’ve actually really good on loamy stuff.

    Where it’ll mainly be used in Austria there are charging stations at most mountain restaurants so no worries about range.

    trail_rat
    Free Member

    got rid of the triangle battery now and just waiting on a jumbo shark 14.9Ah to arrive.

Viewing 40 posts - 1 through 40 (of 47 total)

The topic ‘Ebike help (again), battery range is disappointing!’ is closed to new replies.