The shadow mechs are nice and out of the way and they do away with the cable loop at the back. The old style does have a much stronger fixing though – straight into the mech hanger. (SRAM still have this style) The shadow’s is linked to the hanger via a rather flimsy pivoting plate, which will sheer where the old one would have survived…. My recent experience is, if you smack the shadow on something you now lose the mech hanger AND the mech (since this “linkage” part of the shadow mech, which breaks easily, is not replaceable, (naturellement!)) rather than just the hanger. You are less likely to hit it with it being more inboard though…
The SRAM mechs look like they might have replaceable parts – is that the case?
btw: If you’re not dead set on XT, the SLX shadow ones are the same design, only slightly heavier and much cheaper.