[Closed] Results from idiet.

Thats an amazing loss ton, congratulations.

Have you got over giving up the bread yet?? 😀

Excellent stuff, keep it up.

scaled, yes mate, bread has been ditched along with all other things i see as carbs.
no rice, pasta, bread.
basically i have just been eating as natural as possible, veg, meat, fish, eggs and a few portions of pulses and nuts and seeds.
i am gonna try and keep it up.
i feel fanatastic on it to be honest.

Tony, any chance you can email me a link to what you can & can't eat on it mate??

nick, will do.

cool. keep it up.

Tony, any chance you can email me a link to what you can & can't eat on it please. My email is in my profile.
Thanks

Thanks Tony.
Email just come through..

Will read up on this tonight.

Cheers mate.

well done keep it up, been trying to get under 131/2 stone for over a year just seem stuck, sorry for asking but can you send me the info also please.

fantastic!! well done mate.

don't expect a stone to come off every week though and just keep at it.

I still think it's snake oil.

Sunflower oil is cheaper.

Nice on ton 😀
I've been going just under 2 weeks and am down 3.5kgs to 90kg and feel better as well. I thought bread would be tricky but I don't miss it at all.
My issue is that I need to be heavier for a sailing championship at the end of May, so I may start going to the gym to get stronger and then try to lose another 4kg in June, not been that light for a looking time.

Excellent news Ton. I started about 6 stone less than you were, and without your other issues but I've been on it since last May and I'm having no trouble sticking to it and finding things to eat which satisfy me.

Long may you keep going.

Ton.

My word !, thats a herculean start.
Excellent, well Done !.

Like you, I see and read the numbers on the scales.
But, in addition to weight loss I actually feel physically better.

I see a few comments regarding bread.
You still have your day off, when anything goes, don't forget.
😉

Good luck Ton

i had my day off yesterday, until 7pm where i started my fast for todays procedure.

my list of sins were,
2 pints of landlord
some roast spuds with lunch
a portion of apple pie and custard

feel as guilty as hell now tho....... 😆

Good luck today.
Bet it'll be over before you know it.

Good work ton. Fell off the iwagon over the weekend but back to the rules today. I do def feel loads better inside with the reduction in carbs. I often find the off day a bit bloated and guilty :$

I went from 120 to 100kg in five months to December, and have been maintaining ever since with a slightly slackarse approach. If i go hard, I start to drop again and my stomach goes all flat which i don't understand.

I say reduction, I mean reduction in certain types ofcarbs 😉

Don't feel guilty about the day off. You NEED the day off to make it work (in the long run). It's part of the diet, not just a treat for doing well.

Losing a stone is impressive though! I lost a couple of kg in the first week.

I must admit though after what, 9 months of doing it to varying degrees of strictness (with a few off patches) my body's response to it is changing so I'm learning and adapting.

You still have your day off, when anything goes, don't forget.

I think I'm re-programmed!

Ton, could you send me the link too. That's a great start and a real confidence booster for you. Good luck with the Op later, hopefully your last.

molgrips, can you tell me a bit more about the changing responses, please?

my gf is on a fitness/health/weight kick (in that order of priority) at the moment and I'm considering suggesting this to her. What's holding me back is a couple of reports of people needing to be stricter and stricter to keep weight from putting weight back on, and being increasing intolerant to high GI carbs. Although they might be a couple of reports, both from you?!

idave, Have you heard much reponse along these lines?

Thanks,

Ed

Althought if the changed response is along the lines of what woody describes, it only sounds like a good thing!

ned - molly lacks the will power to do the iDiet. He finds excuses to eat chocolate. 😉

Different people do respond differently to food types though, and the body adapts to food and exercise in different ways. If I go too far down the iDiet route I crave chocolate/cake/fast-carbs like crazy. Teh other night I ate a whole bag of mini-eggs, 2 creme brules a bag of popcorn and a proper meal without it having any negative impact on my weight. I'm still trying to work out what to eat (in advance) to stop me needing to binge.

yeti, eat a large slice of 'enjoy being a bit hungry' 😉

Kev

I was still hungry. I nearly always am 🙂

ned - not something I'm aware of. get on with it. as an aside, being intolerant to high GI carbs isn't a bad thing considering the fact that they're not exactly beneficial to health.

