Home Forums Chat Forum Well Miley, when you offered to cover it we didn’t think it would be…

Viewing 40 posts - 1 through 40 (of 75 total)
  • Well Miley, when you offered to cover it we didn’t think it would be…
  • 1
    desperatebicycle
    Full Member

    .. in 3 tons of shit!

    Gawd this is awful. You may think different, but you are silly.

    A great song crapped all over. Thats all 😀

    (from the Talking Heads cover album just released)

    1
    finbar
    Free Member

    I don’t really know who Talking Heads are (were?) but I like Miley Cyrus. Suspect I may be more of the target market for this, I’ll give it a listen later!

    20
    desperatebicycle
    Full Member

    What? Are you 12 ?? 😂

    scotroutes
    Full Member

    I’m a fan of Mileys various cover versions and yet to hear a bad one. This keeps up that trend.

    1
    TiRed
    Full Member

    That is truly awful.

    The live version is breathtaking. Still can’t beat Once in a lifetime though. Please pray tell she hasn’t killed that yet?

    wbo
    Free Member

    I’ve heard worse.  Not my favourite but ….

    Talking Heads made some great songs, and some godawful ones as well, with not much in the middle

    2
    finbar
    Free Member

    What? Are you 12 ?? 😂

    I’m just messing with you 😉 . I do like Miley Cyrus though.

    2
    pk13
    Full Member

    She has some fantastic songs and will go down as a underated performer. I’m no huge fan but you have to give her that, 20 year pop back catalogue is some achievement.

    1
    IHN
    Full Member

    Talking Heads are one of the most hugely revered bands that I just don’t get, so I don’t mind it.

    It’s not as good as Achey Breaky Heart though, I’ll give you that,

    verses
    Full Member
    goldfish24
    Full Member

    I don’t really know who Talking Heads are (were?) but I like Miley Cyrus

    Oh shit, I think I might be old now.

    fasthaggis
    Full Member

    2/10

    I am happy for people to like (and enjoy) dull shit like that though.
    Vive la difference

    tomhoward
    Full Member

    Her cover of Zombie didn’t offend my ears.

    grimep
    Free Member

    I got into Talking Heads a bit late in the mid 80s, had to catch up on the old stuff by the time Naked came out and they split. Saw Byrne touring his Rei Momo album shortly after, and it became an instant favourite. Have replaced old vinyl with CDs.

    So the chances of me clicking the link are less than zero. Is nothing sacred? Is there no perception of artistic merit these days?? I can take about 10 mins of music radio before Alexa is sworn at.

    2
    Tom-B
    Free Member

    I like neither the original nor the cover. Do I win a special prize?

    …I think that I’m with IHN, just don’t get Talking Heads at all.

    1
    Straightliner
    Full Member

    While I’m a bit indifferent about Talking Heads and find Miley’s okay rather than groundbreaking, that really isn’t great. Sounds more like Lady Gaga doing a cover to be honest.

    martinhutch
    Full Member

    It’s alright. I don’t think TH would be expecting either anything groundbreaking or a slavish copy of the original, so I doubt they’d be offended.

    2
    CountZero
    Full Member

    Talking Heads made some great songs, and some godawful ones as well, with not much in the middle

    Care to explain re the godawful ones; enquiring minds want to know.
    I saw the ‘Heads play Swindon Oasis, with Dire Straits as support, on the ‘77 tour. Been a huge fan ever since, along with Byrne’s solo material, particularly ‘My Life In The Bush Of Ghosts’ with Brian Eno, and also Tom Tom Club.

    Saw Byrne on his tour with St Vincent at The Roundhouse, one of the most extraordinary live performances I’ve ever seen.

    2
    tjagain
    Full Member

    How about Kermit covering talking heads?

    leffeboy
    Full Member

    quite good if you like a mashup

    sirromj
    Full Member

    I’m with debz on this one. Milleys version is equivalent to a ten ton bag of shite and ten seconds was more than enough to realise it wasnt for me.The original I only stopped listening to because a rsndom accidental finger gesture refreshed the page.

    1
    Gunz
    Free Member

    What? Are you 12 ??

