My Wife has tried using Shimano rapid fire left hand shifters before complaining that she didn't have the hand strength to move the lever. She's currently using Sh** Shift (her words) front mech and Rapid fire for the rear, Any girls find the same problem? What else should she try?
new cables - seriously
no shifter should need that much pressure to move unless its neglected.
if its a deore or below front mech check it hasnt siezed - these mechs sieze when you stop looking at them for 5 mins ...
I have the same problem, although only use a right-hand shifter (cables are lubed regularly with in-situ cable oilers) - gets so bad in the winter time that my thumb splits. Reckon I must have seriously weak thumbs 😕 , seriously considering going back to Gripshift this winter.
Think there must be a problem with the shifter or the cable, our girls have been using them from age 4 with no problems [they couldnt twist the twist grips], but have always been looked after
Tracey
I have rapid fire and don't seem to have any problems (left or right), I have small girlie hands also. Second what trail rat said as a first try at sorting the problem.
Ooops, Tracy beat me to it!
Get some XTR cables or keep your current ones well lubed with a decent wet lube, and think about upgrading to XT/XTR rapidfire shifters.
I've got my gf to ratchet it, mind in her case it's not so much strength it's more hand size/travel (she's 4ft 10), so by ratcheting it she can change in little steps, as she just can't reach with one push
Have you made sure it's properly lubed, etc.
(*re gripshift - I've got it on a 2000ish bike, worked fine after being left sitting for 4 years. What's the problem with it ?)
Must be arthritis setting in for me then Tracey 😕 . Bike is stripped down at the mo and I'm singlespeeding but I've been cleaning stuff up today and changed the mounting position on the shifter to see if that helps - also found a narrower cable in the depths of the toolbox so I'll give that a go on the new build.
She's using an XT front mech and Xt cables. Not unfortunatly a Shimano Chainset, an old Suntour one. Could this be the problem?
Divorce her immediately ,
keep the bike ,
then simply test the hand strength of the new future Mrs Mikey-simmo by performing a arm wrestling match with any future date
Simple really
😀
theres nothing as frustrating as a girl with a weak left hand (chortle) 😯
Mamadirt - If you found a narrower cable then it sounds like you were using a brake cable rather than a gear cable, which would make it extremely stiff!
thumbshifter is the answer
still using mine
[url] http://www.flickr.com/photos/rocketdog/3607583335/in/set-72157615716380109/ [/url]
gripshift is the best shifter for LH
[i]GeForce Junky - Member
Mamadirt - If you found a narrower cable then it sounds like you were using a brake cable rather than a gear cable, which would make it extremely stiff![/i]
No, definitely narrower than a brake cable and anyway a brake cable barrel nipple wouldn't fit a shifter. The replacement one is narrower still and is teflon coated so we'll see.
Gear cables come in 1.1 and 1.2mm.
That probably explains it then, although I wouldn't imagine 0.1mm making that much difference 😉
I use thin teflon coated gear cables (teflon as used in non stick frying pans) where they slide like a dream with no lube requied.
Mama try a Sram shifter it will cope better in the mud.
FWIW my hands are actually smaller than my wifes (but a lot more manly) and I have no problem shifting.
I can't change gear with my left hand at all after breaking my thumb last year as I can't lock the joint.
So I just take my hand off the bars and use my palm to push the lever.
It's no big deal now I'm used to it.
I_Ache - MemberMama try a Sram shifter it will cope better in the mud.
Any excuse for more pimpery . . . mmmmmm, orange
[img] 
[/img]
Mount the shifter a bit further inbound? (so she pushes nearer the end - more leverage).
WTFU?
[img] 
[/img]
Aaaaah Mike, and I thought you were going to be talking about your hands!!
Liz's bike had crap levers and cables on for a while which were very hard to move, but with LX levers and new cables they are silky smooth again, so XT stuff should be fine. How long have the cables been on for? And have they been lubed at all during that time? Might be worth looking at fully enclosed cables...
The other option is a gripshift, but then she's obviously not getting on with that either!
How free is the front mech? Does it move smoothly?
Oh, and fancy getting out riding soon?
Yup Nick I'm up for that. Do you have any sundays coming up your free on? BBQ n Stuff too?
Read the OP skimmed the rest.
My GF had the problem on her old bike, and we swapped the deore rapid fire for a grip shifter. But the XT kit with decent cables on her new bike is fine.
Assuming you have nice kit on your bike, give her a shot with those shifters see if it helps.