I was forwarded the info on idiet. I was considering not so much to loose weight but because of all the positive feedback on how much better people feel.

Unfortunately when I read the first thing about breakfast I realised it would be near impossible for me to achieve, as in the morning I have about 5 mins to down 3 weetabix and out of the door 🙁

pretty lame excuse FD. get up 5 mins earlier, or make something the night before?

ok, I've searched the forum, is there more info available somewhere. With all of the "i feel better" comments I might give it a go

Tony, would also appreciate the link.

Cheers
Paul

email me for an up to date version

I also didn't feel particularly well after a day of eating what I used to ie. chips, rice, bread, chocolate, so the 'day off' has been altered to eating only what I really fancy.

pretty lame excuse FD. get up 5 mins earlier, or make something the night before?

I must admit though after what, 9 months of doing it to varying degrees of strictness (with a few off patches) my body's response to it is changing so I'm learning and adapting.

iDave,

I originally thought of this for my gf. Her priorities are fitness>health>weight. She wants to get fitter for ski-touring,eats fairly healthily anyway, wouldn't mind losing a bit of weight.

I'm generally pretty cycle fit, but planning to do a bit more on the run up to the ski touring. I'd like to eat more healthily (she's better at that than me) but no need to lose weight.

Would you suggest any tweaks between her diet and mine, or is it a pretty good catch all diet? Is this your permanent diet? How do you tweak it for training?

Thanks again!

there's a historical link to a google doc. is that the one?

I eat simple carbs during and after intense exercise, or certain sustained sessions. That's my only tweak. And I have my free-for-all day on my hardest training day.

I don't need to lose any weight but still feel better eating this way. Most people seem to, and it 'seems' to lead to an improvement in conditions such as eczema, asthma, high BP, high cholesterol etc.

What's the science behind the iLifestyle? I realise it's 'different' carbs rather than no carbs, but what is the difference, and why?

Genuine curiosity/interest BTW, not trolling or picking a fight.

Could someone be so kind to forward me the details of this diet please?

It's all about reducing the insulin spikes you get if you eat certain foods, I think.

Insulin affects the way your body lays down and uses fat, and a blood sugar dip (result of insulin spike) sets off irresistible cravings for sweet and fatty foods. You don't get these cravings if you're good.

ihn, have a read of "the four hour body" by tim ferriss. It has a similar theme, with some explanations to back it up. as i understand it, it's slow release carbs, and insulin control as mentioned above.

[i]Could someone be so kind to forward me the details of this diet please? [/i]

I think that if you e-mail iDave.
That he will send you a Doc.

If not, then I have [u]an older version[/u] of said document.
( Doesn't look like I am able to distribute the updated document.
In the name of the cause. )

IHN.
Big John is along the right lines.
iDave [b]suggests[/b] that should you avoid eating certain foods.
That you will be able to shed the excess weight.
The OP is a demonstration of this.
The suggestion is simply based on eating foods that elicit a lower insulin response.
Hence [b]Low G[/b]lycemic [b]I[/b]ndex foods form the basis of the iDiet, for 6 days a week.
The foods people eat on iDiet, tend not to elicit such a large insulin response when compared to higher GI foods.
Therefore, eventually.
When on the iDiet, the body produces and stores less fat.

Eating low GI, with a once weekly "day off" has other benefits too.

For example, by cutting out dairy, particularly cheese.
a small patch of Eczema I had, has settled right down now.
I use to [b]Love[/b] cheese. But I haven't had it for so long, I can't remember when I last had some.
Goes to show how much I miss it.
😉

Edit.
I think you'll find that Mr Ferris, for his book, consulted iDave on this very subject.

Cheese isn't really that bad for you though is it? I mean quitting smoking... that makes sense, but cheese??