    What? Did you stop listening to new music in the nineties??

    She’s a talented singer and writer. That TH cover is a bit generic but TH themselves were, shall we say, patchy.

    desperatebicycle
    Full Member

    What? Did you stop listening to new music in the nineties??

    Read me like a book, some people! 😂

    She’s a talented singer and writer. That TH cover is a bit generic but TH themselves were, shall we say, patchy

    A very wise response to a thread about a cover of one song 🤪

    1
    kelvin
    Full Member

    The Stop Making Sense movie version (combined with Heaven) is the one to listen to.

    Don’t mind this cover. It’s not really for me. Some of the other artists on this compilation might do something more interesting though.

    1
    Drac
    Full Member

    Well the original wasn’t one of the good songs, this is a very different take on it.

    1
    IHN
    Full Member

    What? Did you stop listening to new music in the nineties??

    *Raises hand

    desperatebicycle
    Full Member

    Some of the other artists on this compilation might do something more interesting though.

    Not a fan of covers, but yeah some are cool. Lorde’s is good and whoever does Girlfriend Is Better does a good job. Miley might be a selling point for some people though. You know those young, modern types who know a great singer when they hear one (buried in layers of sludgy production crud)

    3
    RustyNissanPrairie
    Full Member

    I have a lot of time for Miley, she rocks out, has some vocal power, exudes confidence and doesn’t seem to have been too damaged by a life in the limelight🤷‍♂️

    I like the Blondie cover she did but I’m not linking to it as it’s too risque for STW old giffers, I also like her jamming Jolene.

    1
    ads678
    Full Member

    I’m not a talking heads fan or a Miley Cyrus fan but think that cover is shite! I think most of her stuff is shite* and I do like the original, so maybe that sways it for me.

    *Not saying she’s a bad singer or owt, just don’t like what she makes generally.

    3
    submarined
    Free Member

    I was appalled when I found out that The Linda Lindas had covered a Talking Heads song, I’m a massive fan and I knew it would be awful.

    Even they couldn’t make Talking Heads bearable.

    Kryton57
    Full Member

    based on the op I don’t like either of the songs fwiw

    seem to have been too damaged by a life in the limelight🤷‍♂️

    She’s had her fair share of drugs and sexual performance / based actions controversy, I started to dislike here when she got all “twerky”, she seemed to be heading all  Pete  Doherty but I think luckily has recovered from that, and since/despite that has a lot of accolades

    I also like her jamming Jolene.

    Her Godmother is Dolly Parton don’t you know.

    Kryton57
    Full Member

    Another cover for us to ponder;

    ThePinkster
    Full Member

    Hmmmm … Well, that was interesting.

    PJM1974
    Free Member

    Miley is pretty talented IMHO, but that sounded way too over-produced for my liking. It’s not as if Miley couldn’t carry it on her own without having force fed it into an autotune machine that surely isn’t needed.

    Anyway, here’s Kesha totally ruining one of my favourite songs from the 1980s. https://youtu.be/w1ClgUGz28g?feature=shared

    joelowden
    Full Member

    Massive Talking Heads fan, have listened to a few tracks off the newly released ” tribute album…….all pretty awful but Paramore’s version of”Burning down the house ” is pretty damn good.
    Feel sorry for all you folks that don’t get their music but , then again, you probably like stuff I don’t get .

    2
    Cougar
    Full Member

    I think I might be old now.

    You’re getting mixed up, that was Tiffany.

    submarined
    Free Member

    @PJM1974 I see your Kei$ha objection on a Miley Cyrus thread, and complete the triangle with the excellent Todd Barrage covering Kei$ha. With a Miley Cyrus ref. [AFI noises]

    pisco
    Full Member

    Miley is talented and has a great voice, I’m always open to a good reinterpretation of a song, but I hate that version of Psycho Killer.

    rakas
    Full Member

    Torreblanca’s cover of it will cleanse thy ears…

    squirrelking
    Free Member

    Paramore’s version of”Burning down the house ” is pretty damn good.

    Meh, Nina Persson did it better. IMO.

Viewing 40 posts - 1 through 40 (of 75 total)

You must be logged in to reply to this topic.