Torque wrench is less than 2 months old.
Means nothing. It spent a while in a container bouncing around the seven seas before it got to the warehouse then the shop. It’ll be close enough for rocknroll with bigger differnces but the jump you’re discussing is miniscule in terms of calibration.
Don’t forget that if you’ve lubed or locktited the bolt threads then you may as well put the torque wrench away unused for all the good it will do you…
I’d agree with go for the bigger number and back off if it feels tight… OR… take advantage of the analogue scale and rebelliously adjust the tool between the two numbers.