I think I'd rather just exercise more than give up the chance of another cheese board.

[i]Cheese isn't really that bad for you though is it? I mean quitting smoking... that makes sense, but cheese??

I think I'd rather just exercise more than give up the chance of another cheese board.
[/i]

😆

I'll pretend you haven't read the post properly...

Then you can start another thread about food and our immune systems, yadda.
😉

Oh, and wrt your binging on crap food.
I think it would help newbie / potential iDieters to be aware of the context for [b]your[/b] eating [i]habits[/i]
You know ?, how you're an exercise addict, can't sit still activity junky.
Which is why you can eat all that stuff, not just on your day-off and still maintain your goal weight, or there abouts.
😉

Oh, and wrt your binging on crap food.

Nothing crap about it... Waitrose nicest Creme Brulee and Heston Blumenthingy popcorn.

Most I've done the last couple of weekends is walk to the pub.

Whilst we're throwing the accusations around you are a bit of of an iZealot. I imagine I can go without exercise more easily than you can live without controlling your food?

I'll buy you some cheese after the Cheshire Cat TSY

I'll be getting some fast carbs in 🙂 Fast carbs and cream 🙂

TSY.

Sorry, I'm too tired today and too chuffed for Ton, to argue.

If you're seriously telling me you can't get your iDiet correct.
Then so be it.
The rest of us seem to be doing fine.
Sometimes with a bit of trial and error. Granted.
But the overwhelming majority are getting it right.
😉

Fair enough Solo. I was trying to bait you into writing a long poem-like post on the subject.

FWIW - I don't try and iDiet. Because other healthy diets are available.
Personally I just listen to my body and give it what it's telling me it needs.

Haha... it worked see... look what you've written down there x x

TSY.

I've just read your stealth edit.

[i]iZealot[/i]
😆

Nah, no chance.
iDave doesn't love me anymore.

I'm just intruiged by the whole shebang.
As I've posted before.
I don't claim to be 100% iDiet.
Nor am I 100 % Primal.

But at least I eat what I like and I enjoy what I choose to eat, with no ill effect to my wardrobe and wasitline.
And, without having to [i]burn it off[/i] afterwards.

My goal is to control my weight via my diet.

And to control / improve / tune, my fitness to my activity goals through exercise and training.

I do not exercise to lose weight.
IMO, thats a mugs game and doomed to failure.

molgrips, can you tell me a bit more about the changing responses, please?

Well.. when I started, I did a couple of weeks by the book, and I didn't manage to eat enough carbs via beans and veg. I felt ok but by the end of week 2 I lost the ability to ride my bike at all. Trying to ride to work felt like the worst bonk ever, could hardly pedal. Interestingly, after that treat day it took several days for my legs to recover even though I had two days of simple carbs.

Next thing I tried was really gorging on all the legumes and root veg I could find - better, but still struggled to ride hard.

Then I started upping my simple carb intake around exercise - probably around double the recommendations. This worked for a while but I still struggled to do proper sprint workouts or hard riding, and my weight loss also plateaued.

Then I started to crave carbs more and I would eat 2-3 twixes or cakes during the afternoon in addition to my workout carbs - this really helped, I was able to ride much harder and as a consequence of that I lost another 2kg - the low 80s are pretty hard to shift for me so that's good.

Then I stopped dieting for a couple of weeks due to other factors, and got back on.. then it was really hard to not eat the simple carbs. Really hard.. I would iDiet the same as before for a few days then binge and hate myself. Weight fluctuated a few kg above the minimum.

Then I decided to introduce small amounts of extra simple carbs steadily through the day if I am training a lot, basically searching for balance. Lots of simple carbs (more than the original plan) really seem to help recover from a hard workout and build strength. If I stick to the plan it'll take me 3-4 days to recover, versus overnight if I supplement.

I don't eat starch - mealtimes are as per the plan still. The simple carb supplementation is in the form of a sugar in coffee maybe once in the morning or once in the evening, and/or a cake with the morning coffee. I'm aming not to have exhausted legs, but not to have the bloated feeling from a big meal.

