[Closed] Filth

I went last night.

Thought it was Shite of the highest order. 😆

The subject matter was sooo far away from my comfort zone that I almost walked out, but I stayed to the end and the best bit was him teetering on the chair, an apt ending before he ruined anyone elses life.

The acting was very good though, some unusual actors playing roles a little left field, which was actually very good to watch.

WOuld I rcommend it? Depends on what aspect of life you like to a)be involved in b)like to understand how the other 20% live and c)if you are bored and an admirer of the lead actor..

Yuk.

Read the book many years ago as i'm a big Irvine Welsh fan

I remember similar comments when Trainspotting came out

Can't wait to see it 🙂

I saw it last night. Similar views to Shibboleth, not sure if I enjoyed it or not. It was certainly one of the more original films I've seen.

Bikebouy, well done for getting a spoiler in there! Maybe edit it for those who haven't seen the film?

A very difficult watch, but strangely compelling. Certainly not a feel-good film but there's no denying the skill of the actors and director to balance a knife-edge like that and create the most complicated characters so believable.

I'm glad I watched it, and I think the fact that I felt compelled to ask others what they thought is testimony to what a powerful film it is...

I hope they've done a good job. The book is one of my favourites.

He was on Chatty Man last Friday and described it very much as shibbo did. You cant help but be drawn in.

They'd have to work very hard to get it wrong.. The book is pretty uncompromising..
I'm reading it again at the moment, and looking forward to the film.. I used to be very offended by some of Welsh's dodgier stuff when I first started reading it..

Surprised by Shibboleth's reaction as I imagined him and Bruce Robertson to be very alike

I haven't seen filth yet, but Welsh did a play a few years ago called you'll have had your hole, this was extremely uncomfortable viewing, if he was trying to shock he achieved it, like so many people I struggled to make my mind up about it!

I definitely want oi see but the mrs will have none of it. Would I be right in thinking I read that book over 10 years ago? Pig in a coppers tit (hat)on the front?

Surprised by Shibboleth's reaction as I imagined him and Bruce Robertson to be very alike

Ironic really, as you remind me of Clifford Blades in so many ways Yunki... I might ring your missus later 😉

😆

eurgh.. I hate it when you make me laugh, I feel violated

Read the book when it came out and much as some of you say above about film, I can't say I enjoyed it but had to finish it. Definitely don't feel the need to see the film despite Mrs B's family knowing James McAvoy quite well and being a big fan.

I admired it but I didn't enjoy it. It's not meant to be an enjoyable film though I don't think. Challenging certainly and McAvoy was amazing, especially considering he was on screen almost 100% of the time.

Erm I never gave anything away.. I stopped precisely where I did for a reason...

Anyhow, you pays yer money, takes yer choice.

As said, acting was very good indeed.

Just not for me that.

Some moments of brilliance with much laughter and other moments of plain wrongness....unsure what to make of it, go make up your own minds 🙂

Saw it tonight.

Extraordinary (in all senses of the word) film. Not sure I've seen anything else quite like it.

Shame it's such a non-mainstream film, as McAvoy's performance deserves accolades that I doubt it will get.

On reflection I think I loved it. Might even be edging into my top 5.

One of my top five favourite reads. Hoarse laughter on one page then raised eyebrow revulsion on the next. Rarely have I been challenged like that in a book, before or since.

I remember going into a bookshop in 1998 (or thereabouts) in full uniform when I was a PC in the Met, asking if they could spare one of their ‘Filth’ promotional posters, which got me a few quizzical looks. I had it framed and it’s currently hung in my spare room.

I struggled with the idea of McAvoy pulling it off as Robertson when I heard he was the lead, so I’m pleased he’s put in a decent performance by the sounds of it. I’ll give it a go at the cinema next week.

… and my profile pic has been the same since joining the forum!

Plus the Daily Fail appears to hate it.

Win win.

I thought, wtf + wow + gritty.

Enjoying in a cinematic kind of way 😀

thought it was a craking film, really laugh out loud at points. I didn't find it overly shocking tbh, but i guess that's down to me being fairly desensitized to welsh and having a fair idea what to expect from him. I've not read filth, well started reading it tonight actually, but i have read trainspotting and the acid house...

I thought it a lot of it was very funny. A bit puzzled that people found it so uncomfortable to watch, but I guess everyone's different!

Sounds like a film that with each watching youll spot/like something else about it.

Seeing some of the comments here, I'm well looking forward to seeing it.

If its really not up your street, there's another Scottish film which may be more your cup of tea........... Sunshine on Leith 😀

I'm trying to organise it so that I see Filth in the afternoon showing, and then straight on to Sunshine on Leith in the evening

A bit puzzled that people found it so uncomfortable to watch, but I guess everyone's different!

I took a date... I found a lot of the sexual references made me squirm a bit! 😯

I'm glad others are reporting back with similar opinions - it's a long time since I've seen a film that's actually made me want to discuss it with others.

The book made my skin crawl in places, the lead character is certainly one of the most unpleasant I've ever come across, but it was good. Not sure if I'd like to see the film version but it would be interesting to see how they handle it.

Ohhhh so it was written by the same bloke that did Trainspotting (right??)
No bloody wonder I didn't like it.

I'll steer clear of "that sort of thing" from now on. 😆

I havent seen it yet but should get to see it this week if i can but reading everybodies comments they make me recall the same commentary about pulp fiction and reservoir dogs, any comparisons in terms of interesting cinematic experience. Both of those seem tame these days but werent on release.

The Tarantino films are 'knowing' and cinematic, whereas I found Filth a much more visceral experience. In that sense I think it's closer to Trainspotting but still a bit more 'direct' than even that.

Saw it this evening. Feeling a little bit mentally ravaged now, think I need a lie down.

I've read the book a couple of times years ago.Not seen the film yet. I wonder how they will get the talking tapeworm into it... Oh and the finer details of Bruce's intimate hygiene and his efforts at DIY grot moviemaking 😯

If the above aren't in the film, then the book is also worth a read, somehow Irvine Welsh still made all that disgusting stuff into a funny book...

Just watched the trailer. Looks amazing

Great Film.

Saw it tonight, Mcavoy is fantastic... Thought it's a bit heavyhanded at times, you don't need the cartoony hallucinations to know he's losing it frinstance. The scene on the stairs in the nick is just heartbreaking.

Not entirely sure about the film, but well worth seeing for the performance.

Watched the TV.... I don't know if I ****ing hated it or loved it.

Saw it at the weekend finally, absolutely brilliant! Not as weird as the book, but still great. Followed it up with pulp fiction, another great one.

Seen it a few weeks ago. Fantastic stuff but yes a little disturbing at times.

I just watched this and have to say I absolutely loved it. Mcavoy is amazing.
The scene with the barristers daughter was a bit disturbing mind but apart from that I loved it.

I watched this recently too. Wasn't impressed to be honest. It wasn't that it was bad, it's just I really love the book. If I'd never had read the book I'd of probably enjoyed it, but as it is I was disappointed.

To me it demonstrates why Danny Boyle is the better film-maker. Trainspotting is equally repugnant yet blissfully entertaining whilst the editing drives it along. With filth as much as I wanted to like it, it just didn't take me along for the ride. Felt like a series of vignettes rather than a whole - to the detriment of the characters.

Yeah filth probably would've been good if I hadn't read the book, but it missed far too many good bits from the book and why change the race of the lad who was murdered?

Anyone else disappointed by this post?

No link or filth?!

Anyone else disappointed by this post?

I was expecting it to be about anti-social council house tenants.