Kryton, do you wear gloves? Makes a difference IMO, I go for slightly thicker in the summer because I don’t wear gloves, then winter it’s thinner stuff. I use Fizik but I’ve used other brands, Spec’s stuff is pretty good, but the problem with Spec’s is it’s branded and you can see who make the tape, like that really matters.
I don’t agree with just buying the first thing then stick it on, I’ve used stuff that’s been far too sticky, far too fleece like, far too cork based that chips off, some with the glue on the back that lasts 300ths of a second then peels off, a good tape that fits your hands is well worth the cost and effort to roll it on properly, IMO of course.
Take a look at Fizik then Spesh..