I was up around 87kg for a good few weeks recently but now I'm back to about 85kg fairly easily following the above. Weight loss seems to be dependent on the exercise I do now, and I eat JUST enough simple carbs to support that.

But the overwhelming majority are getting it right.

Don't get too evangelistic Solo. We all have different bodies and do different kinds of exercise. Lots of people have had great success with this, but quite a few on here haven't. One size does not fit all, and don't fall into the trap of thinking people are weak or failures if the iDiet doesn't work for them.

[i]Don't get too evangelistic Solo. We all have different bodies and do different kinds of exercise. Lots of people have had great success with this, but quite a few on here haven't. One size does not fit all, and don't fall into the trap of thinking people are weak or failures if the iDiet doesn't work for them[/i]

Molgrips.
I think you know my stance on the [i]We're not all the same[/i] issue.
Yet at random, the iDiet is effective.
Its not like anyone is [i]selected[/i] to receive the info.
iDave unleashed it on the world, for anyone to try.
Subject to adherence to the rules, as dictated, by your body and the insulin response.

What I fear you are over looknig is what [b]you[/b] choose to do [b]for sport[/b].
And here is the junxaposition.
You're equiped with a body which is the result of millions of years of evolution, suited to a certain way of life and living.

Yet you aspire to participate in activities that didn't even exist 1000 years ago.
So, when you're body doesn't bring you home first across the finish line.
Its the fault of your body ?.

So, the response is to [i]Fuel up[/i] and let fly !.
Well, I say iDiet has still worked for you.
iDiet has now got you thinking in terms of your carbs, simple and complex and you now consume those carbs as you deem appropriate to suit your physical activities.

But your body still produces insulin when there is sugar in the blood. Your body still converts that sugar to fat, if you don't use it.
So in this respect, as much as you may not like it.
You are just the same as me.
😯

I'm not that convinced that 'quite a few' haven't had success with it MG if they follow it as set out - which included carbs during and after exercise.

Different when you get to 12% or so, but up to that point it seems to work for the vast majority.

Is there an opposite to diabetes?

Different when you get to 12% or so,

What we need Molly is some testing!

Well, I say iDiet has still worked for you.

I agree. I think it is a great principle.

So in this respect, as much as you may not like it.
You are just the same as me

Er yes, but in many other respects it appears I'm not 🙂 If I use the sugar, then I need the insulin, don't I?

I'm not that convinced that 'quite a few' haven't had success with it MG

Ok I am thinking of thisisnotaspoon and coffeeking in particular, so to be fair only two people out of dozens who're loving it. Interestingly there are a fair few reports of people who aren't following 100% and still get great results.

I'm not trying to undermine the ideas, all I am saying is that IF you have problems with this style of eating then try tweaking it, don't just give up 🙂

Curious as to how much this 12% ish bodyfat figure varies between people. I'm certainly not near that. At least I don't think so.

To the lab!

iDave...
I'm just starting out down this route, being a biffer.

Couldn't see an email in your profile so wonder if you can just give me a very quick guideline as to when you think simple carbs should kick in..what's your definition of 'intense' exercise, like.

For instance, using Coggan & Allen power zones - tempo/SS upwards about the right point to start adding simple carbys? So if doing 2x1hr z2 commutes per day I just eat more iDave stuff? But if up around SS/FTP I need to scoff some Torq stuff?
How long's a piece of string, and that, but just a nod in the right direction would be fab.
Fanks, like.

Mol - I'm not sure about CK, but from what I've read TINAS is possibly the worst person on here for trying to stick to it! I don't honestly think he's tried at all.

I did though, and it was too hard for me to get the calories in.

Twice the distance from the centre to the end. Hard to say without knowing what you're doing. Could be that you don't need any simple carbs. So many variables.

Alright, ta. Tricky one to pinpoint fo' sure. Trial and error here we go.

Coffeeking seemed to make a good go of it as far as I could tell. But he did have lifestyle/work issues.

