In regards to stumpy vs the camber, i haven’t ridden either, just the various reviews, is that the camber and the stumpy essentially ride the same, the camber maybe even slightly better, but the stumpy has get out of jail free travel when stuff gets rowdy.
This could be BS, i’d have to live with both to find out, but my impressions from riding reviews is the stumpy gives you some gains in terms of margin of error on gaps and in the rough but gives up far more in terms of pedalling and engagement in comparison to the camber.
To me, stumpy in 29er guise is equivalent to a 26er enduro of yesteryear, ie an awful lot of bike, which i would like to get away from.
I feel that my BMX style lends itself to shorter travel, ie commitment and precision. Plus life long DJing means i don’t really need help when it comes to jumps.
My spin on that debate.
I was having a think about that pic about what we want vs what we have vs what we should have, and yea had the same comparison with the enduro(wistler/EWS)/stumpy(pacific NW)/camber(UK) and put them into the locations in brackets, came to the realisation im in the UK and that on my Mega TR i hadn’t been tested in a while (though i get more flustered than i feel i should on steep new stuff, but thats comparing myself to fast people who have been MTBing their whole life when ive been doing it 3 years).