AndyP - I am not iDave, but I would point out that during the first two week effort I described above I was mostly trying to commute at base pace ie pretty gently, and I still struggled for carbs.

that doesn't make any sense MG unless you were limiting portions?

i'm doing full on threshold interval sessions - on sat after a 2.5 hour easy ride - with no breakfast before

Ta Molgrips. This is the side of things I always struggle to hit. Not enough = training suffers. Too much = pieman.

Usually hitting 5-6 hours of z2/3 rolling, 2x 2x20s @95-110% FTP and one VO2max session (4 on/4 off x5 @120%FTP) per week ...I imagine the 'work' efforts need some sugary stuff rather than munching on some chickpeas...?

that doesn't make any sense MG unless you were limiting portions?

I found there was a natural limit to portions. I can only physically eat so many beans and veg. I got to the point where I was eating huge portions of bean chili and still feeling hungry, but unable to swallow any more beans.

i'm doing full on threshold interval sessions - on sat after a 2.5 hour easy ride - with no breakfast before

Whenever I've tried early morning workouts pre breakfast, I've utterly failed. Probably for more than one reason though. Not a morning person. One other thing I forgot to mention actually - I switched from eggs and sausage to oaty cereal in Germany and it really helped my morning commute.

[i]i'm doing full on threshold interval sessions - on sat after a 2.5 hour easy ride - with no breakfast before [/i]

Oh ! 😯

Training speak.

Anyone care to decode that for me.
I understood the " no breakfast " part.

So does all the low intensity training aimed to make you more reliant on your fat stores actually work? Can people become more adept at using stored fat... or is it all rubbish and we are all the same?

you can become much better at burning fat as fuel to save stored glycogen but that's not the best way to lose body fat.

which most people get confused about

I think it does work, yes. How far we can go in terms of relying on fat I suspect varies. And I guess it also depends on your training goals.

Solo - I did 2.5 hours easy with Mrs iDave then did 5 x 4 mins at a level to make me puke. I'd not had any breakfast.

[i]One other thing I forgot to mention actually - I switched from eggs and sausage to oaty cereal in Germany and it really helped my morning commute[/i]

So, you were powering your commute on sugar, not body fat.

I thought I was aiming to get my body to run most of the time on fat.
Saving sugar for high intensity, short duration activities.
While avoiding gluconeogenesis
❓

Mol, so what you're telling us is that you cannot eat enough beans to satisfy your hunger so you dive in for some simple carbs. This is what is leading you to remain overweight because you then eat too much of the simple ones ? because it must be impossible to be overweight whilst not eating enough ?

Kev

So is it possible to get the body to burn some excess muscle?

yes, don't eat enough

Time to just go hungry for a few weeks then 🙁

stop lifting weights etc TSY. don't use it and you'll lose it

Mol, so what you're telling us is that you cannot eat enough beans to satisfy your hunger so you dive in for some simple carbs

No, it's nothing to do with hunger, it's to do with training performance.

Hunger has nothing to do with it, that's well under control now. And the amount of simple carbs is strictly controlled. I still have far less than a traditional diet.

And I am now losing weight again.

So, you were powering your commute on sugar, not body fat.

No. Massive oversimplification. Oats is not sugar, for a start; and 20 miles of riding uses up more calories than a bowl of oats.

AND I LOST MORE WEIGHT THAN I DID WHEN WAS EATING THE EGGS AND SAUSAGE. I think you are not really listening to what I am saying...

[i]Solo - I did 2.5 hours easy with Mrs iDave then did 5 x 4 mins at a level to make me puke. I'd not had any breakfast. [/i]

Thanks.

I'm impressed with the 4 mins of Max HR.
Yet alone to repeat five times.
You'd leave me for dust... Maybe.
😉

I can certainly knock out the longer ride at a moderate HR.
First thing in the morning.
When I do, I'm expecting my body is using me lard for fuel.

not max heart rate Solo - that's not possible

just a bloody hard effort for 5 x 4 min, 2 min recovery